Dexter: Resurrection – Should Dexter Be The Actual Villain?

by

Key Takeaways

  • Dexter might become the actual villain in Resurrection, deviating from his anti-hero role.
  • Fans may initially resist Dexter’s villainous portrayal, especially across multiple seasons.
  • Dexter’s transformation into a villain in season 2 paved the way for an enticing storyline in the series.

As a die-hard Dexter fan with years of immersion into the twisted world of this anti-hero, I’m intrigued by the prospect of Dexter Morgan becoming the actual villain in Resurrection. Having watched Dexter since its inception, I can attest to the series’ knack for surprising us with unexpected twists and turns. The idea of Dexter turning from a protagonist to an antagonist is not only thrilling but also reminiscent of his villainous portrayal in season 2.

In January 2025, production for the revival of “Dexter: Resurrection” kicks off and it’s slated for a summer release on Paramount+ and Showtime. Michael C. Hall will reprise his role as Dexter Morgan, battling for survival after being wounded by his son Harrison. The series has traditionally portrayed Dexter as the anti-hero, but recent events in “Dexter: New Blood” hint at a possible transformation into the true villain – a twist that could prove intriguing.

In the television series Dexter: Resurrection, the main challenge lies in extending Dexter’s narrative over multiple seasons, given that fans may struggle to accept a long-term villainous portrayal of Dexter. However, it could be intriguing to present Dexter as an antagonist, particularly if beloved characters such as Angel Batista and Vince Masuka are reintroduced to the plotline.

Dexter Morgan Was Essentially The Villain In the Second Season Of The Original Dexter Series

2007 marked the start of Dexter’s second season, following a highly successful debut. Viewers were intrigued to learn who the main antagonist would be for Dexter’s second round, only to be surprised when they discovered it was none other than Dexter Morgan himself, in a twisted sense. Bodies of various victims, dismembered and found at the bottom of the Miami waters, were attributed to a serial killer dubbed ‘The Bay Harbor Butcher’. Indeed, ‘the butcher’ turned out to be Dexter Morgan, who spent the entire season dodging suspicion. In essence, Dexter played both the villainous role and the protagonist, making for an exhilarating narrative in the world of Dexter.

I’m a very neat monster.

Lila Tournay, who was Dexter’s love interest, turned out to be the main adversary by killing James Doakes. However, it’s important to remember that Dexter had been planning to frame Doakes as the Bay Harbor Butcher, and he might have had to kill him anyway. In essence, Doakes served as an antagonist in many ways, but he violated Dexter’s code, which led to his death. During season 2, Dexter can be seen as a villain, yet the audience found themselves supporting his actions. As the series progressed and introduced more disturbed killers, there was never any doubt about who the viewers were rooting for – the serial killer with a code. However, in the upcoming season titled “Resurrection,” it may be worthwhile to reconsider Dexter’s portrayal and present him in a new light.

Dexter Crossed The Line In New Blood When He Killed An Innocent Man, So Resurrection Could Expand On This And Frame Him As The Villain

Dexter: Resurrection
Starring Michael C. Hall (confirmed), Jack Alcott, David Zayas, Julia Jones, C. S Lee and Desmond Harrington (all rumored)
Created by Clyde Phillips
Executive Producers Clyde Phillips and Michael C. Hall

In the second season, the show Dexter was particularly successful because it transformed the protagonist, Dexter Morgan, into a character that could be perceived as the antagonist. This move, which capitalized on the trend of antiheroes, has resonated with audiences for quite some time. If the revival season, Resurrection, continues this trajectory, it might even make Dexter the main villain. In the series New Blood, Dexter had already embarked on a sinister path after unjustifiably killing Coach Logan, who was revealed to be the Bay Harbor Butcher. The plot of Resurrection is still unknown, but it seems that Dexter will likely be evading the authorities. It’s also possible that a new villain without Dexter’s moral code will emerge, creating tension between them. However, with Dexter being one of the most notorious serial killers in history, law enforcement might be more focused on bringing him to justice rather than pursuing another villain.

In a different context, it’s important to note that Dexter shouldn’t kill innocent people during the storyline of “Resurrection”, as it would contradict his character development and alienate viewers significantly. However, much like Logan’s demise in “New Blood”, Dexter might be driven by his dark side to choose between freedom and capture, which could potentially lead him down a more villainous path. This shift in character seems to be a deliberate move by the creators of “New Blood” towards making Dexter into an antagonist at the end of the limited series. If this trend continues in “Resurrection”, it might feel disjointed if they were to reverse course, especially since this new series is planned for multiple seasons.

Read More

2024-11-05 05:03