Starfield Player Points Out Immersion-Breaking Crimson Fleet Issue

Starfield Player Points Out Immersion-Breaking Crimson Fleet Issue

Key Takeaways

  • Players can choose between UC SysDef and the Crimson Fleet in Starfield based on their character’s morality.
  • However, a player has noticed that Crimson Fleet NPCs do not react any differently to players decked out in SysDef gear.
  • While not a major issue, this ocurrence can make the experience less immersive for players.

As a seasoned Starfield player with countless hours under my belt, I must say that the latest observation made by fellow gamer Cleobule has left me scratching my head in disbelief. The Crimson Fleet’s lack of awareness towards players wearing rival faction uniforms is a plot hole that even a blind man could stumble upon.


A Starfield game participant has shared insights about the unorthodox recruiting tactics used by the Crimson Fleet, which seemingly skimp on background checks when enlisting new pirates. More precisely, this user embarked on a covert mission to infiltrate Starfield’s most formidable group of pirates disguised as their sworn adversary, and was taken aback by the response – or lack thereof.

In Starfield, one of the significant decisions players must make is aligning themselves with either UC SysDef or the Crimson Fleet. This choice often boils down to moral considerations. The UC SysDef, a heavily militarized law enforcement agency, represents a government that many in the galaxy perceive as oppressive. Conversely, members of the Crimson Fleet prioritize their personal freedoms, although they are typically lenient towards theft and violence. A significant quest line offers players the opportunity to join the Crimson Fleet while secretly working for UC SysDef. Upon completion, players can choose whether to complete the mission or betray the United Colonies in favor of the pirates.

According to Reddit user Cleobule, it’s astonishingly simple to deceive the Crimson Fleet in the game, which might even be seen as a glaring Starfield plot inconsistency. This player embarked on a covert operation for UC SysDef by embedding themselves within the Crimson Fleet, donning a full UC SysDef uniform. Remarkably, these space pirates, known for their suspicion of almost everyone, didn’t immediately attack the player upon arrival. In fact, it was as if they hadn’t noticed the player had entered a criminal space station disguised as a law enforcement officer. Although amusing, this scenario has sparked criticism from fans who question Bethesda for not incorporating more realistic responses from NPCs when encountering a clear enemy in their midst.

Crimson Fleet’s Lack of Awareness is a Starfield Plot Hole

Apart from UC SysDef equipment, members of the Crimson Fleet also disregard Starfield’s Mantis quest line and its associated rewards, such as the spaceship and armor of the legendary bounty hunter The Mantis. This allows players to embody this character, but one player reported that they were met with complete indifference when they joined the Crimson Fleet dressed as this costumed crime fighter.

In the sprawling universe of Starfield, I’ve dabbled in some cheeky role-playing antics, causing quite a stir with my undercover shenanigans. Fellow gamers have attempted to mimic these stunts, juggling allegiances by taking on missions for one faction while sporting the uniform or armor of an opposing group. One particularly crafty player shared their ingenious strategies to join the Freestar Rangers disguised as a member of The First, an outlaw mercenary crew that usually doesn’t make an appearance outside of Freestar Ranger missions.

Read More

2024-11-11 02:43