You Won’t Believe Which Game of Thrones Season Tops the List—And Which Flopped Big Time!

by

Summary

  • Every Game of Thrones fan has their own preferences for favorite seasons, episodes, and characters in the show.
  • Seasons 7 and 8 represent the low points of GoT, prioritizing action over strong writing and focusing on fan-service with seemingly invincible characters.
  • Seasons 4 and 6 are often regarded as Game of Thrones’ best, striking a fine balance between action, dialogue, and nuanced character portrayals.

The television series Game of Thrones, for nine consecutive years, has solidified its position as a significant pillar in today’s popular culture, transcending the boundaries of traditional television. Acclaimed globally, it stands among the costliest, most-viewed, most-debated, and highest-rated series ever produced. For nearly a decade (excluding 2018), it reigned supreme, offering top-tier narrative through numerous intertwining character stories, coupled with box-office flair, captivating audiences of diverse ages and tastes.

In George R.R. Martin’s book series “A Song of Ice and Fire,” the TV show “GoT” is deeply rooted in a complex world and well-crafted characters from various powerful houses in Westeros, including the Starks, Lannisters, Targaryens, Baratheons, and Tyrells. Primarily, it gained significant success due to exceptional casting decisions that brought forth many young talents who later became famous, as well as providing a realistic and authentic atmosphere through thoughtfully chosen filming locations and remarkable work by the art and costume departments.

Just as every enthusiast has their personal preferences among shows like ‘Game of Thrones’, so too do fans have favorite seasons and episodes, influenced by cherished characters or turning points in the storyline. This ranking will attempt to reflect the show’s grandeur by evaluating each season of ‘Game of Thrones’ (excluding ‘House of the Dragon’), summarizing key events for each and acknowledging their strengths and weaknesses.

The list contains spoilers for all Game of Thrones seasons and major events.

8. Season 8 (2019)

Fan-Service Instead of a Fitting Finale

  • Best Episode: Episode 3 – The Long Night

As a devoted cinephile, I must confess that the concluding season of “Game of Thrones” fell significantly short of my expectations. Instead of delivering the grandeur and intrigue that had become synonymous with the series, it often felt like a betrayal of the show’s core elements. Disregarding the major concerns regarding writing, dialogue, and character transformations in a hurry, there were numerous issues: an inconsistent pace (leaving me longing for action during the first two episodes), an overabundance of fan service moments, a hasty effort to wrap up every plot thread, and a shift towards providing a predictable blockbuster spectacle instead of an epic finale. It was a stark contrast to the show’s most impressive seasons.

In discussing the key events from Season 8 of Game of Thrones, such as the Night King’s defeat in the Battle of Winterfell and Daenerys’s transformation into a mad queen at King’s Landing, as well as the surprising turn regarding the new king – these moments fell short of capturing the signature thrill that typically defines the show. Instead, many plotlines followed an overly predictable path towards their conclusion, or alternatively, attempted to introduce unforeseen twists for no apparent reason and without adequate preparation or reasoning.

Praise for Season 8 is mainly due to Ramin Djawadi’s consistently superb music score, enhancing episodes like “The Long Night,” and the high-quality production, boasting television’s finest costumes and visual effects. However, it was understandable that some level of disenchantment arose from an ending with such extensive buildup and towering expectations. Upon rewatching the series in succession, the shortcomings of the final episodes become more apparent, frequently leading to a disappointing viewing experience.

7. Season 7 (2017)

Where the Show Started to Fall Apart

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 4 – The Spoils of War
  • Episode 7 – The Dragon and the Wolf

In simpler terms, Season 7 of Game of Thrones set the stage for the less satisfying conclusion, with hints of what was to come. Although not as problematic as Season 8, it became apparent that the creators were running low on original content, focusing more on grand battles instead of the intricate dialogue and character development that characterized the show. The season received much criticism due to its convoluted storyline, with characters appearing mysteriously across Westeros and acquiring unexpected plot protection – a tactic that gave an illusion of peril but ultimately led to predictable, action-packed results.

Despite its unrefined narrative, the series effectively captivated audiences through grandiose action sequences, such as the hunt for a wight, epic dragon fights, and unexpected, fulfilling character demises. These elements skillfully overshadowed the absence of clever dialogue and nuanced writing, making good use of an increased budget and scale. Consequently, several viewers praised these aspects, with certain episodes even earning high ratings within the series.

It eventually became apparent that the show was steering towards a focus on appeasing fans and intricate character interplay that served as satisfying conclusions. Essential characters were hard to eliminate or write out of the plot, even if the narrative required such sacrifices.

6. Season 5 (2015)

Not Weak, but Rather Unremarkable

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 8 – Hardhome
  • Episode 9 – The Dance of Dragons

Season 5 of Game of Thrones, while not weak on its own, falls short compared to the seasons before and after it. It’s less engaging and somewhat light on key events, sandwiched between some of Game of Thrones’ most outstanding seasons. This season was also the first time a Game of Thrones episode dipped below an 8.0 rating on IMDb, indicating a slower pace with few significant events unfolding over several episodes in a row. Some viewers even reported feeling a bit bored – a sensation that previously seemed unimaginable while watching Game of Thrones.

The main problem with Season 5 is pacing. The first part seems to linger too much on the High Sparrow, Daenerys in Meereen, Sansa’s ordeal, and Arya’s training in Braavos, making these storylines feel prolonged. However, the second half makes amends with more impactful conclusions, boasting notable episodes like ‘Hardhome’, which skillfully blends dialogue with action, showcasing Jon confronting the Walkers, Stannis’ fall from grace after putting everything on the line, and Arya embarking on her vengeance journey. And let’s not forget one of the show’s most memorable moments: the Night’s Watch betraying and killing Jon, a death that stands out among the series’ most shocking twists.

5. Season 2 (2012)

Expanding the World and Character Roster

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 9 – Blackwater
  • Episode 10 – Valar Morghulis

Season 2 of “Game of Thrones” continues to broaden the scope of its world and increase the level of danger, introducing numerous significant characters while giving emphasis to figures such as Stannis and Robb Stark. This approach muddies the waters regarding who the main characters truly are. Additionally, it starts to consolidate its central conflicts by frequently hinting at a greater peril lurking beyond politics. The second season exhibits a more conversational style than the first, underscoring that exceptional writing is the primary motor of the show, creating genuine tension and emotion through character dialogues and intelligent interactions.

Not only that, but this season also offered viewers a sneak peek at the series’ first major battle – the Battle of Blackwater – which certainly lived up to expectations. However, overall, the season functioned more as a preview of things to come, a transition between the introduction and the main event. In other words, it was a strong season for an excellent show; there’s nothing further to say.

4. Season 1 (2011)

A Strong Debut that Makes Introductions Seem Easy

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 9 – Baelor
  • Episode 10 – Fire and Blood

The first season of “Game of Thrones” was groundbreaking, leaving an indelible mark on television that is still unmatched today. It set the tone for the show’s unique blend of raw, authentic, and immersive medieval fantasy, a combination that remains unrivaled. With a daunting task of introducing numerous characters and settings, Season 1 managed to remain engaging and easy to follow, avoiding the risk of being overly complex or confusing.

In a skillfully crafted manner, featuring exceptional acting, captivating music, and undeniably shocking plot twists that left no one feeling safe in this fictional universe – such as the brutal beheadings of Ned Stark and Viserys Targaryen, and the prolonged, agonizing demise of Khal Drogo – Season 1 served as a remarkable debut and a powerful prelude to the complex web of intrigue that would unfold later. Despite its more leisurely pace to allow viewers to become accustomed to the setting, and its relatively minor impact in retrospect compared to subsequent events, the initial step is always the most challenging, and the first impression is crucial. Could Game of Thrones have attained such popularity if Season 1 had been different?

3. Season 3 (2013)

Gripping, Hope-Shattering, and Convincing

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 4 – And Now His Watch Is Ended
  • Episode 9 – The Rains of Castamere

As a devoted cinema enthusiast, I must say that Season 3 undeniably left an indelible mark, primarily through the unforgettable episode known as “The Rains of Castamere” – often hailed as one of the most potent and startling scenes in the series. This scene surpassed all expectations, outshining everything that had gone before in this universe. The brutal massacre of key characters sent shockwaves through many viewers, leaving them reeling for weeks on end. It was a topic of intense conversation and analysis across the land.

It’s wonderful to note that there are many more aspects to enjoy about this season, not just its thrilling conclusion. Now that George R.R. Martin’s world is well-established, we delve deeper into character development rather than introductions. Characters like Jaime Lannister, who were initially perceived as villains, are given a new light and have become popular favorites among viewers. The relationships between Robb Stark and Talisa Maegyr, Jon Snow and Ygritte, provided some of the most heartwarming and cherished moments, even though we knew they wouldn’t have happy endings. Daenerys Targaryen also saw significant growth, capturing the Unsullied and rising to power in the fiery season finale, making it effortless to support her as the true queen of Westeros and setting the stage for her victorious return.

2. Season 6 (2016)

Action-Packed Season to Deliver Resolutions for Major Arcs

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 5 – The Door
  • Episode 9 – Battle of the Bastards
  • Episode 10 – The Winds of Winter

It’s quite challenging to choose a clear favorite between the two most exhilarating seasons of “Game of Thrones,” considering how Season 6 is overflowing with intense action, shocking resolutions, and unforgettable moments that leave viewers in awe. From Cersei’s revenge against the High Sparrow, Hodor’s heroic act at the door, to the epic Battle of the Bastards – fans were spoiled with one thrilling climax after another. “Game of Thrones” consistently surpasses expectations and presents an even more awe-inspiring grand design, skillfully wrapping up several ongoing storylines in a way that’s both impressive and fulfilling. At the same time, it remains faithful to the fundamental elements that make the show truly special.

Without a doubt, Jon Snow shines brightest, his swift ascension to King in the North following his resurrection, while seeming slightly unusual, is undeniably merited. Sansa Stark moves into the second limelight, maturing into a composed and resolute individual, ready to tackle all her past fears. The season masterfully blends personal journeys with cast development and a gripping larger narrative, making Season 6 one of the most highly-regarded in Game of Thrones. It’s unfortunate that after reaching such a peak – showing us what a fitting finale could be like – the series began to stumble.

1. Season 4 (2014)

Witty, Brilliant, and Rewarding Watch from Start to Finish

Best Episodes:

  • Episode 2 – The Lion and the Rose
  • Episode 6 – The Laws of Gods and Men
  • Episode 10 – The Children

In contrast to Season 6, which boasts some of the most thrilling action sequences and momentous occurrences across all of Game of Thrones, Season 4 stands out for its exceptional writing and engaging dialogue. It skillfully unfolds verbal confrontations and emotional resolutions that are captivatingly compelling, making it challenging to divert one’s attention — this is precisely what GoT is all about. Although not as many groundbreaking events occur in Season 4 as in Season 6, it holds the distinction of having half of its episodes rated 9.7 by viewers, a mark that no other season has been able to surpass.

Season 4 of Game of Thrones predominantly focuses on the Lannister family, particularly noteworthy due to its complexity. Highlights include Joffrey’s murder at his wedding, Tyrion’s trial, and transformative moments for Tyrion, leading up to Tywin’s demise. Action enthusiasts were not disappointed either, with a thrilling duel between the Mountain and Oberyn Martell, as well as Jon Snow commanding the Night’s Watch in the epic battle against the Wildlings. The intriguing bond between the Hound and Arya, characterized by captivating interactions, was another standout feature. It’s challenging to identify any flaws in Season 4 given its impressive contribution to the overall narrative of Game of Thrones and its recognition as one of the best television seasons in general.

Read More

2025-04-20 11:39