What If Eren Chose Peace Over Conflict in Attack on Titan’s Final Act?

by

Summary

  • Eren’s decisions in Attack on Titan led to the catastrophic Rumbling and a moral conundrum for fans.
  • Alternate scenarios explore what could have happened if Eren chose peace over violence, with repercussions.
  • Eren’s extreme actions to protect Paradis Island highlight the complexities of seeking peace in a hostile world.

In a unique and intricate exploration of morality, it’s the story of Attack on Titan that captures attention, with its labyrinthine plots and protagonist, Eren Yeager. The choices made by Eren in the climax of this narrative ultimately ignited the Rumbling, a destructive act intended to eliminate humanity beyond Paradis Island. This mass slaughter leaves fans questioning the moral validity of these actions and their tragic consequences. However, one wonders how events would unfold if Eren had chosen a different path instead?

Let’s explore an alternate perspective: By presenting a fresh perspective, we provoke thought among viewers who may have envisioned Eren as a peacemaker instead of a violent figure. Could the storyline have unfolded differently, without such a devastating outcome? If so, what changes would occur on Paradis Island, regarding Titans, and global powers? To delve deeper, let’s examine two hypothetical situations where Eren chooses to halt the Rumbling and seeks a peaceful resolution instead.

This phrasing aims to convey the same information in a more conversational and engaging manner. It encourages readers to imagine different possibilities and engage with the content.

Choosing Love Over War

A Fragile Peace Through Sacrifice

In the second scenario, the outlier Eren initiates the Rumbling, a destructive event that requires countless Colossal Titans to eliminate most of humanity. His motive is to safeguard Paradis Island from persistent attacks by outside forces who view it as a menace. However, paradoxically, he also confronts his companions – Armin, Mikasa, and others – in an attempt to halt him. In a heart-wrenching conclusion, Mikasa is the one who ultimately ends Eren’s life and halts the onslaught.

Essentially, Eren’s actions, though causing immense destruction, have offered temporary respite for Paradis Island. Outside its borders lie only a few hostile groups, who may pose less of an immediate threat but still harbor resentment and mistrust. The finale leaves fans questioning whether Eren accomplished his mission or merely postponed the war.

Scenario 1: Eren and Mikasa’s Escape

In a different timeline, instead of leading the battles, Eren confides his love for Mikasa and they both escape together, avoiding conflicts. They live in seclusion, distant from Paradis Island and the rest of the world. This choice prevents the Rumbling and saves countless lives, but it also brings its own set of issues. The reason Eren took such drastic measures was to protect Paradis Island from any potential threats, as Marley and other nations possessing most of the Titans could attack for resources.

In this situation, Paradis appears unlikely to have a promising future due to its subjugation by powerful global forces seeking retribution. The joy that Eren and Mikasa managed to secure for themselves would be fleeting, as the suffering of their homeland is bound to return. Additionally, given that there’s little defense other than Armin’s Colossal Titan, it seems likely that Paradis may eventually be destroyed.

Scenario 2: A Truce Built on Fear

In another scenario, Eren warns other countries, particularly Marley, as well as the global leaders, about the Rumbling. Instead of releasing the Colossal Titans, he illustrates the potential consequences if the conflict with Paradis continues – everyone will perish. Faced with such a grim possibility, Marley and its allies might reconsider their actions.

On this particular course, Marley and Paradis Island might establish a tentative truce, meaning they’d stop attacking each other if the Titans remain dormant. However, this truce would heavily depend on trust, which is scarce between these two entities. Eren’s actions may postpone some conflicts, but the danger of Rumbling keeps everyone in check. This truce won’t come without its challenges, as genuine lasting peace can’t be purchased with weapons, despite it appearing to be the initial plan for a short-term solution.

Eren’s Ultimate Gamble

There’s Always A Way, Sadly Not A Good One

In the world of AoT, efforts for global peace are a delicate balance. Eren’s choice to seek an escape or peace option carries significant implications. The enmity between Marley and Paradis is so deep-rooted that lasting peace seems improbable. Without the Rumbling, Paradis would struggle to protect its land, leaving its people vulnerable to attacks from other regions.

If You Win, You Live. If You Lose, You Die. If You Don’t Fight, You Can’t Win!

In the original story, Eren’s choice is a response to the present circumstances, where survival trumps all else. Despite his unconventional tactics, they underscore the extreme measures one might resort to in order to protect their home and loved ones. In different conditions, finding peace would involve sacrifice and uncertainty, which makes sense given Eren’s role as a catalyst for change, whether that change is beneficial or detrimental.

The Lessons of Freedom and Sacrifice

The Weight of Freedom

Regarding the protagonist, Eren Yeager, his actions sparked debate among fans about the moral complexities of a hero and potential alternative paths. The original conclusion provokes thought on themes like tragedy, war, sacrifice, and freedom in a deeper sense. Although stories where Eren opts for peace are intriguing as they explore hypothetical scenarios, they underscore the fact that achieving peace in such a world is anything but effortless.

Eren’s tale is a poignant narrative demonstrating that the pursuit of free civilization often comes at the cost of freedom itself, and this reality arises from the very act of seeking freedom. As a character who resorts to extreme violence and verges on destroying the world due to his rage or despair, Eren’s journey invites exploration among the devoted fans of the series.

Or, more informally:

Eren’s story teaches us that gaining free civilization might mean losing our own freedom, and this lesson emerges from our pursuit of freedom. This intense character, who uses extreme violence and almost destroys the world through anger or desperation, makes fans of the series want to dive deeper into his tale.

Read More

2025-01-18 22:24