Summary
- American Horror Story season 13 could be based on the urban legend “The babysitter and the man upstairs” with a twist.
- The new season may feature Emma Roberts, known for playing a variety of horror roles, making her return.
- Urban legends have been the basis for episodes in American Horror Stories, providing a great foundation for a creepy season.
In 2020, it was announced that the thirteenth season of American Horror Story would be released. The last three seasons have delved into chilling tales set in a seaside town, involving extraterrestrials, a murderer in New York City, and a problematic pregnancy. Ryan Murphy’s acclaimed horror anthology series never fails to surprise and unnerve viewers, with fans frequently speculating about what might transpire next.
Fans are eager to learn more specific story details for the upcoming season 13 of American Horror Story, though until then, people are conjuring up ideas about what the main plotline might be. What if this season drew inspiration from the “Bestie” episode of American Horror Stories and presented a chilling narrative centered around technology? Could Sarah Paulson reprise her role and portray yet another captivating character? Additionally, it would be intriguing if season 13 of American Horror Story was influenced by an urban legend, and one of the well-known cast members could make a comeback.
American Horror Story Season 13 Should Feature The Urban Legend The Babysitter And The Man Upstairs Along With Emma Roberts

Season 13 of American Horror Story might weave a tale inspired by the urban legend “The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs.” This chilling urban legend has served as inspiration for numerous slasher movies, such as the classic 1974 film Black Christmas, its remakes in 2006 and 2019, and the 1979 film When a Stranger Calls, starring Carol Kane. In this rendition, there could be an intriguing twist with the babysitter character turning out to be the killer herself, or perhaps multiple killers are after her.
As a film enthusiast, I find myself pondering over how intriguing it would be if the upcoming season 13 of “American Horror Story” veered towards a more comedic tone compared to some of its previous installments. A campy slasher narrative, inspired by an urban legend, could effectively blend humor with chills. To ensure a captivating storyline that spans over 12 episodes, I envision this season revolving around a protagonist who is a college student or in their twenties, taking on a babysitting job for the weekend. This would provide a refreshing departure from the usual storylines we’ve seen so far.
The secret of the babysitter could be gradually unraveled throughout the season, culminating in a shocking revelation in the final episode. Furthermore, I believe it would be amusing to incorporate elements that poke fun at the clichés often found in haunted house horror films, adding a layer of satire and making it more relatable for modern audiences.
In addition to centering around an urban legend, it would be fantastic if season 13 of “American Horror Stories” also featured Emma Roberts. She delivered a remarkable performance as final girl Brooke Thompson in “American Horror Story: 1984,” which was season 9, and she also portrayed the wicked witch Madison Montgomery in “AHS: Coven.” More recently, Roberts played the lead character Anna Victoria Alcott, an actress dealing with a peculiar and eerie pregnancy in “American Horror Stories: Delicate,” which ended on a thrilling cliffhanger.
Roberts boasts an impressive background in horror movies, having portrayed Jill Roberts in “Scream 4” and the enigmatic character Joan Marsh in Osgood Perkins’s “The Blackcoat’s Daughter”. She also took on the ruthless role of Chanel #1 in Ryan Murphy’s humorous TV series “Scream Queens”. Given her ability to convincingly portray both villains and final girls, she would be ideally suited for a season revolving around a fresh twist on an urban legend with a chilling atmosphere.
Given that Roberts has been a recurring character across multiple seasons and consistently expresses enthusiasm for the series, it seems plausible that she might be open to returning in future episodes. Back in 2014, she shared with E! News her positive sentiments about the show.
I find American Horror Story downright terrifying. However, I enjoyed it during the first two seasons prior to my current engagement.”
“Initially, I found American Horror Story quite chilling but now it scares me to death. I used to be a fan of the show up until my recent involvement.
American Horror Stories Has Featured Urban Legends Before

In each season of American Horror Story, horror motifs are employed, but it seems that two episodes from the spin-off series American Horror Stories are built on urban legends. Familiarity with these storylines enhances viewers’ pleasure as the unexpected twists in each episode add to their enjoyment.
In the fifth episode of season 2 titled “Bloody Mary,” American Horror Stories delves into the chilling legend by the same name, a tale that often echoed in schoolyards and among peers. Here, a band of friends unwittingly unleash a malevolent entity, causing their lives to spiral into a nightmare.
It seems that the chilling urban tale of “the killer hiding in the backseat” appears to have served as the basis for American Horror Stories season 2’s episode titled “Drive.” In this narrative, a character named Marci (portrayed by Bella Thorne), finds herself being pursued on the road by another vehicle. Just like the thrilling American Horror Story episode “Bestie,” there is an unexpected twist, and the plot takes an unexpected turn that leaves viewers in shock.
Read More
- UNLOCK ALL MINECRAFT LAUNCHER SKILLS
- Unaware Atelier Master: New Trailer Reveals April 2025 Fantasy Adventure!
- The White Rabbit Revealed in Devil May Cry: Who Is He?
- REPO: How To Fix Client Timeout
- One Piece Episode 1124 Release Date And Time Countdown
- 8 Best Souls-Like Games With Co-op
- 10 Characters You Won’t Believe Are Coming Back in the Next God of War
- Minecraft Movie Meal Madness
- Top 8 UFC 5 Perks Every Fighter Should Use
- Unlock Roslit Bay’s Bestiary: Fisch Fishing Guide
2025-04-07 18:35