Fans Are Furious: The Shocking Truth Behind One Piece’s Fishman Island Remaster!

by

Summary

  • The new Fishman Island remaster cuts down unnecessary aspects of the original.
  • Animation and pacing in the remaster have improved significantly.
  • Fans may prefer the original over the remaster due to sacrifices made for speed and clarity.

During a six-month break, One Piece surprised many fans by revisiting an arc that was quite contentious: Fishman Island. Instead of leaving viewers without fresh content, they chose to reair this controversial part of the series. While it wasn’t new Egghead Arc material, fans were thrilled about another chance to explore Fishman Island and hopefully resolve some lingering issues.

Initially, fans were thrilled with the remastered version of Fishman Island, but their enthusiasm soon waned as they began criticizing the updated content. Instead of applauding it for enhancing a weak arc, fans started pointing out some fairly negative aspects of One Piece Log: Fish-Man Island Saga. This new wave of criticism from the community could potentially discourage future rereleases of arcs with slow pacing in One Piece.

The New Fishman Island Cuts Down The Unnecessary Aspects Of The Original

Both The Animation And Pacing Have Improved

The “One Piece Log: Fish-Man Island Saga” is a revamped version of the debated Fishman Island Arc within “One Piece.” Its primary goal is to address some of the arc’s most problematic aspects. Essentially, this revised arc enhances the original content in multiple ways, such as refining the visual style with thicker lines and greater detail, and improving the pace by trimming certain scenes and quickening edits. In essence, it significantly reduces the number of episodes from the initial Fishman Island, leading to a smoother, more efficient viewing experience.

It’s going to be cold. Take care of yourself. – Brook

Initially, the revamped version of the arc seemed quite decent following the update, but fans soon noticed that the new approach to editing might be a more significant problem than previously thought. The rapid transitions between scenes felt disjointed and harsh, and some cherished and crucial scenes were omitted entirely, making the Fishman Island storyline less coherent. Despite being a quicker watch, some viewers argue that the arc made too many concessions to deliver this speed.

The Editing Style May Be A Bit Too Fast

The New Editing Sacrifices Clarity For Speed

  • The New Fishman Island Prioritizes Speed And Cuts Important Scenes
  • This Can Lead TO Some Confusing Cuts That Don’t Make Sense

When it comes to choosing between different versions of the Fishman Island Arc in One Piece, many long-term fans suggest opting for the original version over the remaster. In essence, the original provides a clearer understanding of the story due to its inclusion of crucial scenes and better narrative flow, making it more suitable for first-time viewers. While the remaster may have improved animation, some find the editing style peculiar and question whether this enhancement outweighs the changes made.

In essence, the reworked Fishman Island arc appears to be a precursor, testing the waters for potential future trends in the One Piece series. The refined versions address the concerns of pacing and artwork that were present in less popular storylines. Despite a somewhat indifferent response from online communities regarding the revamped Fishman Island, it seems improbable that this would discourage One Piece from pursuing arc remastering altogether. However, if One Piece were to persist with this remastering approach, there is a risk that it could undermine the concept in the long run.

This May Discourage Re-Edits Of Future Arcs

Dressrosa And Wano May Remain Incredibly Long Forever

While some fans initially anticipated remasters for significant arcs such as Dressrosa, their expectations shifted when they noticed the editing approach used in Fishman Island. Given the importance of arcs like Dressrosa or Wano to the overall series, this editing style might attract more criticism than the Fishman Island remaster. However, if editors could discover a fresh editing style, say by making transitions between scenes smoother, it could potentially gain a warmer reception from the fan community.

No matter how we feel about humans, we can’t let children learn it! – Otohime

Although some found the updated version of Fishman Island in One Piece quite satisfactory, it fell short for many and didn’t manage to replace the highly debated arc effectively. Given the unfavorable response to this remaster, there are concerns among fans about the potential quality of future adaptations if One Piece chooses to persist with this approach. Consequently, there is a possibility that Fishman Island might be irreparable in every form, even in the manga.

Read More

2025-04-07 16:56