Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked

Key Takeaways

  • Marvel’s best dark fantasy comics include eerie alternate universes and terrifying villains.
  • Iconic superheroes like Wanda, Thor, and Doctor Strange face dark forces beyond imagination.
  • Unlikely pairings, emotional journeys, and deep mysteries add layers to these complex characters and their dark stories.

As a die-hard Marvel enthusiast who’s been following these characters since the days of paper comics and Saturday morning cartoons, I must say that both these stories are absolute masterpieces in their own right.


I’ve always been captivated by the diverse range of genres that Marvel Comics delves into, from the gritty realism of urban teen dramas to the thrilling escapades of some of the most iconic sci-fi adventures in comic book lore. It’s amazing to see how they delve deep into fantastical realms, mythologies, and the supernatural, with characters like Doctor Strange, Scarlet Witch, and Moon Knight gracing their pages.

These tales, boasting some of the most intricate Marvel characters, seamlessly blend themes and visuals that can be quite eerie or grim. These eight comic books represent Marvel’s top dark fantasy narratives, as they are acclaimed for their compelling character representations and exceptional narrative skills.

8 Marvel 1602

Familiar Characters Take On New Identities

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
AuthorNeil Gaiman
IllustratorAndy Kubert
Year(s)2003-2004
Featured CharactersNick Fury, Stephen Strange, Peter Parker, Matt Murdock, Scott Summers, Robert Drake, Jean Grey, Clea, Steve Rogers, Wanda Maximoff, Pietro Maximoff, Charles Xavier, Natasha Romanoff, Otto von Doom

In the comic book series titled “Marvel 1602“, the characters aren’t identical to those commonly recognized by Marvel Comics fans. Although figures like Sir Nicholas Fury, Carlos Javier, and Peter Parquah echo popular heroes from the Marvel universe, they represent alterations of these characters in an alternate timeline known as Earth-311. This unique setting is during the colonial era of the 1600s, and it brings together various Marvel legends.

In this version of the Avengers, they encounter conflicts akin to those on Earth-616, with a recurring theme being an assassination plot against a queen, orchestrated by Otto von Doom, ruler of Latveria. One chilling aspect of this narrative is the predicament of the Fantastic Four in this universe, as they’re imprisoned by Doom. However, the comic may not be particularly intriguing for those without an affinity for Elizabethan history.

7 The Darkhold

Many Heroes Are Drawn To This MacGuffin

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
AuthorSteve Orlando, Daniel Kibblesmith, Jordie Bellaire, Ryan North, Mark Russell, Alex Paknadel
IllustratorCian Tormey, Federico Sabbatini, Claire Roe, Guillermo Sanna, David J. Cutler, Diogenes Neves
Year(s)2021-2022
Featured CharactersWanda Maximoff, Victor von Doom, Zora Vukovic, Tony Stark, Pepper Potts, Eric Brooks, Hobie Brown, Wilson Fisk, Amadeus Cho, Janet Van Dyne, Thor, Tigra, Hank Pym, Kang the Conqueror, Black Bolt, Peter Parker, Gwen Stacy, Reed Richards, Doctor Octopus, Chthon, Omega the Unknown

As a gamer immersed in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), I can tell you that the ominous Darkhold has been making waves lately, with its appearances in shows like “WandaVision” and “Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.” But for Elizabeth Olsen’s Scarlet Witch, this ominous tome wasn’t exactly a fresh revelation. In fact, the 2021 anthological comic book saga reveals how the Darkhold can twist even the noblest Marvel heroes into ruthless entities.

The storyline centers around Wanda, who brings together a group resembling the Avengers, called the Darkhold Defiled, comprised of Marvel heroes tainted by an ominous text. It’s common to witness characters such as Blade becoming corrupted, but it’s quite chilling to observe how the Darkhold influences figures like Peter Parker and the Wasp within the realm of Marvel Comics. Despite each individual comic being stronger than the whole, this dark turn can be downright terrifying in comparison.

6 Realm Of Kings

The Marvel Universe Gets Sick… In A Bad Way

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
AuthorDan Abnett, Andy Lanning
IllustratorLeonardo Manco, Mahmud Asrar
Year(s)2009
Featured CharactersWendell Vaughn, Peter Quill, Rocket Raccoon, Jack Flag, Groot, Drax, Richard Rider, Bruce Banner, Thor, Carol Danvers, Hank Pym, Wanda Maximoff, Steve Rogers, Tony Stark, Vision

In this comic book crossover, we followed one continuous storyline that delved into a troubled era of Marvel’s timeline. After Black Bolt’s T-Bomb explosion, a tear called the Fault appeared, originating from another dimension. This tear, referred to as the “Fault,” seeped into Earth-616, revealing to our familiar heroes an evil-dominated universe, which we call the “Cancerverse.” In this world, wickedness has utterly conquered all that is good.

In this single encounter, Earth-616’s Guardians of the Galaxy engage in a conflict with a different universe’s version of the Avengers, referred to as the Revengers. These Revengers are significantly more fearsome than their counterparts from Earth-616. Although the magnitude of this event may make it less compelling compared to the more intimate tales on this list, it is still worth reading for providing a chilling fantasy scene that adds to Marvel’s science fiction heroes’ experiences.

5 Black Knight: Curse Of The Ebony Blade

Dane Whitman Comes Into His Own

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
Author​​​​​​​Simon Spurrier
IllustratorSergio Fernandez Davila
Year(s)2021
Featured CharactersDane Whitman, Jacks Chopra, Phillip, Elsa Bloodstone, Mordred, Steve Rogers, Thor, Carol Danvers, T’Challa

Previously, Dane Whitman had a secondary role in the Avengers narrative. However, in this 2021 miniseries, he transforms from a side character into an Arthurian hero who confronts various forms of darkness. This includes the dark sorcery of Sir Mordred under the Twilight Banner and universal struggles such as grief and despair. Throughout his journey, he forges alliances with his daughter, Jack, and Elsa Bloodstone.

This work embodies the quintessential essence of fantasy that one would find in Marvel comics, blending the legends of Camelot and a sword consuming the darkness within its user, offering an exciting balance of action and emotion. It’s my hope that Marvel will handle this tale with care and eventually bring it to life through Kit Harington’s character, Dane Whitman, who I believe has the potential to become an Avenger in the future.

4 Moon Knight: From The Dead

A Different Take On The Fist Of Khonshu

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
Author​​​​​​​Warren Ellis
IllustratorDeclan Shalvey
Year(s)2014-2015
Featured CharactersMarc Spector/Steven Grant/Jake Lockley, Khonshu, Dr. Skelton, Jean-Paul Duchaimp, Black Spectre, Elisa Warsame, Gloria Roza, Nepthys

In a refreshingly innovative twist, not many writers have managed to redefine a character as extensively as Warren Ellis did with Moon Knight. What sets this Marvel Comics character apart is the complex nature of Marc Spector’s multiple personalities, but the story From the Dead primarily focuses on the fresh identity of “Mr. Knight,” who opts for a sharp all-white suit instead of the traditional cape and staff.

Similar to the James Robinson “Scarlet Witch” comic, this Moon Knight-centered narrative delves into a mystery reminiscent of a detective story, as Marc Spector/Mr. Knight navigates not just a labyrinth of criminal activity but also his inner self. If you were captivated by Oscar Isaac’s portrayal in the “Moon Knight” Disney+ series, then “From the Dead” promises to fulfill your anticipation for a second season, while leaving you yearning for even more adventures of the Egyptian hero.

3 Scarlet Witch

Wanda Uncovers Her Past In This Mystery Saga

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
AuthorJames Robinson
IllustratorVanesa Del Rey, Marco Rudy, Steve Dillon, Chris Visions
Year(s)2016-2017
Featured CharactersWanda Maximoff, Agatha Harkness, Hekate, Emerald Warlock, Ringmaster, Pietro Maximoff, Black Bullet, Vision

The stories of the Scarlet Witch have always treaded into dark fantasy territory, but few are as well-constructed and visually stunning as James Robinson’s 2016 series. This comic book saga plays out more like a noir, as Wanda investigates a disturbance in the forces of witchcraft, aided by the ghost of her mentor, the now-iconic Agatha Harkness.

As a fellow enthusiast of Wanda Maximoff, if you’re yearning for a narrative that delves deeply into the realm of the occult and her journey as a sorceress, this run is precisely what you’ve been craving. The artwork, with its surreal and captivating design, might even surprise those accustomed to traditional Marvel Comics aesthetics. This isn’t just a story—it’s Wanda’s narrative: a tale of deceit, enigma, homicide, and despair!

2 Thor: The God Butcher

Thor’s Darkest Story Isn’t As Fun As Its MCU Adaptation

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
AuthorJason Aaron
IllustratorEsad Ribic
Year(s)2013-2014
Featured CharactersThor, Gorr the God-Butcher, Tony Stark, King Thor

As a devoted admirer, I can’t help but express my awe for the groundbreaking comic series arc penned by Jason Aaron that significantly reshaped the mighty Thor. This transformative narrative served as the blueprint for the captivating portrayals of Chris Hemsworth’s character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Yet, it’s essential to acknowledge that the original comic was imbued with a profound sense of darkness. The God of Thunder found himself locked in an epic struggle against none other than Gorr – a relentless deity-slayer, hell-bent on vengeance for the annihilation of his people due to divine negligence.

For one of Marvel’s few almighty characters, the challenge of Gorr is enough to nearly kill the god of thunder. He recruits an army known as the Black Berserkers, demon-esque creatures who slaughter thousands on their bloody path to find Thor. The stakes aren’t just high in this comic book saga, but Gorr proves to be a truly terrifying villain in Marvel Comics canon.

1 Doctor Strange & Doctor Doom: Triumph And Torment

An Unlikely Duo Faces A Hellish Trial

Best Dark Fantasy Marvel Comics, Ranked
Author​​​​​​​Roger Stern, Gerry Conway, Bill Mantlo
IllustratorKevin Nowlan, Gene Colan
Year(s)1989
Featured CharactersStephen Strange, Victor von Doom, Aged Genghis, Cynthia von Doom, Mephisto, Baron Sabbat, the Ancient One

One unforgettable dark fantasy saga in Marvel Comics lore is called “Triumph and Torment“, where Doctor Strange and Doctor Doom teamed up on an adventure to the underworld of Mephisto, with the aim of freeing the spirit of Doom’s mother. If there’s a more intriguing synopsis for a Marvel Comics tale, I can’t imagine what it might be!

As I delve into this chilling comic book series, what truly grips me is the intricate development of Doctor Doom from a one-dimensional supervillain bent on global domination, to a character with layers of complexity. The enigmatic sorcerer Strange serves as both antagonist and guide, leading him through the darkest realms. This tale is not just about power struggles, but a deeply moving exploration that has left an indelible mark on Marvel Comics fans like me.

​​​​​​​

Read More

2024-09-13 09:34