Battlefield 6’s Most Immersion-Breaking Features Show Why BF1 is Still King of Immersion

by

Battlefield 6 was a huge release this year, and it’s great that it’s been so well-received. However, it still faces competition from other games in the Battlefield series. Since its launch, Battlefield 6 has been a strong contender against Call of Duty: Black Ops 7, but some of its features don’t quite fit and break the feeling of being fully immersed in the game.

The Battlefield series has faced some challenges recently. After Battlefield 2042 wasn’t well-received, there was a lot of pressure on Battlefield 6. Thankfully, DICE largely returned to what made the series successful. While Battlefield 6 feels more realistic and familiar compared to 2042, it doesn’t quite capture the same immersive and gritty realism that still makes Battlefield 1 so popular, even years later.

Battlefield 6 Has a Few Immersion-Breaking Features That Can Take Players Out of the Experience

  • More experimental skins
  • Unrealistic weapons in REDSEC
  • Floating weapon drops in REDSEC

Some players might find the cosmetic skins in Battlefield 6 distracting and take away from the game’s realism. While not as outlandish as those in Call of Duty, certain skins added to Battlefield 6 have already sparked debate among players. Despite community concerns about maintaining immersion, EA continues to introduce these less realistic cosmetic options.

In Battlefield REDSEC, you have more freedom to experiment with unusual weapons. As the battle royale mode for Battlefield 6, it’s expected that some guns are a bit extreme, but not every player will enjoy that. Two of the most unique weapons are the Rorsch Mk-2 SMRW and the MP-RMG. The Rorsch is a railgun that you charge up before firing, and the MP-RMG is a mini-gun with an incredibly fast firing rate. While rare, finding either of these weapons in a match can be incredibly satisfying, especially compared to typical Battlefield gameplay. However, they’re presented in a way that breaks immersion – they float slightly and are outlined with bright colors – which makes the game feel more like an arcade title than some players might prefer.

Image via EA

While it’s true that Battlefield 6 features some advanced weapons, this fits with its modern setting, and it would be unrealistic to expect everything to feel completely current. The game’s marketing always focused on fast-paced, explosive action, which many FPS players enjoy. However, those hoping for a more realistic experience, or who loved the immersive feel of older Battlefield games, might find this new installment disappointing.

Battlefield 1’s Slower Pace Automatically Brings a Deeper Level of Immersion

Compared to other games in the Battlefield series, Battlefield 6 features noticeably smaller maps. While Battlefield 1 doesn’t always have the biggest maps, its large maps are truly massive, demanding more thoughtful strategy and preparation from players. This greatly increases the feeling of being truly immersed in the game, as it encourages players to slow down and think carefully. This slower pace is a key reason why fans who enjoy a realistic, ‘in the trenches’ experience often prefer Battlefield 1.

Besides its slower speed, Battlefield 1 stands out for having incredibly realistic in-game chatter. Soldiers naturally speak their native languages – English, French, German, or Turkish – and the conversations feel more lively and relevant to what’s happening around you, making the game even more immersive.

Image via EA

Battlefield 6 and Battlefield 1’s All-Time Peak Player Count on Steam

  • Battlefield 6 – 747,440
  • Battlefield 1 – 53,714

Okay, so the player numbers are seriously different. Even though Battlefield 1 is almost ten years old now, it still has a dedicated community! Right now, I’m seeing around 5,000 people playing it on Steam. That’s a big drop compared to Battlefield 6, which has over 112,000 players – huge! But it’s awesome to see so many people still enjoying Battlefield 1 even with the new game out. Battlefield 6 is definitely a really popular shooter, but Battlefield 1 has something special for those of us who love a more realistic experience. It’s all about being grounded and immersed, and that appeals to a lot of players. It’s not for everyone, sure, but the original fans are still totally into it. Battlefield 6 has way more stuff to do and a setting that’s easier for most people to get into, but that doesn’t always grab players the same way.

Is Battlefield 6 or Battlefield 1 the Right Fit for You?

Battlefield 6 Battlefield 1
  • Almost-constant, intense action
  • Set in the late 2020s, so modern weapons and combat
  • Smaller overall map sizes
  • New, so future content and updates will release
  • Slower pace, requiring more strategy
  • Set in World War 1 between 1917-1918, so more historically accurate, low-tech weapons.
  • Larger overall map sizes
  • Nearly 10 years old, so no future updates or content will release

Choosing between Battlefield 6 and Battlefield 1 really comes down to what you prefer. Battlefield 6 offers more content and is visually more impressive, while Battlefield 1 has a unique appeal that many players still enjoy. Even though Battlefield 6 sometimes breaks from complete realism, it generally maintains the series’ reputation for a believable first-person shooter experience. However, if you’re looking for the most immersive experience possible, Battlefield 1 might be a better fit. Both games demonstrate why the Battlefield franchise has remained popular for so long.

Read More

2025-12-04 21:08