Best Teams To Join As A Shortstop In MLB The Show 25

MLB The Show 25 can deliver some exciting and challenging moments when playing as a shortstop, but not every team will be the best pick going into the draft. Going to a team that already has a strong shortstop will only make your path out of the minor leagues longer in Road to the Show.

At the same time, some teams in need of a shortstop just don’t have the surrounding cast for you to compete early on in RTTS. If you don’t want the unpredictability of letting the draft pick your landing spot Road to the Show, it’s better to choose one of the best teams for a shortstop in MLB The Show 25.

Atlanta Braves

Position Highest Rated Player
Starting Pitcher Chris Sale – 94 OVR
Relief Pitcher Joe Jimenez – 78 OVR
Closing Pitcher Raisel Iglesias – 85 OVR
Catcher Sean Murphy – 80 OVR
First Baseman Matt Olson – 87 OVR
Second Baseman Ozzie Albies – 81 OVR
Third Baseman Austin Riley – 86 OVR
Shortstop Orlando Arcia – 70 OVR
Left Fielder Marcell Ozuna – 81 OVR
Center Fielder Michael Harris II – 87 OVR
Right Fielder Ronald Acuna Jr. – 93 OVR

The best team to join as a shortstop in MLB The Show 25 is the Atlanta Braves. Despite being the second-best team in the league, the Braves are in the bottom five teams when it comes to shortstop ratings. They have 80+ OVR rated players at almost every other position, and that gives you an extremely strong supporting cast that could reliably make the playoffs.

With your strongest competition having just a 70 OVR rating, playing consistently well in Road to the Show might get you called up to the majors after just a year or two. The one risk with this option would be the Braves acquiring a better shortstop while you’re working in the minor leagues, and in that case, you might want to ask your agent about being traded.

Arizona Diamondbacks

Position Highest Rated Player
Starting Pitcher Corbin Burnes – 86 OVR
Relief Pitcher Kevin Ginkel – 76 OVR
Closing Pitcher Justin Martinez – 76 OVR
Catcher Gabriel Moreno – 80 OVR
First Baseman Josh Naylor – 80 OVR
Second Baseman Ketel Marte – 96 OVR
Third Baseman Eugenio Suarez – 86 OVR
Shortstop Geraldo Perdomo – 77 OVR
Left Fielder Lourdes Gurriel Jr. – 79 OVR
Center Fielder Jake MCCarthy – 77 OVR
Right Fielder Corbin Carroll – 85 OVR

If you don’t mind waiting a little longer to make the majors, a really solid all-around choice for shortstops in RTTS is the Arizona Diamondbacks. In addition to being one of the top ten overall teams in the league, they’ve got a very well-rounded roster in MLB The Show 25.

Having a higher-rated target to replace once you reach the majors will likely give you more time to develop and improve your player against less challenging competition in the minor leagues. This could also give you time to work on upgrading perks as well as your own ratings before taking on major league opponents. The Diamondbacks have a solid enough roster that they should remain contenders in the coming years, and your shortstop could be a big part of that after developing them in Road to the Show.

Milwaukee Brewers

Position Highest Rated Player
Starting Pitcher Freddy Peralta – 82 OVR
Relief Pitcher Bryan Hudson – 77 OVR
Closing Pitcher Trevor Megill – 80 OVR
Catcher William Contreras – 89 OVR
First Baseman Rhys Hoskins – 79 OVR
Second Baseman Brice Turang – 80 OVR
Third Baseman Joseph Ortiz – 77 OVR
Shortstop Andruw Monasterio – 64 OVR
Left Fielder Christian Yelich – 87 OVR
Center Fielder Garrett Mitchell – 78 OVR
Right Fielder Sal Frelick – 73 OVR

If you want your shortstop to get called up to the majors as quickly as possible in Road to the Show, choose the Milwaukee Brewers. Despite being dead last in shortstop ratings, the Brewers are the fastest team in MLB The Show 25 and will surround you with quality defensive players.

With their best shortstop sitting at just a 64 OVR rating, you might be able to pass that and go right to the majors in your rookie season. If that’s the goal, spend all your early tokens on attribute upgrades instead of perks. Improving attributes will boost your overall rating quicker, and you’ll still be able to upgrade perks after you’ve powered your way into the major leagues.

Seattle Mariners

Position Highest Rated Player
Starting Pitcher George Kirby – 89 OVR
Relief Pitcher Gregory Santos – 74 OVR
Closing Pitcher Andrew Munoz – 82 OVR
Catcher Cal Raleigh – 86 OVR
First Baseman Luke Raley – 74 OVR
Second Baseman Dylan Moore – 72 OVR
Third Baseman Donovan Solano – 71 OVR
Shortstop J.P. Crawford – 73 OVR
Left Fielder Randy Arozarena – 77 OVR
Center Fielder Julio Rodriguez – 90 OVR
Right Fielder Victor Robles – 74 OVR

Another great option for shortstops in Road to the Show is the Seattle Mariners, and you’ll have the benefit of covering the field for the second best pitching core in MLB The Show 25. They’re just shy of being among the top ten teams in the league, but the Mariners need some help on defense.

With the best Mariners shortstop at 73 OVR, it will take a little longer to hit the majors compared to some other options listed here. That gives you extra time to upgrade your player while working against minor league competition. If you get called up and have a higher rating than every other infield player, it could present more challenging fielding opportunities in RTTS.

Cleveland Guardians

Position Highest Rated Player
Starting Pitcher Tanner Bibee – 86 OVR
Relief Pitcher Cade Smith – 88 OVR
Closing Pitcher Emmanuel Clase – 91 OVR
Catcher Bo Naylor – 73 OVR
First Baseman Carlos Santana – 84 OVR
Second Baseman Daniel Schneemann – 67 OVR
Third Baseman Jose Ramirez – 95 OVR
Shortstop Brayan Rocchio – 68 OVR
Left Fielder Steven Kwan – 82 OVR
Center Fielder Lane Thomas – 80 OVR
Right Fielder Jhonkensy Noel – 75 OVR

The Cleveland Guardians were a top landing spot at shortstop in MLB The Show 24, and that’s a hole in their roster that has yet to be filled. The Guardians have a reliable pitching core, solid overall defense, and the fourth-worst starting shortstop in MLB The Show 25.

With the right upgrades, you’ve got a good chance of getting called up within the first few Road to the Show seasons. With five-time Silver Slugger Award winner Jose Ramirez in the lineup, a shortstop that can hit might be enough to take them to the postseason in MLB The Show 25.

Read More

2025-03-17 10:00