Unlocking Proton Collision Dynamics with a New Multiplicity Model

by

Author: Denis Avetisyan

A novel two-component model, leveraging modified DGLAP evolution and unintegrated PDFs, provides a compelling description of particle production in high-energy proton-proton collisions.

The study reveals the crucial role of gluon dynamics at low momentum fractions in understanding hadronic interactions.

Despite the success of perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics, understanding particle production in high-energy proton-proton collisions remains a complex challenge. This study, ‘Description of Charged\text{-}Particle Multiplicity Distributions in High\text{-}Energy Proton\text{-}Proton Collisions Based on a Two-Component Model and Examination of Parton Distribution Functions’, investigates charged-particle multiplicities using a minimal two-component model driven by modified Dokshitzer-Gribov-Lipatov-Altarelli-Parisi (MD-DGLAP) evolution and unintegrated parton distribution functions. Results demonstrate the model effectively captures experimental data from the ATLAS collaboration, revealing gluon-gluon fusion as the dominant process at \sqrt{s} \ge 900 \text{ GeV}. How do variations in parton distribution function sets impact our understanding of small-$x$ gluon dynamics and ultimately, the fundamental mechanisms governing hadronic collisions?

Probing the Proton: A Collisionist’s Primer

Proton-proton collisions represent a cornerstone of modern particle physics, serving as the primary means of probing the strong interaction – one of the four fundamental forces governing the universe. These collisions, orchestrated at facilities like the Large Hadron Collider, aren’t simply crashes of indivisible particles; they are complex interactions between the quarks and gluons residing within each proton. By meticulously analyzing the debris from these collisions – the newly created particles and their energies – physicists can reconstruct the underlying dynamics of the strong force, described by the theory of Quantum Chromodynamics. Understanding this interaction is vital not only for completing the Standard Model of particle physics, but also for unraveling the structure of matter itself, from the smallest subatomic particles to the largest cosmic structures.

The fundamental interactions governing proton collisions are comprehensively described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), a theory postulating that protons are not elementary particles but composite structures built from elementary constituents called quarks and gluons. These particles interact via the strong force, mediated by the exchange of gluons, and it is this complex interplay that dictates the outcomes of high-energy collisions. QCD predicts that the strong force becomes weaker at shorter distances, a phenomenon known as asymptotic freedom, and explains how quarks and gluons combine to form hadrons, like protons and neutrons. Understanding these interactions, however, requires sophisticated mathematical tools and computational methods due to the inherent complexity of the strong force and the numerous possible configurations of quarks and gluons within a proton – a challenge that continues to drive research in particle physics.

Proton collisions, the cornerstone of high-energy physics experiments, aren’t simply impacts of indivisible particles, but rather interactions between their internal constituents – quarks and gluons. Describing these events with precision necessitates understanding how momentum is distributed among these constituents, a concept formalized through Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs). These PDFs aren’t fixed values; they represent probabilities, detailing the likelihood of finding a quark or gluon carrying a specific fraction of the proton’s total momentum. Crucially, accurate predictions, especially at the energies reached by modern colliders, rely heavily on a precise understanding of the PDFs in the low-momentum, or ‘small x’, region. This is because, at high energies, these low-momentum partons significantly contribute to the collision dynamics, and uncertainties in their distribution directly translate to uncertainties in the predicted collision rates and properties of the resulting particles; therefore, refining these functions remains a central challenge in particle physics.

Beyond the Snapshot: Mapping Transverse Momentum

Traditional Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) describe the probability of finding a parton within a nucleon, but are defined through an integration over the parton’s transverse momentum \vec{k}_T . This integration process inherently loses information about the distribution of partons in the transverse plane. Specifically, PDFs provide only the longitudinal momentum fraction x carried by the parton, and not how that momentum is distributed across different \vec{k}_T values. Consequently, standard PDFs cannot directly predict observables sensitive to transverse momentum, such as those arising in hadron-hadron collisions where the transverse momentum of produced particles is significant. This limitation motivates the development of unintegrated PDFs which preserve the \vec{k}_T dependence.

Unintegrated Parton Distribution Functions (UPDFs) differ from traditional Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) by explicitly maintaining information regarding the transverse momentum k_T of partons within the nucleon. Standard PDFs are obtained through integration over all k_T, effectively losing this crucial momentum component and simplifying the internal nucleon structure. UPDFs, conversely, represent the probability of finding a parton with a specific longitudinal momentum fraction x and a specific transverse momentum k_T. This retention of k_T dependence allows for a more complete and realistic description of high-energy collisions, particularly in processes sensitive to the parton’s transverse momentum, such as hadron production in proton-proton collisions and heavy-quark production.

The Kimber-Martin-Ryskin (KMR) scheme provides a method for generating Unintegrated Parton Distribution Functions (UPDFs) from well-established collinear PDFs by incorporating the effects of transverse momentum. This is achieved through a modified DGLAP evolution equation that accounts for both the usual longitudinal evolution and a new evolution equation in k_T (transverse momentum). The KMR scheme introduces a parameter, typically determined by fitting to experimental data, that governs the initial k_T distribution and controls the strength of the unintegrated gluon distribution at low transverse momenta. Essentially, the scheme postulates a specific initial condition for the unintegrated gluon and evolves it using the DGLAP equations, allowing for the calculation of unintegrated distributions for all partons.

Decoding the Cascade: A Two-Component View of Particle Multiplicity

Charged-particle multiplicity, representing the total number of charged particles created in proton-proton collisions, serves as a fundamental observable in high-energy physics. Its measurement provides critical insights into the underlying dynamics of strong interactions and the subsequent hadronization process. The distribution of these particles, often quantified by its dependence on pseudorapidity η, is particularly informative. Variations in multiplicity, and its pseudorapidity density dN_{ch}/d\eta , are sensitive to the collision energy, impact parameter, and potentially, the presence of new physics phenomena. Precise determination of charged-particle multiplicity is therefore essential for both validating theoretical predictions from Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) and searching for deviations indicative of beyond-the-Standard-Model effects.

The observed charged particle multiplicity in proton-proton collisions is effectively modeled by combining hard and soft processes. Hard gluon-gluon fusion, occurring at higher energy scales, produces a relatively small number of high-p_T particles, contributing to the “jet-like” features of the events. Conversely, soft quark recombination, a process involving the collective emission of low-p_T particles, accounts for the bulk of the produced hadrons. This recombination arises from the color strings created during the collision, fragmenting into numerous particles. The relative contribution of each mechanism varies with collision energy and pseudorapidity, necessitating a combined approach to accurately describe the overall particle production rate and pseudorapidity distribution.

The Two-Component Model explains the observed pseudorapidity density of produced particles by positing that particle production occurs via two distinct processes contributing additively to the final distribution. The “hard” component, arising from gluon-gluon fusion, results in a narrow, centrally located distribution characterized by a lower average particle multiplicity and is well-described by perturbative Quantum Chromodynamics (pQCD). Conversely, the “soft” component, attributed to quark recombination, contributes a broader distribution with a significantly higher average multiplicity, and is effectively modeled using phenomenological approaches. By combining these two components – typically parameterized by their respective average multiplicities and pseudorapidity distributions – the model accurately reproduces the experimentally measured dN/d\eta across a wide range of collision energies and particle types, effectively capturing the overall topology of particle production in proton-proton collisions.

Confirming the Map: Experimental Validation and Future Pathways

Recent analyses of data collected by the ATLAS experiment at the Large Hadron Collider offer compelling validation of the Two-Component Model for parton distribution functions (PDFs). These PDFs, which describe the probability of finding a parton within a proton, are crucial for predicting the outcomes of high-energy particle collisions. The ATLAS data, encompassing a wide range of collision energies and final states, demonstrates a significant level of agreement with predictions derived from the Two-Component Model. This concordance strengthens confidence in the model’s ability to accurately represent the internal structure of protons and provides a robust foundation for future precision measurements in particle physics. The observed alignment between theoretical predictions and experimental results not only validates the underlying assumptions of the model but also underscores the power of collaborative efforts between theoretical and experimental physicists in unraveling the fundamental constituents of matter.

The consistency of Parton Distribution Functions (PDFs) across varying energy scales is paramount in high-energy physics, and is achieved through the application of the MD-DGLAP equations – a set of integro-differential equations describing the evolution of PDFs with respect to the exchanged momentum. These equations, derived from the Dokshitzer-Gribov-Lipatov-Altarelli-Parisi (DGLAP) formalism, effectively account for the radiative corrections arising from the emission of gluons and quarks. By solving these equations, physicists can reliably extrapolate PDF knowledge, initially determined at a specific energy scale-typically from fixed-target experiments-to predict particle interactions occurring at much higher energies, as those probed at the Large Hadron Collider. This evolution process is crucial for maintaining predictive power and ensuring that theoretical calculations accurately reflect experimental observations across the entire energy spectrum, thereby bridging the gap between low- and high-energy measurements.

The success of the Two-Component Model relies not in isolation, but upon a foundation of established parton distribution function (PDF) sets developed by collaborations like CTEQ, MSHT, NNPDF, and HERAPDF. These existing sets served as crucial benchmarks against which the model’s predictions could be validated and refined; however, comparative analysis revealed that the GRV set consistently provided the closest alignment with experimental data. This isn’t to suggest a replacement of these robust existing sets, but rather demonstrates the model’s compatibility with, and enhancement of, current understandings of proton structure. The GRV set’s superior fit indicates a promising synergy, suggesting the Two-Component Model can effectively integrate with, and potentially improve upon, the predictive power of established PDF frameworks, ultimately bolstering confidence in high-energy physics calculations.

The study meticulously dissects the intricacies of high-energy proton-proton collisions, effectively treating the underlying physics as a system ripe for reverse engineering. This approach aligns with a philosophy that views reality as open source – a complex code waiting to be deciphered. As Albert Camus observed, “The struggle itself…is enough to fill a man’s heart. One must imagine Sisyphus happy.” This resonates with the persistent effort to model particle distributions; the iterative refinement of the two-component model, even in the face of complex gluon dynamics and the challenges of unintegrated PDFs, embodies a similar dedication to understanding the fundamental code governing hadronic collisions. The success in describing charged-particle multiplicities isn’t merely a result, but the affirmation of a continuous, necessary struggle.

Beyond Counting: The Road Ahead

The successful application of a two-component model, leveraging modified DGLAP evolution and unintegrated PDFs, to describe charged-particle multiplicities is, predictably, not an ending. Rather, it exposes the inherent inadequacy of treating parton distribution functions as static entities. The model’s strength in the small-x region hints at a more complex gluon dynamics than currently accounted for-a suspicion that demands direct investigation. One anticipates, of course, that further refinement will involve not simply better PDFs, but fundamentally different approaches to their construction-perhaps those embracing non-perturbative effects with a greater degree of honesty.

The true test lies in extrapolation. Will this framework accurately predict multiplicities at energies beyond current collider capabilities? Or will the inevitable deviations reveal deeper, unforeseen physics? Such failures, should they occur, are not defeats, but invitations to dismantle the current structure and rebuild-to probe the limits of the DGLAP framework and, if necessary, to discard it in favor of something truly novel. It is, after all, in the breaking that understanding resides.

Future efforts must address the connection between these multiplicity distributions and the underlying hard process. Treating hadronization as a mere afterthought-a convenient parameterization-is increasingly unsustainable. A complete picture requires a framework where the evolution of the PDFs is intrinsically linked to the formation of the final state particles-a challenge that necessitates a willingness to abandon comfortable approximations and embrace the messy reality of strong interactions.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.16569.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

See also:

2026-01-27 07:40