Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Highlights

  • Characters in One Piece, like Carrot, can receive mixed reception from fans due to unexpected character arcs and conclusions.
  • Gecko Moria lost his powerful reputation due to laziness and annoying personality, leading to his downfall in the series.
  • Sanji’s cool demeanor and strength are overshadowed by his perverted side.

These are five characters from the popular manga and anime series “One Piece,” each with their unique backstory, debuts in manga and anime, and notable traits that make them stand out to fans.


Over the past nearly three decades, Eiichiro Oda has created an extensive cast of characters in “One Piece,” each distinct in design, personality, and significance to the storyline. These characters have been widely appreciated by the show’s fanbase and the public at large, earning them iconic status within the anime and manga worlds.

As a dedicated gamer and avid fan of One Piece, I’ve noticed that some characters in the series have sparked controversy for various reasons. Some criticisms are valid, while others border on the absurd. A few characters, however, have received conflicting reactions from fans. Their portrayals have elicited intense love and hate within the community, making them intriguing figures to follow.

1 Carrot

Given A Confusing Character Arc With An Unsatisfactory Conclusion

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Manga Debut

One Piece Chapter #804 “Adventure in the Land Atop the Elephant’s Back”

Anime Debut

One Piece Episode #753 “A Deadly Elephant Climb – A Great Adventure on the Back of the Giant Elephant!”

Carrot, a green-eyed rabbit hailing from the Mokomo Dukedom, had undergone rigorous training under Pedro as part of the esteemed Kingsbirds and Inuarashi Musketeer Squad. Her innocence belied her potential, and she soon formed a close bond with the Straw Hat Pirates during their stay in Zou. At one point, there were plans for her to become a crew member, but this did not transpire.

Carrot played significant roles during the Whole Cake Island Arc, most notably advancing her connection with Pedro and demonstrating her loyalty as an ally. She showcased immense strength when she transformed into her powerful Sulong form. However, the unexpected turn of events in the Wano Country Arc concluded Carrot’s character development in a surprising manner. The appointment of Carrot as the new ruler of the Mokomo Dukedom by Inuarashi and Nekomushi came as a shock since this decision seemed illogical at that moment.

2 Gecko Moria

Laziness And A Grating Personality Eclipsed His Powerful Devil Fruit

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Manga Debut

One Piece Chapter #449 “The Mysterious Four of Thriller Bark”

Anime Debut

One Piece Episode #343 “His Name is Moria! Trap of the Great Shadow-Stealing Pirate”

As the proud bearer of the formidable Kage Kage no Mi Devil Fruit, I, Gecko Moria, once held the esteemed title of one of the Seven Warlords of the Sea. My position among the strongest pirates in the Grand Line was well-earned. However, my propensity for shunning battles and compelling others to carry out my will left me wanting in combat abilities. Consequently, I became a source of ridicule and doubt among those who questioned my worthiness of maintaining this prestigious title.

I’ve always found it unfortunate how Moria’s borderline annoying personality and the numerous problems during the Thriller Bark Arc tarnished his image. He’s now viewed as a pitiful character by many fans, despite his past significance. After the time skip, Moria was hardly mentioned until he was captured by the Blackbeard Pirates on Hachinosu. It remains to be seen if Moria will regain prominence in the Final Saga.

3 Tony Tony Chopper

Some Adore His Cuteness While Others Struggle To Appreciate It

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Manga Debut

One Piece Chapter #134 “Dr. Kureha”

Anime Debut

One Piece Episode #81 “Are You Happy? The Doctor who is Called a Witch!”

In a fascinating twist, Dr. Tony Tony Chopper of the Straw Hat Pirates is an extraordinary reindeer doctor with remarkable healing abilities. His medical expertise has been pivotal in saving his crewmates numerous times, making the count unimaginable. During both pre-time skip and post-time skip periods, Chopper’s designs were carefully crafted to emphasize his adorable features, significantly contributing to the immense affection he has garnered from fans.

In the Pre-Time Skip era of One Piece, I found Chopper’s struggle to control his powerful Rumble Ball transformations added an intriguing layer to his character development. However, this aspect of his personality became less significant after his training for entering the New World. Nowadays, Chopper is frequently utilized for comedic relief and his role in major battles has waned due to the immense strength of his crewmates.

4 Vinsmoke Sanji

His Cool Demeanor And Strength Are Overshadowed By His Perverted Side

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Manga Debut

One Piece Chapter #43 “Introducing Sanji”

Anime Debut

One Piece Episode #20 “The Famous Cook! Sanji of the Floating Restaurant”

Sanji, a significant member of the Straw Hat Pirates since the East Blue Saga, holds a pivotal role alongside Luffy, Zoro, and Jinbe. Their long-standing rivalry with Zoro has fueled intense arguments among fans, as the two frequently butt heads over their bounties and importance within the crew’s ranks.

Sanji consistently exhibits a cool and collected demeanor in various circumstances, earning comparisons to a clandestine agent due to his polished speech and penchant for donning suits. He is knightly at heart, swiftly responding when women require protection. Unfortunately, his behavior towards females is often far from virtuous, as he harbors a deeply impure side that has been repeatedly criticized as his most glaring flaw.

5 Foxy

A Gag Character Who Starred In One Piece’s Most Polarizing Story Arc

Most Polarizing One Piece Characters

Manga Debut

One Piece Chapter #305 “Foxy the Silver Fox”

Anime Debut

One Piece Episode #207 “Long Ring Long Land’s Big Adventure!”

As a devoted fan of “One Piece,” I can’t help but bring up the intriguing character of Foxy the Silver Fox. His role in the series is undeniably contentious, to put it mildly. He serves as the Captain of the Foxy Pirates and the primary adversary during the Long Ring Long Land Arc. Unfortunately, his influence on the main story of “One Piece” is most notably felt during the Davy Back Fight between the Straw Hat Pirates and his pirate crew. This particular segment, which has left a bitter taste in the memories of many fans, is not typically revisited with fondness within the fan base.

In the pre-time skip era of the story, Foxy served as a comic relief character who brought amusement but also frustration for many. He periodically resurfaced, yet his impact on the plot remained minimal. Some viewers appreciate his presence as a lighthearted contrast between two major narrative arcs, while others believe he hindered the story’s progression and was an unnecessary distraction.

Read More

2024-07-14 16:04