Dexter: Original Sin Casting Shuts Down Shared Universe Fan Theory

by

Summary

  • “Dexter: Original Sin” debunks the shared universe theory between Dexter and Buffy due to Gellar’s distinct role.
  • The Doublemeat Palace hint was a red herring for a crossover between Dexter and Buffy.
  • Actress Julie Benz was in both Buffy and Dexter, realistically ending the potential for crossovers, but Gellar’s role ends the theory officially.

As a dedicated enthusiast, I’m thrilled that Dexter: Original Sin has finally arrived! Now, we get to delve deeper into the world of our beloved anti-hero, Dexter Morgan, exploring not just his personal life but also the expansive universe that intertwines with his existence. This includes his relationships with the people he interacts with professionally and personally.

What’s more, it appears that one of the most captivating fan theories has been laid to rest – the theory that Dexter’s Miami and Buffy’s Sunnydale might exist within the same universe. For years, fans of Dexter and Buffy the Vampire Slayer have pondered over this intriguing possibility, imagining a world where these two iconic series could coexist, enriching their dark humor and potentially supernatural elements.

As a devoted film enthusiast, I’ve always cherished the idea that Sarah Michelle Gellar’s roles might somehow intertwine across different productions, particularly Buffy and Dexter. However, with her appearance in the revival of Dexter: Original Sin, it appears this theory has reached its end. Instead of reprising her iconic role as Buffy, she steps into a new character – Dexter’s boss. This clear departure from her previous roles effectively shatters the notion of a shared universe between these two captivating series. It’s not about Buffy adopting an alias this time; it’s a completely fresh character. This decision seems more like a nod to the dedicated fanbases of both shows, celebrating their shared love for these stories, rather than weaving a narrative bridge between them. The debunking of this theory serves as a testament to the vibrant and imaginative communities that have grown around these remarkable series, constantly seeking connections in their favorite tales.

Dexter & Buffy’s Shared Universe Theory Explained

By a subtle connection spotted by dedicated fans of both series, there’s a possibility that the worlds of “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” and “Dexter” might overlap. Both shows feature a fast food chain called Doublemeat Palace – Buffy started working at one in “Buffy” season 6, while Dexter’s character, Angel Batista, consumed Doublemeat burgers in season 1. Since this fast food chain doesn’t exist in reality or any other fictional universes, it seems to be a hint that these shows might share the same universe. Interestingly, restaurants often serve as clues when multiple shows take place in the same universe. For instance, the Arrowverse frequently used Big Belly Burger as a reference across its shows by mentioning characters eating there. It appears that the writers of both “Buffy” and “Dexter” may have employed this gag to some extent, although it seems more like a nod rather than a clear indication of a shared universe.

Beyond the connections within the series themselves, writer Drew Z. Greenberg may have subtly hinted at potential crossovers, although these never materialized. For such a crossover to be possible, there had to be supernatural elements in the story of Dexter. However, Dexter, airing on Showtime, did not feature vampires or monsters. Similarly, it’s highly unlikely that we’ll see any supernatural elements in Original Sin. Despite this, some fans still hoped for a surprise twist involving the Doublemeat Palace from Dexter, perhaps leading to an unconventional killer being revealed.

The Two Shows Offer More Unofficial Crossovers

As a movie enthusiast, I can’t help but be thrilled about Sarah Michelle Gellar joining the “Dexter” universe! This move signifies that not one, but two actresses with significant roles are now part of an expanding franchise – both having made their mark in the “Buffy the Vampire Slayer” realm. Julie Benz, who once portrayed Darla, will also be a key figure here. In the world of “Buffy,” Darla was more than just a thorn in the side of our titular slayer; she was a recurring adversary. Later, Darla became a persistent challenge for Angel when he transitioned from Sunnydale to Los Angeles.

Dexter: Original Sin
Creator Clyde Phillips
Showrunner Clyde Phillips
Starring
  • Patrick Gibson
  • Christian Slater
  • Molly Brown
  • Christina Milian
  • James Martinez
  • Alex Shimizu
  • Reno Wilson
  • Patrick Dempsey
  • Michael C. Hall

In the television series “Dexter,” actress Jennifer Carpenter portrayed Rita, the romantic interest of the protagonist, a serial killer named Dexter. The presence of Rita in the storyline suggests that there is no common universe between this show and others. However, dedicated fans of the show might argue that some enchantment or spell could have made Rita forget her past as Darla.

It appears undeniable that Sarah Michelle Gellar joining Dexter: Original Sin effectively debunks most fan theories of a crossover, except for those particularly imaginative fans who might stretch their thinking abilities considerably. For such enthusiasts, it remains theoretically possible that her character could unexpectedly deliver a speech revealing the existence of vampires and her past as a slayer. However, given her involvement in the new series, this scenario seems highly improbable at best.

Read More

2025-01-09 06:03