Batman: Arkham Shadow’s Boss Fights Redefine the Arkhamverse Experience

by

In terms of following the footsteps of previous Arkham games, Batman: Arkham Shadow certainly isn’t just a faint echo. Instead, it offers an exceptional gameplay and story experience that is rich in world-building and deep lore within an intriguingly intimate setting like Blackgate. The bosses in this game are inspired by the complex timeline of the Arkhamverse, making them all the more compelling.

In the Arkham series, its villains are a major attraction that set each game apart. It’s intriguing when these antagonists reoccur across multiple games, but this can be both an advantage or a challenge depending on their character progression and the design of their battles. Drawing from the example of Shadow, future Arkham games should think about which villains would work best for boss fights.

Batman: Arkham Shadow’s Bosses are Few Yet Fascinating

In the game titled Batman: Arkham Shadow, there are only three major battles against boss characters: Carmine Falcone, Lyle Bolton, and a shadowy version of Batman created by Dr. Jonathan Crane’s experimental fear toxin. The choice and design of these battles showcase the game’s attention to detail and focus on character depth and development.

The battle against Carmine Falcone, as a boss fight, was long-awaited in the series and it works well because, similar to Penguin, he’s a crime lord who doesn’t show much respect or fear for Batman. He needs to be taught a harsh lesson before he’d provide useful information. Conversely, a battle against a Ratcatcher boss could have been thrilling under different circumstances, but in the story of Shadow, it would have been unnecessary as Otis Flannegan is more of a smart NPC (Non-Player Character) and not a true antagonist.

Lyle Bolton’s battle against the protagonist is impressive as it provides an opportunity for characters like Irving “Matches” Malone to interact with Carmine Falcone. The excitement doubles because players can’t rely on the Batsuit or tools during this confrontation. In addition, Takeo Yamashiro (who is secretly a GCPD cop named Chris Nakano) and Bird are also fought while the protagonist disguises as an inmate at Blackgate. These enemies don’t have special abilities or unique attacks. The Shadow Batman fight stands out because it represents Batman’s first hallucination sequence due to fear toxin, which makes it particularly meaningful and indicative of Bruce Wayne’s internal struggles.

Harvey Dent, who was unwittingly the Rat King for Shadow but transforms into Two-Face just as the game concludes, engaging in a boss battle might have diminished the tragic impact of his multiple personality disorder revelation. Confronting him at the end of Shadow, however, provides a profound climax without compromise.

Consequently, these boss battles resonate deeply, reflecting the central theme of Shadow. Unfortunately, not every Arkham game has managed to create such harmonious battles. Shadow, however, focuses on quality rather than quantity with its bosses. Although a good number of bosses are usually present in a game as expansive as Batman: Arkham Knight, future games should aim to select antagonists based on the potential impact of their battles or key sequences on the unfolding storyline.

Batman’s Arkhamverse Has a Notorious Boss Fight Imbalance

In the Arkhamverse series, which includes games like “Batman: Arkham Asylum”, “Batman: Arkham City”, “Batman: Arkham Origins”, “Batman: Arkham Origins Blackgate”, “Batman: Arkham Shadow”, and “Batman: Arkham Knight”, there have been numerous boss fights featuring both recurring and new antagonists. Some villains, such as Mad Hatter in “Origins”, “City”, and “Knight”, are better showcased through special scenes rather than boss battles. For example, Killer Croc and Scarecrow in “Asylum” are more integrated into the game’s story compared to others. The variety of villains in “City” is diverse because they are all confined within Arkham City, while “Origins” ties eight of its antagonists to the bounty on Batman’s head.

In the game “Asylum”, Bane’s final encounter is an enjoyable blend of mechanics, resembling a typical Titan brute fight, which was one of the few ways to make Bane’s boss battle engaging given that the “Arkham” series was still in its early stages. Bane engages in two boss fights in “Origins”; one at the Royal and another during the second Blackgate riot. The first is reminiscent of his fight in “Asylum”, with Bane acting like a brute enemy once more, although the second phase introduces Venom-powered attacks that make him significantly more menacing. The second encounter, however, stands out distinctly as its second phase features Bane injecting himself with TN-1 and transforming into a massive monster, requiring players to employ stealth tactics against him.

In the game “City“, the boss battle against Mr. Freeze stands out as one of the Arkhamverse’s finest, as it becomes essential to recall those fading stealth takedown techniques.

In the battle against Ra’s al Ghul during the game titled “City“, the fight is grandiose and cinematic as it unfolds through regular stages. However, unexpectedly, Ra’s al Ghul is diminished by his hidden role as the mastermind behind Arkham City and Protocol 10. Ironically, Professor Hugo Strange is exposed as working under Ra’s al Ghul’s command. Shortly after eliminating Strange, Ra’s al Ghul succumbs to death. Both deaths are seemingly inconsequential compared to the larger narrative of Protocol 10, which is abruptly dismissed to pave way for a climax featuring Clayface and Joker. Consequently, the third act becomes somewhat disorienting due to this sudden shift in focus.

In the game Knight, Professor Pyg’s encounter with players is more akin to managing a situation rather than a traditional boss fight. Instead of directly engaging Pyg, players are mostly dealing with Dollotrons and occasionally returning his cleavers. However, when it comes to challenging encounters in Knight, none can be compared to Deathstroke.

In the game Knight, Deathstroke’s boss battle might be considered one of the most impactful in the franchise, serving as a prime illustration of how antagonists should be timed and placed strategically for maximum effect. This particular boss battle essentially transforms the Battle Mode Batmobile combat, with Deathstroke taking over the role of the red-and-white militia’s commander from the Arkham Knight. However, this fight could have been assigned to Simon Stagg’s Cloudburst boss battle or the Arkham Knight’s large drill chase sequence, given its somewhat disappointing ending.

Heating up Ra’s al Ghul’s nachos is similar to some fights against bosses in the game Origins, especially the fight with Deathstroke. The Deathstroke boss fight stands out because it rewards players for successfully parrying multiple times, a feat that can be quite thrilling and dramatic. In fact, there’s an achievement for defeating Deathstroke without ever missing a counter. However, in Knight, Batman easily knocks out Deathstroke as soon as he appears from his tank, which seems to undermine the significance of Deathstroke’s character, not just in Knight, but across the Arkhamverse. This raises the question of whether Deathstroke should have been included in Knight at all.

Some boss characters in a game’s open world might serve as placeholders, but that doesn’t mean they should be poorly designed or inconsistent. Fortunately, future Arkham games can learn from Batman: Arkham Knight, especially if Rocksteady is indeed coming back to the action-adventure style of play.

Read More

2025-03-19 23:38