Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley

Highlights

  • Slimejack fish ponds yield valuable Slime Eggs with a 2% chance daily, making them a reliable choice.
  • Spook Fish ponds offer rare Treasure Chests with a 0.4% daily drop rate.
  • Blue Discus ponds produce unique items like Golden Coconuts.

As a seasoned farmer and fisherman in Stardew Valley, I must say that my personal favorite fish to rear in a Fish Pond is none other than the elusive Lava Eel. With its high retail value and the potential for numerous valuable items, it’s truly a game-changer.


In the game Stardew Valley, a Fish Pond is an item that allows for fish breeding. You can keep up to ten fish of any kind in one pond, but you’ll need to accomplish some simple tasks first to reach its full capacity. These ponds serve as farm buildings and are available for purchase from Robin, the local carpenter. Each pond costs 5,000 gold and requires 200 Stones, five pieces of Seaweed, and five Green Algae to construct.

Beyond just facilitating fish breeding, Fish Ponds in games like Stardew Valley can also yield various items depending on the type of fish inside. This can make it hard for players to choose the ideal fish for their ponds, as they might be interested in knowing which species will provide the greatest profit over time. To help all Stardew Valley farmers make informed decisions, here’s a list ranking the top fish for Fish Ponds in Stardew Valley, along with reasons why these fish offer the best return on investment.

8 Slimejack

Best Item: Slime Eggs

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 3 Days
  • Base Price: 100g

Although the Slimejack might not be the most financially rewarding inhabitant for your Fish Pond at first glance, its unique quality of laying Slime Eggs makes it a dependable selection. These eggs can either be hatched into Slimes using a Slime Incubator or sold straight away for 1,000 gold pieces.

Potential Slimejack buyers should keep in mind that the usual item dropped by this fish is the Green Slime Egg. In a Slimejack pond containing nine to ten fish, there’s approximately a 2% chance you’ll find one Green Slime Egg each day.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1 Roe 1-10 18-44%
1 Green Algae 3-10 4-8%
10-50 Sime 9-10 6-15%
1 Green Slime Egg 9-10 1.7-1.9%

7 Spook Fish

Best Item: Treasure Chests

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 4 Days
  • Base Price: 220g

At the Night Market’s Submarine attraction, you can catch Spook Fish. If your goal as a player is to open Treasure Chests every day, the ideal strategy would be to keep Spook Fish in a Fish Pond.

As an ardent gamer, I can’t help but get excited about the prospect of finding those elusive Treasure Chests! They can fetch a whopping 5,000 gold pieces, providing a swift means to skyrocket my earnings. However, these prized chests are hard to come by as each Spook Fish pond only has a slim 0.4% chance of bestowing one per day. Most often, the pond rewards you with Roe, which, unfortunately, isn’t nearly as lucrative as the Treasure Chests.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1 Spook Fish Roe 1 23-95%
1 Treasure Chest 9 0.4%

6 Blue Discus

Best Item: Golden Coconut

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 3 Days
  • Base Price: 120g

The Blue Discus is a beautiful tropical fish found on Ginger Island. It can be caught in freshwater bodies on the Island’s North and West sides during any season. When placed in a Fish Pond on the farm, the Blue Discus reproduces every three days. Additionally, they drop items that can’t be found in Pelican Town – things like Bananas and golden Coconuts.

In a Blue Discus Fish Pond, the most common harvest is usually its specific eggs, or roe. On a daily basis, there’s approximately a 76% chance that you’ll obtain this item. However, there’s also a 4% probability of finding a Golden Coconut instead, which is quite uncommon but highly valuable. If you happen to crack open a Golden Coconut, it might reward you with items such as Golden Walnuts, Banana and Mango Saplings, Pineapple Seeds, Taro Tubers, Mahogany Seeds, Fossilized Skulls, Iridium Ores, and even a Golden Helmet.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1 Blue Discus Roe 1 23-76%
1 Banana 4 5-15%
1 Golden Coconut 9 4%

5 Ice Pip

Best Item: Diamond

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 5 Days
  • Base Price: 500g

In the chilly depths of the Frozen Earth section on Mines Level 60, you’ll find a scarcely found fish species known as Ice Pips. These fish are resilient to extreme cold and simple to catch. Once placed in a Fish Pond, they multiply every five days. Being a precious aquatic life form, each Ice Pip has an initial market value of 500g, which can soar up to 1,000g when they possess the high-quality attribute of iridium.

Successful players might occasionally be awarded free Diamonds by nurturing this particular fish. When the pond’s inhabitants number nine or ten, there’s approximately a 0.7% chance of receiving one each day. Nevertheless, it’s advisable to not solely depend on this item, as it is quite scarce.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1 Blue Ice Pip Roe 1 6-41%
5 Iron Ore 3 4-8%
1-5 Frozen Geode 9 15-15%
5 Frozen Tear 9 6-7%
1 Diamond 9 0.7%

4 Rainbow Trout

Best Item: Prismatic Shard

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 2 Days
  • Base Price: 56g

In the scenic valley, you’ll often spot the vibrant Rainbow Trout swimming in its freshwater habitats. This fish is perfect for your farm’s fishpond in Stardew Valley. You can easily catch them in the sunlit rivers of Pelican Town and Cindersap Forest, as well as the Mountain Lake on summer days. Interestingly, Rainbow Trout reproduce at a rapid pace, approximately every two days, in a Fish Pond.

The most valuable item a Rainbow Trout pond can produce is the Prismatic Shard. However, like other rare drops, it is quite unlikely for the average player to obtain one. The chance of receiving a Prismatic Shard from this pond is just 0.09% per day, which translates to approximately a 10% chance per year.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1 Orange Rainbow Trout Roe 1-8 100%
1 Rainbow Shell 9-10 1.7-1.9%
1 Prismatic Shard 9-10 0.09%

3 Blobfish

Best Item: Pearl

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 4 Days
  • Base Price: 500g

Blobfish, which are uncommon marine beings, can be caught during the submarine ride at the Night Market’s operation hours. Players stand a 10% chance of catching a Blobfish in the submarine between 5 PM and 2 AM.

Keeping Blobfish in Fish Ponds could be a beneficial choice given their rapid reproduction rate, approximately every four days. These creatures are sold at different prices, ranging from 500 grams for common ones to 1000 grams for those of higher quality (iridium-grade). Moreover, they produce valuable goods like:

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1-2 Beige Blobfish Roe 1 21-91%
1 Pearl 9 1.7-1.9%
5 Warp Totem: Farm 9 1.7-1.9%

2 Sturgeon

Best Item: Caviar (Roe)

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 4 Days
  • Base Price: 200g

Sturgeons are fascinating fish that can be caught during summers and winters in The Mountain Lake. They’re quite challenging to catch as these fish are only available on rainy summer days but are the least common during rainy winter days. However, players can purchase them from Krobus’s Shop on Wednesdays for 200g.

Sturgeons reproduce approximately every four days when kept in an aquatic environment such as a fish pond. These fish are prized for their roe, which can be transformed into caviar by storing it in a preserving jar. Caviar is a luxurious delicacy and typically sells for around 500 gold pieces.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1-2 Sturgeon Roe 1 5-84%

1 Lava Eel

Best Item: Roe

Best Fish For Fish Ponds In Stardew Valley
  • Reproduction: Every 5 Days
  • Base Price: 700g

The optimal choice for a Fish Pond is the Lava Eel due to its popularity and high market value, which ranges from 700g for standard quality to 1400g for iridium quality. Lava Eels also have a rapid reproduction rate of every five days and produce valuable items like Spicy Eels and Magma Geodes.

In Stardew Valley, if you’re aiming to find these particular creatures, try exploring the swelteringly hot Floor 100 of the Mines or the Volcano Caldera regardless of the season.

Items Produced Required Population Daily Chance
1-3 Red Lava Eel Roe 1 18-71%
5 Gold Ore 3 4-8%
5 Spicy Eel 9 3-4%
5-10 Magma Geode 9 1.7-3%

Read More

2024-08-18 05:54