9 Indie Game Flops That Deserve A Second Chance

As a seasoned gamer with over two decades under my belt, I find myself constantly seeking out the underrated and overlooked treasures that the gaming world has to offer. And, boy, have I stumbled upon some real gems in this list!

Since Atari’s 1972 hit Pong, games have had the chance to become cultural icons. You only need to look as far as Fortnite’s in-game concerts, celebrity collaborations, and viral dance moves on TikTok to realize that some games just have that it-factor.

Additionally, some games fail to connect, either because they fall short of expectations or require a bit of time before their appeal becomes apparent.

Regardless of whether a game flops because its narrative is unclear, its mechanics are odd, or its concept is too daring for the current market, many independent games end up overlooked and undervalued despite their potential merits.

This list honors lesser-known independent games that may not have achieved their full potential initially, but still possess a hidden brilliance, deserving of a second look and a new opportunity to captivate players.

9. Back To Bed

Quirky, Puzzling, Surreal

As a gamer, I can tell you that “Back to Bed” is like diving into my own dream world. Some people have criticized it for being more about the aesthetics of dreamscapes than offering deep gameplay mechanics. But let me tell you, this surreal adventure is worth giving a try to become one of the best indie cozy games out there.

In this game, you take on the role of a canine-shaped entity known as Subob. Your purpose is to lead a character called Bob, who is sleepwalking, through a dreamscape reminiscent of Salvador Dali’s surreal art. Along the way, you’ll need to solve various mind-twisting puzzles.

Clearly implied by its title, it’s essential to return Bob to his bed, before he encounters odd dream-world perils that might lead to a physical altercation.

Regardless of the criticisms, playing this game just once reveals such an unusual and charmingly surprising experience that it warrants a bit more appreciation.

As a gaming enthusiast, I can’t help but share my excitement about this intriguing game where the objective is clear, yet mastering it requires a few attempts to see Bob plummet. It’s hilarious, in an unexpectedly entertaining way, to watch Subob strut around with a gigantic apple on its hind legs. So, if you’re up for a challenge and a good chuckle, this game should be your next adventure!

8. Enchanted Portal

Cuphead? Is That You?

In most fantasy stories, enchanted portals serve as exciting entries to realms filled with mystery, excitement, and exploration. However, when it comes to these enchanted portals in the game, they lead to rather uninspiring gameplay experiences.

In this reimagined setting, Mystic Gates whisk you away to a mystical land filled with riddles and encounters with enchanting beings. Your quest is to protect the realm from the malevolent sorcerer Dovus, adding an intriguing twist to a captivating universe. It’s a fascinating premise that boasts a strong foundation.

However, it’s essential to understand that this isn’t similar to Cuphead, despite the resemblance. It falls short, acting as a less effective imitation. Still, I find myself hoping that with another opportunity, the creators might develop a cooperative adventure reminiscent of Cuphead, which could be priceless if done right.

In this case, the issue at hand revolved around insufficient originality and distinctness, coupled with subpar control mechanisms. However, its lively, fantastical ambiance is so captivating that it’s definitely worth delving into – particularly for enthusiasts of contemporary indie games inspired by retro styles.

7. CARRION

You’re The Monster Now

If you’ve ever found yourself playing a horror game and thinking, “Couldn’t things be simpler if I were the one doing the chasing instead?” – then indeed, that could be the case! The game CARRION demonstrates this by putting you in the role of the terrifying monster.

In a research lab, you find yourself as a shape-shifting extraterrestrial being. Your primary objectives are break free from confinement, satisfy your hunger, and continuously develop and grow.

This game seems familiar to many others, but this time around, instead of being a victim, you are the aggressor. Instead of survival for basic needs, your actions are more about deliberate demolition when it comes to escaping.

In simpler terms, “Carrion” received mixed feedback from critics and had a challenging reception within the Metroidvania community because its map layout can make navigating confusing, which often disrupts the game’s intended fast-paced destruction experience.

However, such a unique premise, grotesque level design, and fluid movement are enough for this modern indie horror game to warrant more attention.

6. Rain World

Tough-As-Nails Survival Platformer

Although the main character is adorable, it’s a demanding survival platformer with a merciless edge. It masterfully combines tough gameplay mechanics and immersive storytelling through its environment, but unfortunately, it hasn’t received the acclaim that the Slugcat should have earned.

In the game Rain World, a Slugcat represents the character you control. You are a solitary creature who has been torn away from your kin, navigating through a treacherous world filled with deep waters and hazardous predators, striving to survive.

Initially, Rain World faced criticism upon its release due to its high level of difficulty and inaccessibility, which left some critics struggling to understand and enjoy the game. As a result, they often dismissed it as a poorly designed platformer or a disorganized Metroidvania.

Yet, Rain World isn’t just about surviving; it’s a game with layers of complexity. Persist in its challenging environment, and you’ll eventually uncover all the wonders it has in store.

This game isn’t planning to create a list of top-tier platformers any time soon, but its distinctive features – the immersive setting, captivating storyline, and three distinct game modes (Survivor, Predator, and Monk) – make it stand out enough that it warrants an opportunity to prove itself on its own merits.

5. Griftlands

Balatro Meets Subsurface Circular Meets Tekken

In simpler terms, Griftlands is a role-playing game that combines deck construction with elements of noir storytelling. You’ll choose among three characters and navigate through missions using strategies like political maneuvering, deceitful tactics, and diplomatic negotiations.

Pick your course – mercenary, felon, or statesman. Each choice influences how events unfold, whether it’s discussions or conflicts, played out as card games that may result in victory or catastrophe. If you enjoy strategy and mechanics involving cards, explore some top-tier deck-building games for similar experiences.

Despite its popularity among some, I understand why others might find it hard to connect with it. The initial phase is somewhat slow-paced due to an abundance of character introductions prior to the first fight. Additionally, this game offers fewer options in terms of cards compared to other deck-building games you might be accustomed to.

With some patience, you’ll find that the storyline in this card game is exceptionally detailed, ranking among the richest narratives I’ve encountered in deck-building games. The dual-deck mechanism, which divides combat and negotiation, is an innovative approach worth exploring.

In the start menu, you have the option to turn off permanent death, which allows you to concentrate more on the storyline without encountering additional challenges.

4. The Swords of Ditto

Bite-Sized Action RPG

If you enjoy old-school roguelikes and dungeon explorations, check out The Swords of Ditto. It’s a whimsical, vibrant action RPG that didn’t quite reach the masses. Its adorable graphics and high replay value might leave you puzzled as to why it didn’t gain more popularity.

When the most recent hero, known as the Sword of Ditto, dies in combat, you’ll have to take up his mantle and sword, thus transforming into – here it comes – the new Sword of Ditto. One hero perishes, another takes birth, but with each demise, the world is reborn anew.

Some people criticize the gameplay as being repetitive, but isn’t that the essence of a grind-heavy roguelike? After all, Hades, which shares this characteristic, has garnered numerous Game of the Year awards.

1) The quirky art design and innovative take on traditional roguelike aspects truly set it apart. Plus, not many games let you traverse using a flying kazoo!

3. Eternal Threads

A Crash Course In The Butterfly Effect

As a captivated onlooker, I find myself drawn into the tumultuous wake of a devastating house blaze in Eternal Threads. The game compels me to employ the power of temporal manipulation, a unique gift that allows me to revisit the critical moments in the lives of six individuals and alter their fateful choices, ultimately sparing them from the jaws of danger.

The narrative held my attention as each decision seemed significant, yet discovering the crucial turning points proved to be the real puzzle.

Despite some critics labeling it as generic or lacking in ambition, my opinion varies greatly. In an instant upon starting to play, I found myself immersed in a profoundly thought-provoking moment – navigating through time, modifying the past, and sculpting the future.

This type of interactive storytelling is one that truly shines when approached with a specific perspective. For those who are captivated by the interplay of cause and effect, they may discover within it an inventiveness reminiscent of some exceptional time travel game designs.

Eternal Threads, perhaps, didn’t receive much mainstream recognition, possibly because of its more leisurely tempo and emphasis on repetition. Yet, it has a dedicated fanbase who value the game’s complex narrative. If the concept appeals to you, it might be worth giving it another try.

2. Ghost Master

Become A Diabolical Puppeteer

In a unique twist, Ghost Master switches the conventional ghost-hunting tale, placing you as the controller of the spirits instead. Your role is to terrify the wits out of unwitting humans through tactical placement of your ghostly minions and orchestrating pandemonium.

Despite the fact that its distinctive concept and offbeat humor resonated strongly with a specific group of fans, Ghost Master failed to achieve widespread popularity in the mainstream market.

Despite some people pointing out its rough mechanics and need for refinement, there’s no denying that Ghost Master stands out with its unique allure and freshness.

Originating back in 2003, this game showcases an unparalleled approach to the ghostly strategy genre that remains distinctive. Given its enduring appeal, it’s high time for a modernized version to cultivate a new fan base, much like The Sims 2 and 3 have sustained their dedicated player communities over the years.

1. Yooka-Laylee

Not Banjo, But Close

Yooka-Laylee was marketed as the spiritual sequel to Banjo-Kazooie, but it fell short of the lofty expectations set for it. Nevertheless, its colorful setting, eccentric characters, and nostalgic allure are appealing to enthusiasts of popular 3D platformers.

Indeed, the gameplay does have a tendency to feel somewhat repetitive, and the controls can be a bit tricky for precise movements, but there’s an undeniable charm in Yooka and Laylee’s journey. Given some polish, it could have easily matched the classics that inspired it.

Hey fellow gaming enthusiast! If you’re drawn towards vibrant, joyous adventures that are anything but ordinary, then let’s not let naysayers deter us – Yooka-Laylee is a world filled with enchantment all its own.

2024-12-12 18:39