Star Trek’s Wil Wheaton: Prodigy Isn’t Just For Kids!

by

Summary

  • Star Trek: Prodigy offers Pixar-level storytelling that appeals to all ages, not just children.
  • The series tackles mature themes like legacy and identity through stellar character development and deep storytelling.
  • Wheaton aims to change the perception of Prodigy and promote it as a legitimate piece of Star Trek storytelling for all viewers.

As a devoted Star Trek enthusiast, I can assure you that Star Trek: Prodigy may seem like it hails from a Nickelodeon lunchbox at first glance. However, let me clarify – it’s not just for the young ones. In fact, Wil Wheaton, who played Wesley Crusher in The Next Generation, is here to emphasize that point. This animated spinoff has achieved something no other Star Trek series could in almost four decades: they nailed Wesley Crusher’s character perfectly. And as someone who’s been a part of this iconic franchise, I can’t help but celebrate this remarkable milestone.

As a die-hard Trekkie, I recently got a thrilling insider scoop about the underappreciated animated series, Star Trek: Prodigy, during a buzzing Reddit AMA. This gem, which teetered on cancellation at one point, masterfully combines franchise history, heartfelt narratives, and vibrant aesthetics to resonate with viewers of all ages – although it might not be immediately apparent to everyone yet. Wil Wheaton, who insists it’s far from a kids-only show, likens its storytelling prowess to Pixar standards. And he couldn’t be more spot on. Prodigy delves into themes like legacy, self-discovery, and redemption as deeply as any live-action series that preceded it. If an offbeat animated Star Trek spinoff like Lower Decks can find its footing with mature audiences, then why can’t Prodigy do the same?

The Star Trek: Prodigy PR Problem

When Wheaton refers to “Star Trek: Prodigy” as being similar in spirit to Pixar films, he’s not overstating it. Like “Up” or “Inside Out,” “Prodigy” doesn’t talk down to its viewers. It tackles intricate themes in a way that’s easy to understand, such as rebellious AIs, interstellar power struggles, and the weight of tradition. Additionally, the series received high praise from critics and boasts an impressive 97% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

As a devoted movie enthusiast, I’ve tirelessly attempted to shift the mindset that one must be young or accompany children to appreciate it. However, this task has been as challenging as attempting to reinstall the isolinear optical chips, which Drunk Shinoda carelessly removed without Data’s assistance in Star Trek: The Next Generation.

As a movie enthusiast, let me tell you that Prodigy is not just a show for babysitting purposes. It’s a captivating tale that carries high stakes, intellectual depth, and even a dash of nostalgia reminiscent of the Starfleet era. However, it was initially aired on Nickelodeon, which might have been a bit misleading as it catered to a broader, younger audience. This decision might have influenced its perception among adult Trekkies.

At first glance, Prodigy may appear to be “the one for kids,” but for those who gave it a chance, there’s a profound narrative hidden beneath the vibrant 3D animation. It’s filled with canonical references and emotional journeys that resonate deeply, proving that this series is not just for the younger generation.

Why Star Trek: Prodigy Is a Grown-Up Story Too

What sets Prodigy apart isn’t only its animation or ease of use, but how it explores maturity, identity, and development through an outstanding cast. It’s true that growing-up stories often resonate with adults reminiscing about their past. These characters aren’t initially part of Starfleet; they don’t even know what the Federation is. However, by the end of Season 1, they’ve managed to secure a spot in its future. This transformation isn’t just progress — it’s top-notch Star Trek.

In a simpler phraseology: Dal R’El, played by Brett Gray, initially comes off as arrogant and unsure, striving to demonstrate his authority. However, his transformation into someone who prioritizes the crew over himself is heartfelt and emotionally fulfilling. Gwyn (Ella Purnell), daughter of the series’ antagonist, goes from spy to rebel to negotiator, wrestling with her father’s impact and making her own choices. Her interactions with the genuine Admiral Janeway (voiced by Kate Mulgrew) in Season 2 are among the most emotionally powerful moments in the show.

In another part of the universe, other stars also gleam. Introducing Rok-Tahk, a young Brikar who is initially portrayed as the strongman, but unexpectedly develops a keen interest in science and alien biology. Jankom Pog, a Tellarite engineer, stands out with his boisterous demeanor, grumpy attitude, and endearing charm, providing both humor and genuine technical expertise. Zero, a genderless Medusan character, provides some of the series’ deepest, thought-provoking moments that echo classic Star Trek themes. Lastly, there’s Murf – voiced by the esteemed Dee Bradley Baker – who begins as a squishy pet and transforms into an invincible, lovable action hero with a phaser-proof exterior.

Mulgrew’s double portrayal of Hologram Janeway and Admiral Janeway is impressive. The holographic character serves as a guide, instructor, and nurturing figure, instilling Federation ideals within the crew. When the genuine Janeway appears later on, she doesn’t come to take control; instead, she encourages them and tests their abilities.

The narrative is unreservedly engaging. The Protostar’s quantum slipstream engine serves as a crucial plot element, stirring moral dilemmas and inciting exhilarating pursuits. Season 2 delves further into the intricacies of Star Trek universe, scrutinizing the consequences of time travel, dissecting the intentions behind the Vau N’Akat, and even incorporating the Traveler mythology from TNG, with none other than Wesley Crusher taking on a significant part.

Despite the impressive polish and epic nature of Season 2, it’s not hard to overlook the fact that the series was initially in danger of never being made. In 2023, Paramount+ suddenly canceled Prodigy and even removed it from their platform, leaving fans heartbroken. However, a passionate online campaign ignited hope, leading Netflix to acquire the rights and save the show. Season 2 debuted on Netflix in 2024, expanding its reach to an even broader audience.

Wesley Crusher: Finally More Than a Bad Meme

There’s no denying that Wesley Crusher, initially introduced on The Next Generation as a prodigious teenager on the Enterprise-D, had a tough time. Despite his potential, the character, portrayed by Wil Wheaton with a youthful countenance, was frequently the target of jokes. Fans found it hard to decide how to feel about the young man in sweaters who could solve problems even before experienced Starfleet officers. This often led to sighs and rolled eyes.

A significant amount of the criticism arose due to Wesley’s perceived likeness to a character created by Gene Roddenberry in his own image: an exceptional, youthful figure who frequently outshone older crew members. His habit of rescuing situations gave him an air of unrelatability and transformed him into a convenient plot device rather than a fellow crewmember.

However, a significant change occurred in “Star Trek: Prodigy”. In the episode titled “Asylum” (S2, Ep3), Crusher – now functioning as a Traveler – influenced the destiny of the Prodigy team. This Wesley is self-assured, mysterious, and seems to be one with the universe. He’s no longer striving to prove his worth; instead, he knows it. Wheaton was delighted by his character’s rejuvenation, expressing his joy in the AMA.

“They finally got Wesley right.”

He’s not in error. The Traveler storyline from the later seasons of Star Trek: The Next Generation finally bears fruit. Unlike previous series that left his storyline unresolved, Star Trek: Prodigy respectfully continues it, transforming Wesley from a mere footnote into a pivotal character.

Star Trek: Lower Decks vs. Prodigy: Two Animations, Two Receptions

In my perspective, I’ve found that both “Star Trek: Prodigy” and “Star Trek: Lower Decks” have significantly broadened the scope of the Star Trek universe by venturing into animation. However, each series has taken distinct paths, leading to varied responses from fans.

  • Lower Decks is irreverent, adult-oriented, and packed with meta-humor and inside jokes. It’s animated Trek filtered through the lens of Rick and Morty (which makes sense, considering showrunner Mike McMahan’s background). Trekkies loved the show for its obscure Easter eggs and episode callbacks. It ran for a full five seasons.
  • Prodigy, on the other hand, is more earnest and made for a family audience: kids and adults. It aims for heart and character depth rather than laughs and lampoons. The show was packaged and marketed as children’s programming; therefore, it was mostly overlooked by fans.
  • Both series received high praise from critics and Rotten Tomatoes scores in the 90s.

Could it be because Lower Decks became popular so swiftly while Prodigy struggled to gain traction has something to do with its timing? It premiered during a period saturated with meta-content, where humor that is self-aware and referential reigns supreme in the cultural sphere. Shows like Deadpool and Rick and Morty have shaped our expectations for postmodern winks and nods. Lower Decks, with its fitting place within this ecosystem, caters to both the subject and audience of fandom.

The show was specifically targeted towards mature “Star Trek” enthusiasts rather than kids or families. This strategy helped it avoid being labeled a children’s show, instead fitting neatly into the realm of adult animation. Since “TOS” premiered in 1966 and “TNG” in 1987, many original Trekkies are indeed adults.

Moreover, what might be most significant is that the series provided the fanbase with an abundance of references to the lore, along with obscure trivia, and characters who seemed as if they were privy to the inside jokes. Characters like Mariner, Boimler, and their peers don’t just inhabit the “Trek” universe; they are well-versed in its tropes, appreciating them as much as we do, sometimes even poking fun at them.

Wheaton’s Mission to Change the Perception of Star Trek: Prodigy

Beyond simply appreciating Prodigy, Wheaton is striving to redefine its perception. During his AMA session, the Star Trek: The Next Generation actor emphasized that he’s grown weary of the series being misconstrued or disregarded. He openly voiced his annoyance at the struggle to change people’s minds about it.

This isn’t just for children; it’s animation that can be enjoyed by kids while still engaging adults.

Wheaton isn’t just speaking to those already convinced; he’s urging followers to aid him in changing the conversation. Whether it’s by word-of-mouth, engaging in social media discussions, or persuading that hesitant friend to give it a try, his goal is for Prodigy to be recognized as a genuine contribution to Star Trek storytelling. Maybe this collective action will lead to a third season.

Read More

2025-04-10 16:25