Harry Potter’s Two-Way Mirror: The Emotional Backstory You Never Knew!

by

Summary

  • The two-way mirror in Harry Potter wasn’t fully explained in the movies, creating confusion among viewers.
  • The mirror functions as a communication tool and plays a significant role in Harry’s interactions and emotions.
  • The mirror’s backstory, its connection to Sirius Black, and emotional impact on Harry were more detailed in the books.

The Harry Potter films often leave some parts of the story unclear because directors had to condense a lot of detail from JK Rowling’s books into each movie, given their limited running time. As a result, certain crucial scenes in the Harry Potter movies may not receive the necessary explanation or background information for those who haven’t read the books to fully grasp their significance.

One unexplained plot point in the Harry Potter series is the two-way mirror shard that appears in both _Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1_ and _Part 2_. Although it’s depicted frequently enough for viewers to understand its purpose, there’s no explanation given as to how Harry comes into possession of it. Given its significance as a crucial magical artifact, not providing an explanation in the films was somewhat daring.

What Is The Two-Way Mirror?

The fragment of mirror that Harry Potter carries in the last two films serves as a straightforward yet potent magical device. Unlike other complex uses of magic, this one is simpler, facilitating communication or viewing activities between those holding matched mirrors at any given moment. In addition, it can swiftly reveal locations of people in tricky circumstances, making it particularly useful during such times.

How Does Harry Potter Use It?

In the movie “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 1”, Harry resorts to using a mirror when he finds himself imprisoned within Malfoy Manor alongside some companions. As events unfold, Hermione Granger is subjected to torture at the hands of Bellatrix Lestrange, leaving our heroes in a dire predicament as they come increasingly close to being exposed by Lord Voldemort’s loyal followers. However, Harry employs the mirror to send for aid, which eventually leads Dobby to locate him. This method of communication is hinted at but not fully shown, contributing to the confusion felt by viewers, as they are typically expected to grasp such plot points without explicit explanation.

In a crucial moment, Dobby steps in and saves everyone, sacrificing himself to free Harry and his companions from a dangerous predicament. Later, in the final movie, the mirror reappears, with Aberforth Dumbledore disclosing that he had possessed it all along. He employs this mirror to monitor Harry’s progress as he embarks on his mission to destroy the Horcruxes, showing a deeper concern for his late brother’s pupil than initially apparent. Unfortunately, Aberforth’s mysterious demeanor leaves much unexplained, fueling speculation and further bewildering the audience about the mirror’s true purpose.

How Harry Uses The Two-Way Mirror In The Books

As a devoted cinephile delving into the captivating world of Harry Potter, I can’t help but notice the intriguing distinctions between the novels and their cinematic adaptations. One such difference lies in the enigmatic magical artifact, which plays a considerably larger role in the books. In “Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix,” Sirius Black introduces this object to Harry, allowing them to communicate silently while Harry is still at Hogwarts, as the venerable school was not a safe haven for Sirius. Consequently, he resorted to using this artifact as a means of communication, given that physically visiting Harry would have been perilous. However, in the movies, Harry doesn’t use it due to his fear of endangering Sirius if they were caught communicating in such a way. This aspect would have added depth to the movie, as it underscored the strong bond between them and their emotional connection long before Sirius’s tragic demise.

In the specific book, Harry resorts to using the mirror following Sirius’ demise, harboring hope that his godfather might still be alive. However, this proves to be untrue. Overwhelmed by the inability to reach Sirius’ spirit, he shatters the mirror, underscoring the profound effect of Sirius’ death on Harry. This scene not only demonstrates that the mirror serves more than just a whimsical magical artifact; it also carries deep emotion and consistently triggers memories of Sirius for Harry. Incorporating this detail in the movies would have enriched Harry’s backstory, made the emotional situation more impactful, and softened the surprise when Dobby emerged. Since the mirror was vital to his survival, a clearer explanation of its significance would have been beneficial. Hopefully, HBO will take the opportunity to elaborate on this aspect in their television series, as it will allow for a more detailed exploration of smaller details that distinguish the series from the movies.

Essentially, leaving the two-way mirror unexplained in the last two Harry Potter films didn’t detract from their understanding, as events remained clear. However, including Dobby’s backstory might have elevated the Harry Potter series, particularly enriching Harry’s personal connection with Sirius, which could have been crucial details left out but were significant in this case.

Read More

2025-01-15 22:03