The Penguin’s Secret Weapon Is Its Pulpy Tone

The Penguin's Secret Weapon Is Its Pulpy Tone

As a lifelong comic book enthusiast who has seen the highs and lows of adaptations, I must say that “The Penguin” has managed to carve out its own niche in the ever-expanding universe of Batman lore. While it may seem risky to stray too far from the source material, this gritty crime drama feels refreshingly grounded and authentic.


In contrast to typical comic book productions, “The Penguin” series is remarkably distinct. Originating as a spin-off from “Batman,” it blends elements of the comics while significantly deviating from the source material. Showrunner Lauren LeFranc steered clear of stereotypes to craft something more earthy and authentic. This glimpse into Gotham’s underbelly resonates with a tangible, vibrant feel that mirrors the city like never before. Despite being an adaptation, “The Penguin” draws upon a broader spectrum of source material compared to most comic book TV shows. The pulp noir genre serves as a solid foundation, enabling “The Penguin” to stand out from the crowd.

Rearranging the approach too far from the original comic book sources might come across as insincere or even disrespectful to the originals. This could make fans think that a franchise is just trying to exploit a well-known name while belittling the art that made it popular. With such iconic characters as Batman and Superman, there’s a solid case for them occupying a higher echelon of fictional importance. They are cultural giants, and their worlds deserve to be explored from various angles.

The Penguin is a gritty crime drama

ShowrunnerLauren LeFranc
StarsColin Farrell, Cristin Milioti, Rhenzy Feliz, Deirdre O’Connell
Episodes8
Release DateSeptember 19, 2024–November 10, 2024
Streaming OnHBO Max

In the world of Gotham’s underbelly, we find Oz Cobb, a rising criminal figure, striving tirelessly to earn respect within the crime scene as portrayed in Matt Reeves’ “The Batman”. Initially introduced as an enigmatic character, Oz experienced a significant transformation during the film. The events unfolding led to a major upheaval among those above his rank. As the story unfolds, we find Oz navigating through a power shift, grappling with the aftermath of the Riddler’s deadly rampage.

Is The Penguin pulp fiction?

19th century saw the birth of pulp magazines, a trend that persisted till mid-20th century. These publications encompassed diverse tones and genres, yet they were often associated with their sensational themes. Genres like gangster, crime, and detective stories weren’t exclusive, but they were particularly notable. In many ways, “The Penguin” mirrors the conventional pulp magazine story, leaning heavily towards the pulp noir genre, which is more prevalent in visual mediums. Oz shares similarities with the lone hero, a staple of most pulp noir stories. This connection sets “The Penguin” apart from comic book adaptations, while also distinguishing it from other prestige crime dramas.

How does The Penguin stand out?

The Penguin's Secret Weapon Is Its Pulpy Tone

For current reference, The Penguin is often likened to The Sopranos. While the creators haven’t explicitly drawn parallels, critics frequently do. The comparison holds up as both series delve into the criminal underworld from the perspective of a middle-ranking mafia figure with an outdated understanding of their criminal lifestyle. Despite some discrepancies, such as the origin of Penguin’s mother being comic-based, there are numerous valid points of convergence. Watching The Sopranos could indeed provide valuable context for understanding The Penguin better. This series unfolds around a masked serial killer known as the Riddler who detonates a seawall to flood the city, setting its events in motion.

Similar to many Batman tales, they have a boundary as to how realistic they become. After all, it’s a series that revolves around an exaggerated world of criminality and turmoil. It may not reach the level of comic book superheroes, but it fits perfectly in the style of pulp fiction. One defining aspect of pulp literature was its brevity. These were swift, uncomplicated stories that thrived on relentless, sensational action. Oz’s narrative is exactly that – a fast-paced dash through the life of a man who can persuade his way into or out of any situation. There’s no secret identity in this story. Oz’s tale lacks subtlety; it’s raw, grim, and perpetually dark. It diverges from shows like The Sopranos by veering beyond realism and into the territory of classic crime literature.

In a harmonious fashion, “Pulp Fiction” joins other notable references like “The French Connection”, “Scarface”, and numerous decades of “Batman” comics to establish the foundation for the “The Penguin” series. The pulp tales served as precursors to superhero comics, even though no superheroes are present in “The Penguin”. It’s deeply rooted in the same kind of mythology that allows superheroes to thrive. This touch of exaggerated reality gives “The Penguin” the flexibility to transcend comparisons to both the most and least serious works within the genre.

Read More

2024-10-04 21:04