Guarma in Red Dead Redemption 3: To Include or Not to Include?

by

Red Dead Redemption 2, often hailed as one of the best open-world games ever created, is admired for its vividly realistic settings and profound storytelling. Even now, it remains popular – in fact, it recently set a new player count record on Steam. However, among fans of Red Dead Redemption 2, there’s still much discussion about one particular chapter: the trip to Guarma – an isolated tropical island that deviates from the American frontier and temporarily becomes part of the game’s storyline.

Different individuals perceive it as a welcome shift from the norm or an unneeded interruption that disrupts the narrative progression. Rockstar Games’ Non-Disclosure Agreements are more stringent than Marvel’s, and they are known for their secrecy, making information scarce. However, as Rockstar subtly continues its work on what could potentially be Red Dead Redemption 3, the question remains whether the next game will continue in the vein of Guarma’s setting.

Red Dead Redemption 3 – To Guarma Or Not To Guarma

The Case For Another Guarma in RDR3

In the grandiose American West, characterized by its dusty expanses and snow-capped mountains, as portrayed in Rockstar’s cowboy saga, holds a central position. It’s quite astonishing then, to catch a fleeting glimpse of something different, given the vastness and intricacy of this world. Remarkably, even after thorough exploration, mysteries remain unsolved on the map of Red Dead Redemption 2. This unexpected shift in scenery is what makes it unique. It suggests that the game’s universe stretches far beyond its primary boundaries – hinting at a more comprehensive geopolitical narrative unfolding in the periphery.

Experiencing Guarma chapter felt like a change of pace, offering a dynamic contrast to the earlier storyline. After immersing ourselves in detailed character growth and extensive exploration, we were plunged into an action-packed, storyline-driven sequence that was heavily focused on combat. This shift served as a cathartic release following the tumultuous events in Saint Denis with the Van der Linde gang. Furthermore, it sparked curiosity about the world beyond America. Some players have gone as far as suggesting that Guarma hints at the possibility of a future Rockstar game set in South America.

The Case Against Another Guarma in RDR3

It’s understandable that not everyone appreciated being transported to a secluded island during gameplay in Guarma. For many players, this change seemed abrupt and disrupted the main storyline. The transition deprived them of their equipment, restricted access to the vast open world, and provided minimal opportunities for exploration. This sudden shift to tropical gunfights might have felt discordant with the overall immersive experience of for those who had grown accustomed to its slow, deliberate pace. Consequently, some players of debated about the purpose behind this change.

The concern lies in the aspect of repeatability for Guarma. Essentially, once this part of the game is completed, players can’t revisit it. While there’s a quirky glitch in Red Dead Redemption 2 that allows a return, for some, it might seem like a missed chance – making Guarma feel more like a diversion than a significant piece of the storyline. It’s worth noting that not every game requires a ‘Guarma-like’ segment. The surprise factor in Red Dead Redemption 2 makes this chapter stand out, and attempting to replicate such an experience in a sequel could potentially result in it feeling contrived or overly gimmicky, especially if it’s included solely for variety’s sake.

Read More

2025-04-09 13:06