Harry Potter: Why Argus Filch Hates Hogwarts Students, Explained

by

Key Takeaways

  • Filch’s resentment towards students stems from being a squib, unable to perform magic like them.
  • Peeves the Poltergeist adds to Filch’s frustration by constantly causing chaos at Hogwarts.
  • HBO’s Harry Potter series could benefit from exploring Filch’s backstory for more character depth.

As a dedicated Harry Potter fan who has spent countless hours immersed in the magical world J.K. Rowling created, I must say that Argus Filch is one character that deserves more attention than he often gets.

In the realm of Harry Potter, Argus Filch serves as the diligent caretaker, always ready to tackle tasks at Hogwarts. He’s particularly keen on disciplining students, which he seems to view as an integral part of his role. Filch is known for his grumpy demeanor and takes great pride in his work, often perceiving the students as a nuisance rather than the future guardians of magic.

Filch, despite having a minor role in the Harry Potter films, has no qualms about reprimanding students for being beyond boundaries or past curfew, and it appears he finds some satisfaction in his limited authority. His grumpiness stems from certain circumstances, which he often expresses through his harsh treatment of younger students.

Argus Filch Is A Squib And Is Jealous

One significant factor contributing to Filch’s persistent irritability is his status as a squib, meaning he lacks the ability to cast spells. Unlike Hagrid, who is barred from using magic, Filch simply doesn’t possess the genetic makeup required, which sets him apart in a unique and likely frustrating way given his daily immersion in the magical world. It’s not hard to empathize with his feelings when he sees new students arrive each year, all capable of performing magic, while he remains incapable. This situation undoubtedly stirs up frustration within him. Additionally, when students misbehave or disregard instructions, it irritates Filch more because they possess magical abilities, and he perceives their actions as carelessness towards something he can’t experience.

Albus Dumbledore tolerates Filch’s grumpy demeanor, understanding the stress and hardship he endures. Despite being a non-magical person (a squib), Filch is diligent in his duties and takes his job seriously, which earns him Dumbledore’s respect. Moreover, Dumbledore provides Filch with a position and a secure environment at Hogwarts. However, the school setting unfortunately fuels Filch’s growing resentment, as he vents it on the students rather than the professors, who are more powerful and knowledgeable. Caught between a rock and a hard place, Filch finds himself stuck in a job that brings him misery at Hogwarts, yet he struggles to find alternative employment elsewhere.

The Issue With Peeves The Poltergiest

A significant factor behind Filch’s constant irritability is a mischievous poltergeist named Peeves, who haunts Hogwarts. Unlike other spirits at the school that prefer to keep quiet and let things be, Peeves enjoys wreaking havoc and bothering people as much as he can. This can be quite bothersome for anyone unfortunate enough to cross his path, and it’s usually Filch who bears the brunt of his antics.

As a devoted Harry Potter fan, it’s regrettable that the character Peeves was left out of the films, leaving many unaware of his existence and the dynamic tension between him and Filch. In the books, however, they are formidable adversaries, with Peeves consistently causing trouble for Filch, making his life a nightmare. Peeves is a significant factor in Filch’s behavior because there’s no way to punish him effectively for his misdeeds, as he can get away with doing the same things to students. Filch often pushes for Peeves’ expulsion from Hogwarts, but to no avail. Instead, Filch is left grappling with Peeves undoing his efforts or making his life more challenging simply because it adds an element of fun to his existence.

HBO’s Harry Potter Series Should Explain Argus Filch’s Backstory

In the films, Filch is often portrayed as a minor character who is more of an irritant than a genuine danger to Harry, Ron, and Hermione. Although they may annoy him, he typically doesn’t actively antagonize people like a typical villain. Instead, he seems focused on doing his job diligently, and taking disciplinary action against students brings him pleasure. However, the books offer a richer exploration of Filch’s background and character development compared to the movies, a detail that HBO could explore further in their adaptation.

As they prepare for the new TV series, showrunners will aim to differentiate it from films and add a distinctive touch. Delving into characters like Filch can be one method to achieve this. The novels contain a wealth of information about him, understanding his motivations behind his resentment would make his character less stereotypical and more complex. This approach allows the audience to empathize with him better, fostering a stronger connection.

Filch is a testament to the intricate character development J.K. Rowling crafted in her novels, where each character serves a distinct role and adds depth to the narrative. Expanding on Filch’s personality could make the Harry Potter series on HBO even more enthralling because it would allow viewers to discover fresh insights about familiar characters, enriching their overall experience.

Read More

2024-12-06 18:33