Hogwarts Legacy: Ways To Shake Up A Second Playthrough

It’s hard to believe, but Hogwarts Legacy has already been released for over three years! Time really flies, doesn’t it?

It’s good to be back! So, Hogwarts Legacy did really well, which basically meant a sequel was inevitable. But these days, big games take forever to make. Honestly, I’m thinking Hogwarts Legacy 2 might not even come out until the PlayStation 6 is out! That means we really need to enjoy the first game while we can. It wasn’t perfect, sure, but Hogwarts Legacy was a genuinely magical experience, and it gives me plenty of reasons to jump back in for another playthrough – or maybe even a third!

While the basic gameplay remains the same, players can still have a unique experience with each playthrough, making it a great choice for those returning to the wizarding world after some time. If you’re craving more Harry Potter, revisiting Hogwarts Legacy is worthwhile, but try these suggestions to make it feel like a new adventure instead of just repeating the same story.

5. Changing Houses

Gryffindor, Hufflepuff, Ravenclaw, or Slytherin

Choosing a different house can change proceedings.
Roleplay can also play a huge part.
This can be selected when introduced to the Sorting Hat.

When players start Hogwarts Legacy for the first time, they’ll probably pick the house that feels most like home – whether it’s brave Gryffindor, clever Ravenclaw, kind Hufflepuff, or cunning Slytherin. Because fans of the Harry Potter series have always loved sorting themselves into houses, it’s a natural choice to play through the game as the house you’ve always identified with.

One of the best ways to experience Hogwarts Legacy again is to choose a different house. Each house offers unique conversations and experiences within its common room. Slytherin students, in particular, will have more interactions with the important character Sebastien Sallow, and can unlock quests focused on the Unforgivable Curses. Plus, each house has its own special questline that becomes available after finishing all the initial student quests. This adds variety to a second playthrough and lets you see more of the world from a different perspective.

4. Unlock Different Talents

Some Talents Remain Elusive In A First Playthrough

Hogwarts Legacy has a level cap of 40, with 48 talents available for purchase.
Experimenting with character building can provide a new experience.

When you first play Hogwarts Legacy, it’s common to not unlock every skill. Because you can only reach level 40 and there are 48 talents available, you’ll need to prioritize which skills are most important to you.

Players might have skipped certain parts of the talent tree during their first time playing, like the Room of Requirement, which focuses on plants and potions, or the Dark Arts. These choices can significantly change how the game is played, letting you become a powerful witch or wizard, or a more benevolent one. Experimenting with different skill builds can make a new playthrough of Hogwarts Legacy feel fresh and exciting.

3. Learn The Unforgivable Curses

Become A True Master Of The Dark Arts

Crucio, Imperio and Avada Kedavra allow players to become even stronger.
Unforgivable Curses end fights quickly.

Delve into the world of dark magic and become a powerful, evil witch or wizard. Master spells like “Avada Kedavra” for instantly defeating opponents, “Imperio” to take complete control of enemies, and “Crucio” to inflict agonizing pain and drain their life force.

Some players might naturally explore the darker side of magic during their first time playing, but if you prefer a more heroic character, experimenting with the Dark Arts can add excitement on a second playthrough. You can fully embrace becoming a powerful, evil witch or wizard, unlocking abilities through the Unforgivable Curses. Or, if you’ve already mastered those dark spells, you could try a playthrough as a compassionate witch or wizard who actively avoids them and their corrupting influence.

Who’s That Character? Identify the silhouettes before time runs out.

Easy (7.5s)Medium (5.0s)Hard (2.5s)Permadeath (2.5s)

5.0s

0/10

Results

High Score: 0 —

More Games

2. Engage With Classmates

Everyone In Hogwarts Has Their Own Story To Tell

Hogwarts Legacy has a wide range of side-quests to complete.
With 57 side-quests to complete, these can add a huge amount to a second playthrough.

Because the main story of Hogwarts Legacy is so captivating, players might miss some side quests during their first time through the game. A second playthrough is the perfect opportunity to fully experience everything Hogwarts Legacy offers by completing all of those optional quests.

How you experience the game again really depends on your initial playthrough. Even if you completed every side quest the first time, you can still make things interesting by making different choices at the end. For instance, instead of returning Zenobia Noke’s Gobstones, you could choose to keep them – after all, you earned them! This adds another layer of role-playing to a second run through Hogwarts Legacy.

1. Turn Off the Heads-Up Display

A Big Change To Visuals

Removing the HUD can fully immerse players in the Wizarding World.
Adds the extra challenge of remembering what spells are in which slots.

One easy way to make Hogwarts Legacy even more immersive is to turn off the on-screen display. This encourages players to really explore the game world to find items and remember their spells, creating a beautiful and captivating experience within the Wizarding World.

Disabling the on-screen display in Hogwarts Legacy significantly increases the difficulty. Players will need to rely on their own sense of direction to navigate Hogwarts Castle and explore, making it feel like their first time as a student, even if they’ve played before. For a truly immersive experience, players can also choose to disable fast travel. While this heightened challenge isn’t for everyone, the increased immersion it provides is well worth the effort.

2026-02-20 17:35