What if Final Fantasy 14 Never Got A Realm Reborn?

by

Today, Final Fantasy 14 stands as one of the world’s most impactful MMORPGs, a crucial pillar in Square Enix’s financial and cultural success, and possibly one of the most remarkable turnaround tales in gaming. However, this was far from the case in 2010. The initial release of Final Fantasy 14 was marred by technical issues, lackluster content, and puzzling design choices that drove both casual and dedicated players away. The game’s poor performance came close to undermining the very identity of the Final Fantasy franchise itself.

After this point, something astonishing unfolded: Naoki Yoshida was appointed, the initial servers were shut down, and the debut of “Final Fantasy 14: A Realm Reborn“, a complete overhaul that not only rescued the game but elevated it to an industry frontrunner. However, imagine if “A Realm Reborn” had never materialized. Suppose Square Enix had abandoned the project altogether, writing off their losses and allowing “Final Fantasy 14” to decay in disrepute. This hypothetical timeline shows how drastically things could have changed—for the studio, the fans, and the RPG genre.

Without A Realm Reborn, Final Fantasy 14 Would Have Been a Graveyard

Initially, the first version of “Final Fantasy 14” wasn’t just a flop; it served as a warning. Both critics and fans strongly criticized its inefficient performance, absence of an auction house, and bizarre interface decisions, such as requiring numerous menu clicks to equip gear. If “A Realm Reborn” hadn’t been developed, it’s probable that “Final Fantasy 14” would have faded into obscurity within two years. Square Enix might have dismissed it as a failed experiment, without making any serious effort to restore its tarnished image.

If things had turned out differently, the market for Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) games would have taken a distinctly different shape. On consoles, it’s likely that Final Fantasy 14 would have reigned supreme as the leading subscription-based MMORPG, leaving a niche that would have otherwise been largely empty. In such a scenario, players might have held onto titles like The Elder Scrolls Online or shifted their allegiance to PC-centric MMOs such as Guild Wars 2. It’s also plausible that Square Enix could have redirected its efforts towards creating a new online game in the absence of Final Fantasy 14, possibly a multiplayer version of Final Fantasy 16.

Once upon a time, the creative minds behind Final Fantasy 14 contemplated incorporating significant story developments during regular server downtimes. In reality, this approach was utilized for the “End of an Era” event, serving as a dramatic narrative link between that game and A Realm Reborn—an unusual case where a game’s failure was marked by a grand finale instead of a quiet end.

Could Final Fantasy 16 Have Been the Replacement?

If ‘Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn’ hadn’t existed, Square Enix might have chosen ‘Final Fantasy 16’ as its next MMO project instead. In this hypothetical scenario, ‘Final Fantasy 16’ could have been an online game rather than the single-player action RPG it currently is.

Considering the significant financial losses Square Enix incurred with Final Fantasy 14, it’s understandable they might feel compelled to recover these costs. Transforming Final Fantasy 16 into a Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) game could have offered a new beginning under a different title, and the company has history in this area, as Final Fantasy 11 was an MMO before it became trendy. If Final Fantasy 16 had been developed as an MMO, it would probably have adopted a grittier, more realistic tone from the get-go, similar to the darker themes found in the expansions of Final Fantasy 14, such as Endwalker and Heavensward, which delved into topics like death, politics, and redemption.

Speaking of it, transitioning to a new approach could potentially involve considerable risks for Square Enix. Given the criticisms surrounding the linear design of Final Fantasy 13 and the initial struggles of Final Fantasy 14, introducing another online game too swiftly might have eroded fan trust even more deeply.

Naoki Yoshida openly shared in interviews that the creators of Final Fantasy 16 deliberately applied insights from Final Fantasy 14, particularly its global narrative framework and combat system adjustments. If not for the evolution brought about by A Realm Reborn, these valuable lessons might never have been realized.

Without A Realm Reborn, Yoshi-P Might Be Unknown

One intriguing “what if” scenario revolves around Naoki Yoshida himself. Prior to taking on Final Fantasy 14, Yoshi-P was relatively unknown beyond Japan’s borders. His work on Dragon Quest: Monster Battle Road arcade games was solid but not widely recognized. However, Final Fantasy 14: A Realm Reborn marked a significant turning point in his career. This project, which rescued a floundering franchise and catapulted him into an elite group of developers whose influence is on par with the games they produce, became his masterpiece.

It’s plausible that Yoshida might not have risen to the position of Head of Creative Business Unit III or been selected to lead Final Fantasy 16 without the success of Final Fantasy 14: A Realm Reborn. His emphasis on transparency, community input, and live service authenticity are now key aspects of Square Enix’s modern approach, but these attributes were largely shaped by his work on Final Fantasy 14.

The impact of his work transcends just game mechanics; the “Letter from the Producer Live” broadcasts revolutionized Square Enix’s approach to engaging with players. Previously, the company was known for its secrecy, only making announcements after long periods and seldom providing updates until promotional campaigns started. However, Yoshi-P changed this by conversing directly with fans, disclosing spreadsheets, outlining patch plans, and modifying development based on feedback. This shift in strategy was groundbreaking for the company and served as a benchmark that other departments began to follow.

Square Enix’s Financial Future Would Be Very Different

In simpler terms, it’s clear that “Final Fantasy 14” has been a vital lifeline for Square Enix during tough times. While many other live-service games struggled or even failed, “Final Fantasy 14” consistently generated income, even in periods of less new content. The game’s subscriber base has continued to expand over a decade since its reboot, and its expansion packs often exceed expectations. Without this steady financial support, Square Enix might have been more cautious with taking risks.

Instead of investing heavily in mobile monetization or reducing their focus on console gaming development, the company might have chosen a different path. This alternate choice could have potentially deprived fans of beloved games like “Octopath Traveler”, “Triangle Strategy”, and the HD-2D engine that rejuvenated Square Enix’s classic library. Furthermore, without the global presence of “Final Fantasy 14”, Square Enix’s outreach in the west might have diminished, resulting in fewer simultaneous worldwide launches and potential delays in localization.

Instead of having a functional precursor, the approach Square Enix employs in games such as Foamstars and Final Fantasy 7: Ever Crisis, which emphasizes a live-service model, might not have ever existed before. The success of Final Fantasy 14 demonstrated that ongoing updates, active developers, and long-term narrative can transform a live game into a cultural phenomenon by keeping players engaged over time.

Final Fantasy 14 Players Would Have Scattered, Not Settled

MMO enthusiasts have experienced their fair share of letdowns, but Final Fantasy 14 provided a unique form of continuity. After spending years moving from one game to another, numerous gamers found a lasting refuge in Eorzea. The release of A Realm Reborn played a crucial role in creating this sense of belonging that would have been absent otherwise. World of Warcraft might have maintained more of its player base, or games such as Black Desert Online and Lost Ark could have become the go-to options for console gamers.

Beyond the gameplay, there’s also the social dimension to consider. Final Fantasy 14 has transformed into a collective journey in the gaming world, where virtual events like in-game weddings, memorial services for departed players, LGBTQ+ pride parades in Limsa Lominsa, and raid completions streamed by numerous viewers take place. This unique experience fosters a sense of continuity that very few games manage to accomplish. The community, in fact, might not have existed without this game.

In a world without “Final Fantasy 14: A Realm Reborn,” we would be missing out on a forward-thinking game director, a change in corporate transparency, a solid financial foundation, and an enduring virtual haven. Although it’s intriguing to ponder alternate scenarios, this is a reality where the event was necessary – for renewal, reform, and the telling of one of gaming’s greatest stories.

Read More

2025-05-03 03:35