Unveiling the Shocking Truth Behind Red Dead Redemption 2’s Strange Man!

by

For years, The Mysterious Figure from the world of Red Dead Redemption has sparked intense discussions among fans. This peculiar character is deeply rooted in something mysterious and unsettling, and Red Dead Redemption 2 serves as undeniable proof of this when players explore the cabin in Bayall Edge, nestled within the Bayou Nwa, Lemoyne. Here, they can discover a meticulously kept home that seems to belong to The Mysterious Figure.

Delving into the mysterious aspects surrounding the enigmatic character known as the Strange Man, it might be beneficial to examine some historical theories that could potentially shed light on his identity within the context of “Red Dead Redemption 2.” After all, unraveling the mystery of the Strange Man is one of the most intriguing unsolved puzzles in the world of “Red Dead Redemption.”

Spoilers ahead for Red Dead Redemption!

1. The Strange Man is God Himself

The One Above All is Here to Judge John Marston in His Final Weeks

One intriguing speculation born from the world of “Red Dead Redemption” regarding the enigmatic character known as the Stranger is the hypothesis that he could be none other than a divine entity, specifically God himself. Although the storyline surrounding the Stranger presents some inconsistencies with this theory, the strongest evidence against it can be found in the culmination of the mission “I Know You” within “Red Dead Redemption.” At the end of this mission, John Marston curses the Stranger, to which the Stranger responds with a seemingly nonchalant, “Many have.

Back in the wild, wild West, it wasn’t uncommon for folks to curse and blame the Almighty for their misfortunes, much like they themselves were destined for hardship. This chaotic landscape of New Austin was no exception, and it seems the Mysterious Man has taken notice of John Marston’s moral struggles. He’s sending me on a quest that feels like a test of redemption, probing to see if I can shake off my ruthless past or if I’m still the heartless, self-centered outlaw I was before.

One significant clue suggesting the Mysterious Man might be divine is his interaction with John Marston. This alignment stems from the concept that God grants humans free agency, making it plausible that the Mysterious Man, who respects John’s autonomy and doesn’t interfere in his decisions, could be a representation of God. Additionally, given that God is omniscient and omnipresent, it aligns with the fact that John feels watched (especially when players observe the mirror) in the Bayall Edge.

However, a major pitfall in this argument arises from the Mysterious Man’s knowledge of the Armadillo curse and his potential involvement in making a deal for “happiness or two generations.” This action doesn’t resonate with the idea of God engaging in Faustian bargains…

2. The Strange Man is Satan

A Devil Makes a Cursed Deal for Souls and Torment

Instead of interpreting that the Strange Man is divine, as some might suggest, there’s an alternate view that he is none other than Satan himself. This notion arises primarily because the Strange Man appears to delight in immoral acts and seems intent on encouraging John Marston to engage in such activities, just to observe the consequences. Given that Satan is known for testing and tormenting the moral compass and free will of God’s creations, it could be argued that orchestrating chaos and sin in the lawless West would be a clever tactic by which the Devil might tempt John Marston.

As a gamer, I can’t help but notice the recurring tension between John and the Mysterious Man, akin to how some might confront the Devil himself over God. What intrigues me most is the hint of Faustian bargains suggested by the Mysterious Man, as evidenced by the map in Bayall Edge cabin that reads: “I offered you happiness or two generations. You made your choice.” It appears the pride of the Devil is insatiable, which explains why there’s a picture of him hidden behind Herbert Moon, the only healthy man in Armadillo, as if he’s under some mysterious and dark protection through a pact.

It appears that Herbert Moon’s arrangement is quite definitive, given the widespread cholera outbreak in the town, which has spared only him. Another point worth mentioning about Herbert Moon is his questionable moral standing, as he holds strong prejudices against various groups – homophobia, xenophobia, racism, and antisemitism. These views led him to disown his daughter, Herberta, after she married a Jewish man. Despite being immune to the plague, Herbert seems to be sacrificing his own happiness by refusing to accept his daughter’s marriage, which he does not approve of.

3. The Strange Man is Death

The Grim Reaper is An Accountant, of Sorts, Just Like the Strange Man Says

An intriguing hypothesis about the enigmatic figure known as the Strange Man suggests that he might symbolize Death, personified as the Grim Reaper. This mysterious character seems to haunt John because the Strange Man is believed to be aware of the exact circumstances and timing of John’s demise, and understands the inevitability of it all. Furthermore, the Strange Man hints at his role by claiming to be an accountant, in a sense, as if he keeps track of the debts owed by mortals, guiding their souls towards either Heaven or Hell upon their passing.

The Strange Man personifies Death through his somber all-black clothing reminiscent of a funeral, and by challenging John’s moral integrity, seeming to gauge whether he will end up in Heaven or Hell when his fate arrives. Notably, by 1911, the Strange Man’s impending time draws near. Intriguingly, he identifies the precise location where John will meet his demise – within Beecher’s Hope – and praises it as “a stunning location,” coincidentally being the same tree under which John is interred.

Death is inevitable for everyone, eventually claiming even those closest to us. The Strange Man’s impartiality suggests that he neither holds good nor evil intentions; rather, he is an inescapable force regardless of the choices people make. However, it remains puzzling as to why he would be revered in a swamp shrine and why he would cast a curse upon Armadillo town.

4. The Strange Man is Cain, the Elder Brother of Abel

The First Murderer is Doomed to Walk the Earth

An unexpected hypothesis about who the Mysterious Man could be is derived from the biblical tale of Cain and Abel in the Book of Genesis. Cain, the first-born son of Adam and Eve, ends up killing his brother, Abel. As a result of this heinous act, God banishes Cain from his homeland, condemning him to wander the world for eternity. Additionally, God brands Cain so that he is destined to live as either a human or an animal, never truly able to die due to his sin.

One chilling element of this theory is the retribution that befalls John for attempting to harm the Mysterious Man, as it’s foretold in Genesis 4:1-16: “Anyone who kills Cain will endure a sevenfold vengeance.” After John fires three shots at the Mysterious Man, he himself is hit 21 times by Edgar Ross and the law enforcement officers sent to apprehend him. Not only that, but the trio of bullets fired by John symbolize the three deaths at Beecher’s Hope: One bullet for John, one for his uncle, and a third for Abigail. The fourth shot malfunctions – sparing Jack.

An argument supporting the hypothesis that the Strange Man could be Cain lies in the fact that Cain was the firstborn son of Adam and Eve, making it plausible for him to have lived for centuries and thereby forgetting his name. Similarities between the two characters include their wandering nature, as the Strange Man never rides a horse but instead observes the world around him, much like Cain who was forced to wander due to his curse. However, this theory has flaws. For instance, Cain doesn’t possess supernatural powers such as immortality, invisibility, or omniscience, which are attributes associated with the Strange Man. It is unclear how Cain could be depicted in a painting and disappear at will, or how he would have acquired such extensive knowledge.

Read More

2025-01-31 18:35