A Final Fantasy 8 Remake Shouldn’t Be a Totally Faithful Adaptation

by

As a longtime fan of the Final Fantasy series, I’ve seen my fair share of remakes and remasters, each with its own set of challenges and triumphs. The 2019 remaster of Final Fantasy VIII was a step in the right direction, but it left me yearning for more. If Square Enix were to tackle a true remake of this beloved game, they should tread carefully when addressing level scaling and the Junction system.

Square Enix has demonstrated an eagerness to rework their iconic Final Fantasy series, evident in the multi-part remake of Final Fantasy 7. Though fans may yearn for a similar transformation for Final Fantasy 8, as of now, there are no confirmed plans for such a project. However, a remaster was released in 2019, enhancing character designs but leaving background textures somewhat pixelated, resulting in mixed reviews. Should Square Enix eventually undertake a genuine Final Fantasy 8 remake, it’s advisable not to focus solely on recreating the original game, as certain aspects, such as level scaling, could benefit from a fresh perspective.

In the game “Final Fantasy 8”, the concept of level scaling was implemented, but it frequently dampened the player’s enjoyment. This system caused certain enemies to grow stronger as the player advanced in levels, making battles more challenging than necessary and sometimes dissuading players from leveling up. A remake of this game offers an opportunity to rectify this issue, along with other contentious mechanics, while preserving the core spirit of the original game.

Level Scaling in Final Fantasy 8 Needs Reworking

In “Final Fantasy 8”, as the player’s party progressed in levels, so did the strength of the monsters they encountered. Though this principle seems reasonable at first, it unintentionally gave rise to certain problems. Players often discovered that skipping leveling up was a more efficient strategy, instead relying on stat enhancements from Guardian Forces (GFs) and magic junction. This system resulted in boss battles against enemies like Tiamat or the Omega Weapon becoming tougher than necessary if players over-leveled.

One way to rephrase the text could be: “A notorious instance of this is the strange battle with the Tonberry King. If a player meets it at a high stage, its health and damage are substantially higher, making the encounter seem like retribution for leveling up. This design can lead to frustration because players feel penalized for following standard RPG advancement. A potential remake should adjust enemy power so that monsters are tough but not so tough that avoiding battles becomes an attractive option.

Instead of adjusting the challenge dynamically based on the player’s level (full level scaling), we could mix things up by implementing a hybrid system. In this system, some enemies would have a limit on their highest level, or certain boss battles would be designed with fixed difficulty levels. This way, these challenges would remain consistently tough as players progress through the game. By doing so, players would feel rewarded for leveling up, yet still encounter enough difficulty to keep things engaging. Games like Final Fantasy 12 have successfully utilized this method, offering a sense of mastery over enemies while maintaining an appropriate level of challenge.

Final Fantasy 8 Junction System Needs Refinement, Not Replacement

In the world of Final Fantasy 8, the Junction system has sparked debate among players. This system allows characters to acquire magic from enemies, which can then be linked to their stats for enhancements. While some players found this process tiresome, others considered it an integral aspect of the game’s strategic depth. Producer Yoshinori Kitase has expressed a desire to revamp this system if a remake were to happen. As stated in an interview with IGN, Kitase’s primary goal for combat would be to ensure balance and accessibility.

Instead of starting from scratch, we might opt for an improvement on the current Junction System in Final Fantasy 8. One idea is to simplify the magic drawing process by incorporating an automatic drawing mechanism that optimizes storage of magical energy. While players would still have the freedom to adjust stats via magic junctioning, the tedious aspects of the original system’s grinding would be minimized. This approach preserves the essence of customization within Final Fantasy 8’s Junction System while making it more appealing to today’s gamers.

Changes might involve limiting the amount of magic a player can summon before reaching their maximum limit, or offering alternative methods to acquire magic, such as crafting or synthesis. This strategy would maintain the fundamental idea of the original system while eliminating the annoyances that frequently irritated players. Reminiscent of changes made in the Final Fantasy Pixel Remaster series, where players received new options like battle speed adjustments and encounter toggles.

The concept of blending accessibility and complexity might find its muse in contemporary RPGs such as “Persona 5 Royal,” where mechanics were developed further, yet always retained their unique essence. Adopting Kitase’s method could breathe fresh life into the combat system of “Final Fantasy 8” while maintaining respect for the significant influence of the Junction system.

Not Too Faithful, Not Too Radical Final Fantasy 8 Remake

Striking a balance between preserving originality and introducing new elements can be tricky. The Final Fantasy 7 Remake took a strong lean towards reinvention, featuring significant narrative modifications and altered character journeys. On the other hand, whispers hint at Final Fantasy 9’s potential remake being more faithful to the original. As for Final Fantasy 8, neither extreme approach seems perfect.

Adhering too strictly to the original version might retain issues such as blurry backdrops, awkward level progression, and excessive repetition in the Junction system. Conversely, a total revamp like that seen in the Final Fantasy 7 Remake could spark controversy if changes are made to cherished narrative aspects or characters. A more balanced strategy would be to enhance the game’s graphics, optimize its systems, and incorporate user-friendly updates, all while preserving the essence of the original.

Read More

2024-12-11 00:24