Attack on Titan: Would Erwin have Supported Erens Rumbling Plan?

Key Takeaways

Erwin’s calculated ruthlessness may have supported Eren’s Rumbling plan as a strategic deterrent against Marley.
Erwin’s pragmatism and strategic mind could have led to diplomatic solutions rather than Eren’s total destruction.
Erwin’s legacy as a leader suggests he would endorse a tempered Rumbling, using it as a deterrent, not an apocalyptic measure.

As a scholar of human conflict and a dedicated student of history, I find myself deeply intrigued by the hypothetical scenario of Erwin Smith’s involvement in the events of Attack on Titan. With his vast experience as both a soldier and a tactician, Erwin’s presence would undoubtedly have left an indelible mark upon the storyline of this beloved anime.

In the thrilling series “Attack on Titan“, the topics of leadership and morality are intricately linked, with characters often faced with agonizing decisions to ensure their survival. As Marley and the outside world are uncovered, the narrative challenges the characters’ resolve by probing just how far they might go to safeguard humanity. While their approaches differ, figures like Eren and Erwin possess conflicting ideals; they do share a common thread: a willingness to sacrifice everything for an ideal. Unraveling what drives these characters unearths a series of personal and moral crossroads they must navigate.

One fascinating speculation from the series “Attack on Titan” revolves around Erwin Smith’s hypothetical stance on Eren’s controversial Rumbling plan: if he had survived, would he have supported it or not? Throughout the story, Erwin’s strategic brutality was crucial to many of the victories within the walls. The question then arises: does this pragmatism encompass a catastrophic action like the Rumbling? It’s hard to say for sure. This speculation leads us to delve into Erwin’s character, his motives, and how he might react to the threat posed by Marley.

Erwin’s Ideal and Ruthlessness

A Dream Enlightened by the Death of his Father

Attack on Titan: Would Erwin have Supported Erens Rumbling Plan?

Erwin’s adventure started when his father passed away, leaving behind a theory that beyond the city walls lay a place where humans lived. This idea was met with skepticism by both society and the authorities. However, this knowledge sparked an unwavering belief within Erwin to find out if it were true, no matter the personal risk. Unlike many others confined within the city walls, he was certain that somewhere out there, life existed beyond, driving him to expose the hidden truths the public had been kept ignorant of. The enigmatic circumstances surrounding his father’s demise only fueled his resolve to defy the odds and ultimately vindicate his father’s beliefs.

Frequently, he navigated a morally ambiguous zone due to his relentless pursuit of truth. Renowned for his self-sacrifices, Erwin consistently balanced the greater good with his personal aspirations, much like Eren. For Erwin, any risk deemed worthwhile was acceptable, regardless of potential danger to his companions. This ruthless ambition, often questioning ethical boundaries, would eventually mirror Eren’s mentality in confronting the Marleyan threat.

Erwin and Eren’s Mindset

Knowing Sacrifice Is Necessary For Success

Erwin and Eren exhibit an unwavering dedication that drives them tirelessly towards achieving their distinct goals: for Erwin, this meant seeking answers he thought lay beyond the walls; for Eren, it was about safeguarding and liberating Eldians at any expense. Each has been willing to make ethically challenging decisions, which they find justified, though others may view as excessive.

As a gamer, I find myself mirroring Erwin’s unwavering resolve, especially as seen in the later episodes of our beloved series. Unlike Eren, Erwin never resorted to drastic actions like mass murder, but his strategies often required sacrifices that were considered taboo by most people’s moral standards. Considering Erwin’s practical approach, I believe he might view the Rumbling as the less harmful option among two evils, yet it’s hard to predict how far he would go in endorsing such a devastating act.

Would Erwin Have Supported the Rumbling?

A Leader’s Calculations in The Face of Total War

If Erwin had learned about Marley’s role and the oppression of Eldians, he might have chosen a more tactical approach to address this new danger. His thirst for knowledge would have been satisfied upon discovering Marley’s existence; perhaps Erwin’s goals would have shifted towards protecting the Eldians without resorting to complete annihilation. Instead of the Rumbling, he could have devised diplomatic solutions or other methods given his unique ability to perceive situations from an unconventional perspective.

Simultaneously, Erwin was a pragmatist who recognized that the Marleyans had long carried and perpetuated hatred towards Eldians. Given this historical context, while he might have supported the Rumbling as a means to prevent future aggression, he likely did not endorse Eren’s radical plan to annihilate most of mankind. As a result, Erwin likely advocated for a more balanced approach, using the Rumbling more as a bargaining chip rather than an execution strategy.

Erwin’s Reaction to Eren’s Actions

Guiding or Confronting a Former Comrade

In the Rumbling event, Eren’s aggressive actions, driven by his desire to protect Paradis, might have sparked a sense of understanding from Erwin. Perhaps he saw the strategic value in Eren’s abilities to force Marley and other nations into negotiations about their stances. On the other hand, as a strategist, Erwin would likely be opposed to the magnitude of Eren’s plan. Instead, he might have advocated for a more controlled application of Eren’s powers, using them to maintain balance rather than for genocide.

If Erwin strongly disagreed with Eren’s approach, he could have suggested an alternative solution to halt him, given how desperate Eren was when coercing Hanji if she knew a better way. After all, Erwin was aware of the potential moral implications and catastrophic costs associated with total destruction, which could have devastated Paradis. Instead, Erwin might have engaged in negotiations with Eren, proposing a vision that aimed to safeguard Eldians without sacrificing the entire world. Such advice may have diverted Eren’s plans and potentially lessened the impact of the ensuing conflict.

How the outcome could have been changed

Paradis and Eldia Taking a Different Path.

If Erwin had been able to influence Eren, the events in Attack on Titan would likely have taken a different course. Instead of launching into full-scale war, Erwin might have pursued a diplomatic approach, focusing on the shared interests between Paradis and the outside world. With his strategic intellect, Erwin could potentially have found a solution to the current problem and saved Eldia without causing global turmoil. This could have paved the way for peace through a new, more peaceful path.

In a similar vein, imagine if Paradis had to exist side by side with Marley in a state of constant tension, neither party suffering complete destruction. If Erwin had been the leader, he might have prepared Paradis’ defenses and used strategic demonstrations of power to discourage them from stalemated diplomatic situations. This would leave open possibilities for more alliances or mutual understandings to be formed.

The Potential Impact on The Rumbling Plan

A Leader Torn Between Ideals and Realities

Erwin’s leadership style, which was both strategic and idealistic, differed significantly from Eren’s approach to the Marleyan threat. Although they both were ready to take extreme measures, Erwin’s focus on strategy and knowledge might have led him to a less devastating solution. If Erwin had backed Eren, it would have been a cautious approval, intending to use the Rumbling more as a warning than a final catastrophic outcome.

The scenario of Erwin potentially joining the Rumbling raises complexity: if his commitment to practical methods aligns with Eren’s plan, or if his idealistic nature propels him towards a more moderate approach is uncertain. This is a point that fans can only ponder over. However, it’s undeniable that the inclusion of Erwin would significantly impact the plot of Attack on Titan, possibly steering its outcome away from what actually transpired.

2024-11-12 04:35