American Horror Stories Bestie Fans Spot Huge Plot Hole That Will Blow Your Mind

by

Summary

  • “Bestie” episode of American Horror Stories is a fan favorite with strong themes of loneliness and online culture.
  • Fans have noted plot holes in “Bestie,” questioning how the character sustains herself in an abandoned house.
  • Despite some unanswered questions, “Bestie” is praised for its dark storyline, like other intriguing episodes in the series.

As a cinephile enthusiastically sharing my thoughts on American Horror Stories, I can confidently say that this series doesn’t just rehash horror tropes – it breathes new life into them. While the “Backrooms” episode might not delve deeply into its source material, the third season standout, “Bestie,” truly shines. This riveting tale premiered on FX on Hulu in October 2023 and featured Emma Halleen as Shelby Brubacker, a teenager yearning for connection who finds an online friend named Bestie, portrayed by Jessica Barden.

Regardless of how many seasons of American Horror Stories are released, fans will continue to debate “Bestie,” discussing everything from its exploration of loneliness, the impact of online culture on young adults, grief, and loss, to the surprising climax. I must admit that it’s a powerful episode that has stuck with me since my initial viewing. However, after learning about a plot inconsistency highlighted by a viewer, I can’t help but believe that there is a point in the episode that isn’t logically sound.

Fans Noticed One American Horror Stories “Bestie” Plot Hole & It Brings Up Some Questions

In a Reddit post, a viewer posed some thought-provoking queries regarding the “Bestie” episode of American Horror Stories.

What circumstances led my friend to reside in a deserted housing complex? How was she managing utilities like electricity, water, and internet there? How was she obtaining her meals?

Redditor @Picabo07 replied:

“I wondered that too. They left a lot open there.”

It’s a valid observation, and it’s got me pondering the same thought. I can’t help but wonder how Bestie manages to live in such an old house without anyone noticing. It’s not unbelievable, but it does raise questions about her access to Internet and electricity. Additionally, it seems improbable that she could afford groceries and clothes. Perhaps River Wallace, Shelby’s love interest whom Bestie manipulates, provides her with necessities. However, this arrangement can’t last forever, and one has to wonder how long they’ve known each other. It’s conceivable that Bestie has been deceiving several online acquaintances for years, convincing them to send her supplies. If that’s the case, though, I believe the episode should have clarified this aspect.

After watching several episodes of “American Horror Stories,” such as “Lake,” which feature supernatural elements, I found myself wishing that some paranormal aspects were incorporated into the episode titled “Bestie.” This could have provided a plausible explanation for any plot inconsistencies or confounding moments. Some viewers have pondered if Bestie was deceased throughout the entire storyline, and I too had questions about this. If Bestie was a ghost, then she might have been capable of activating the electricity in the abandoned house and even setting up an Internet connection. Granted, this could have seemed a bit cheesy, but it would have aligned with the episode’s overall tone.

In simpler terms, both “Bestie” and an episode from “Black Mirror” Season 7 named “Bête Noire” delve into intricate and potentially harmful relationships. Despite its flaws such as unanswered questions about the Internet and power supply, I find “Bestie” engaging because of the profound thoughts it provokes. The narrative leads Shelby on a dark path that overshadows these technical concerns. However, addressing some of those questions, even briefly, would have enhanced the viewing experience.

Fans Have Some Other Thoughts About The American Horror Stories “Bestie” Episode

Many viewers are enjoying the “Bestie” episode of “American Horror Stories,” yet some have raised concerns regarding the storyline and character development. In a separate Reddit discussion, a fan speculated that the character in question was actually the child of Mr. Nevin (Jeff Hiller), a theory that left other viewers intrigued and eager for such a twist.

“I’m so bummed we didn’t get any background on bestie at all.”

It’s clear that delving deeper into Bestie’s past could have been fascinating, and while we learn some aspects of her life, it seems there’s not enough depth. In another discussion, a fan expressed curiosity whether there might be a major disclosure regarding River, expressing it as: “Is there going to be a significant revelation about River?

Was I anticipating that the person would secretly be a close friend, or perhaps that my friend was some form of manipulative entity? Anybody else feel the same?

It’s true that some questions were left hanging at the end, but much like the season 3 episode “Tapeworm,” the latest installment titled “Bestie” was both intriguing and unsettling – exactly what I appreciate in an episode of American Horror Stories.

Read More

2025-05-03 20:05