8 RPGS That Have Aged Like Milk

by

Role-playing games (RPGs) have consistently produced timeless masterpieces ever since their inception. Notable series such as Final Fantasy, Pokémon, The Elder Scrolls, among others, have stood the test of time for decades and continue to captivate gamers’ hearts even today.

But just because we loved these games back then doesn’t mean they’ve aged well today.

At times, some older games retain outdated design elements and game mechanics that are no longer common in modern gaming. These advancements often encompass essential quality-of-life upgrades. On other occasions, the visual aesthetics of these games appear noticeably outdated compared to contemporary titles.

That doesn’t imply we no longer cherish these RPG classics; it’s simply that, much like a glass of warm milk, they’ve undergone some changes over time.

8. Fallout 3

Live in the Vault, Die in the Vault

Although some might contend that Fallout: New Vegas may not hold up as well over time, it’s worth noting that its writing sets it apart from Fallout 3. In fact, many consider Fallout: New Vegas to be the peak of the Fallout series for a good reason.

Fallout 3, however, lacks the personality and charm of New Vegas to overcome the game’s jank.

In the upgrade of its visual appeal, Bethesda truly excelled in Fallout 4, offering an intriguing post-apocalyptic landscape ripe for discovery. In contrast, Fallout 3 seems a bit uninspiring. Over time, its flaws become increasingly noticeable, hinting at its age and dependence on older technology.

After watching the Fallout TV series, I eagerly anticipated returning to Fallout 3. However, despite initially finding pleasure during my initial playtime (even triggering the explosion in Megaton), I eventually grew disenchanted due to its outdated aesthetic and feel.

7. The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind

Dated Greatness

Regarding antiquated equipment, it’s not surprising that Morrowind doesn’t hold up well over time. In fact, as I pointed out in my review of Avowed, the entire Elder Scrolls series is starting to show its age. While other role-playing games are evolving and improving their gameplay mechanics, the combat in Elder Scrolls is becoming more monotonous.

Indeed, any of the contemporary Elder Scrolls series could fit here. While Skyrim’s main narrative might seem incomplete, Oblivion is predominantly remembered for its limited voice cast (a slight overstatement), but Morrowind’s outdated technology and challenging combat ultimately lead to its downfall.

In the early 2000s, playing Morrowind for the first time was like night and day compared to attempting to navigate it nowadays.

Revisiting Morrowind feels akin to replaying Grand Theft Auto III in 2025, where it takes barely twenty seconds before feelings of irritation set in, compelling you to consider quitting. However, this doesn’t mean the game is poor; we’ve simply become accustomed to more intuitive and convenient gaming experiences in the present day.

6. Mass Effect

The Mako Sucked, And It Still Sucks

A significant challenge when composing the opening chapter of a three-book series lies in devoting much effort to establishing the background and foundations for the subsequent installments. This appears to be the major shortcoming of the narrative in Mass Effect.

In comparison to Mass Effect 2, some believe the sequel stands out due to its more engaging gameplay experience as a key factor.

BioWare intended to evoke a sense of discovery and awe in Mass Effect, yet they didn’t consistently achieve this goal. While you can visit various planets at random and investigate them, not every planet offers something interesting to find. Furthermore, using the Mako vehicle is often unappealing to players.

One significant factor contributing to Mass Effect appearing dated is its core gameplay mechanics. Although Mass Effect offers a decent squad-based cover shooting experience, it’s clear that BioWare was relatively inexperienced in this genre at the time. In contrast, Gears of War, which debuted a year earlier, presents a much more polished cover shooting experience, creating a stark difference in gameplay fluidity between the two titles.

Thankfully, BioWare would learn their lessons and deliver an incredible sequel in Mass Effect 2.

5. Fable

I Need A Hero

Originally, Fable struggled to meet the high standards set by its successor, as it was not able to fully realize the grand expectations placed upon it. I recall watching an advertisement that demonstrated how each decision made would alter the game’s world in a way reminiscent of the Butterfly Effect. For instance, simply stepping on a leaf could trigger a chain reaction of changes throughout the game.

Indeed, the game deviated significantly from what was initially expected. In fact, it offered a compact yet engaging Action Role-Playing Game (RPG) experience, allowing players to explore a wide spectrum of moral choices, ranging from good to evil.

The issue lies in the fact that the encounter seems quite basic. Fable 2, on the other hand, would enhance this and create a more fulfilling experience; however, it’s not even close to what Peter Molyneux had initially suggested we would get.

In contrast to other role-playing games consistently offering dynamic open-world adventures shaped by player choices, Fable has yet to fully meet the ambitious standards set for it.

4. Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean

Cringeworthy Voice Acting

2003 marked a significant milestone for role-playing games (RPGs) on the Nintendo GameCube, with the summer release of Tales of Symphonia, which is often ranked among the top, if not the very best, titles in the Tales series.

Towards the end of the same year, Namco came back with the release of Baten Kaitos: Eternal Wings and the Lost Ocean – an enchanting role-playing game (JRPG) in the turn-based format. This game incorporates aspects from trading-card games into its battle system.

The trailer left a powerful impact worldwide; I vividly recall the buzz on the authentic Nintendo discussion forums back then. We were all thrilled: the narrative seemed captivating, the visuals were impressive, and the voiceovers were top-notch!

Initially, I was taken aback when the game began and the voices were distinctly different from what I had expected. Despite this unexpected twist, the game turned out to be quite enjoyable, though it left me feeling a tinge of disappointment.

Over time, as the quality of role-playing games (like Expedition 33) has significantly improved, Baten Kaitos’ subpar voice acting, illogical plotline, and specialized combat system have led to this vintage game not holding up as well as others.

3. Dragon Age: Origins

A Forgotten Relic Better Left Buried

Though the Dragon Age series has moved away from a more tactical approach, Dragon Age: Origins remains competitive with newer versions such as Mass Effect and Fable, even if they seem to surpass it in certain aspects.

Just as the genre surpassed the level of The Elder Scrolls series, it could be argued that the same growth occurred for Dragon Age: Origins. A specific game supports this notion: Baldur’s Gate 3.

Absolutely! The writing, characters, and narrative in Dragon Age: Origins remain compelling even today, yet to fully appreciate the game, one must be prepared to overlook some dated rough edges.

In contrast to Baldur’s Gate 3, a contemporary role-playing game offering an optimal experience blending strategic battles, another title presents a starkly different atmosphere. The gap between these two games is as wide as that between day and night.

Instead of immediately savoring it as a timeless RPG masterpiece, Dragon Age: Origins might require players to develop a taste for its unique combat elements and recurring gameplay aspects.

2. Final Fantasy

The Greats All Start Somewhere

Today, among the games available, the modern Final Fantasy series titles are visually striking masterpieces. Starting from the initial PS2 release of Final Fantasy X, the visuals were notably distinctive. While the graphics may not have been everlasting, their compelling narratives, captivating characters, and engaging gameplay make it effortless to ignore any flaws in the visual department.

Initially, we have the pioneer Final Fantasy I, which has undergone numerous remakes and upgrades throughout the years. Yet, despite these transformations, its original problems remain unchanged.

In the realm of Japanese Role-Playing Games (JRPG), the Final Fantasy series brought about numerous groundbreaking features such as the job system, unique battle mechanics, well-developed characters, and an immersive narrative. Regrettably, none of these elements can be found in

As someone who enjoys revisiting nostalgic gaming experiences, I’d say Final Fantasy I is perfect for that trip down memory lane, reminding us of the early days when this beloved franchise was first introduced. However, if you’re seeking a more refined old-school Final Fantasy adventure, I’d recommend sticking with either Final Fantasy IV or VI instead.

1. Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow

Gotta Catch ‘Em All!

pokemon-yellow-in-game-screenshot-2.jpg

Back in the day, I was hooked on those original Pokémon games for a good reason – they ignited a worldwide craze that hasn’t fizzled out yet! The way they sucked me in with their irresistible gameplay was truly something special.

It wasn’t only about advancing through the plot, exploring different lands, and rescuing the day. It was also about capturing Pokémon, competing against friends, and striving to be the greatest, surpassing all others in skill.

Despite the many positive aspects of Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow, it’s clear that these games are starting to show their age.

Every time Nintendo remakes these games, I attempt to immerse myself in them as I used to when I was young; however, I usually end up quitting after approximately an hour.

1. Navigating through the lush Viridian Forest can be quite challenging.

2. Finding Charmander utterly ineffective in the initial two gym battles is extremely aggravating.

Exploring the game’s caves, like Mt. Moon, feels just as tiring now as it did when I used to play with my worm light attached to my Game Boy Color many years ago.

Among the best video games I’ve ever played are Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow, yet they no longer hold up as well as they once did. The most recent generations of Pokémon have significantly improved the gaming experience by incorporating valuable improvements in gameplay mechanics, such as making it easier to manage and develop your team.

Read More

2025-04-02 17:11