How Dune: Prophecy Recreates a Key Moment for House Atreides and Harkonnen

by

As a seasoned movie buff with a penchant for epic sagas, I must say that the HBO series “Dune: Prophecy” has truly piqued my interest. The way they’ve delved deeper into the complexities of characters like Tula Harkonnen and Orry Atreides, giving their love story the attention it deserves, is nothing short of commendable.

In the HBO series “Dune: Prophecy”, they skillfully interweave an unique narrative with elements from Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson’s “Great Schools of Dune” novel trilogy. A significant incident borrowed from the novels is House Harkonnen’s brutal retribution against House Atreides, who were responsible for the former’s exile and disgrace.

In a thoughtful move, Dune: Prophecy expands upon an incident of lesser importance in the original novels, deepening Tula Harkonnen’s character and setting up a critical decision that significantly impacts her life. Game Rant had a chat with Emma Canning, who plays young Tula Harkonnen, about this pivotal scene and other aspects of the production.

The Fate Of Tula Harkonnen And Orry Atreides

In the book “Mentats of Dune”, Tula Harkonnen – sister of the influential Bene Gesserit Valya Harkonnen – secretly wed Orry Atreides and ended his life on their wedding night. This act was allegedly carried out at Valya’s behest, as a means of retribution for the death of Tula’s elder brother, Griffin Harkonnen, who fell victim to an Atreides.

The incident is generally implied rather than thoroughly depicted, mainly recounted from Vorian Atreides’ perspective – the one who killed Griffin. He learns about it afterward, and though he tries, his attempt to avenge Griffin by killing Tula ends unsuccessfully.

In “Dune: Prophecy”, Tula’s decision to pursue Orry is portrayed as a personal choice, distinct from any influence from Valya. The narrative then primarily revolves around Tula, instead of Vorian. The third episode of Season 1, titled “Sisterhood Above All”, delves into the blossoming romance between Tula and Orry, depicting sincere affection growing between them. Tula reveals her true surname to Orry, who accepts her despite their feuding families. She contemplates abandoning her identity and staying with him, but ends up carrying out a murder, killing not just Orry, but also numerous members of his family, leaving only a young boy she had befriended unharmed.

Tula And Orry’s Love Story Felt Like “A Short Film” To Emma Canning

Canning cherished collaborating with Milo Callahan, who portrayed Orry, and they formed a genuine connection during their scenes. Canning warmly recalled the experience of working alongside Callahan and director Richard J. Lewis on that particular episode.

For two weeks straight, I engaged in horse training alongside [Milo]. This experience fostered a casual camaraderie between us and allowed for discussions about that particular plotline. Given its self-contained nature, we often joked that it felt like producing a mini film with Richard. It was incredibly personal and cozy. Milo would frequently question, “Is this truly Dune?

Opting to depict the evolving romance between Tula and Orry, instead of merely recounting subsequent events, is a potent creative decision. This approach allows viewers to witness their love blossom firsthand and feel deeply affected when Tula ultimately carries out the act. Canning characterized Tula’s decision as an impulsive one, revealing that she portrayed Tula as wavering multiple times during the scene. As Canning put it, Tula’s actions are “driven by emotions,” “raw,” and a manifestation of her survival instincts.

Fundamentally, the interactions between Tula and Orry significantly shape the narrative of “Dune: Prophecy,” transcending Tula’s lingering remorse and internal turmoil. The repercussions of their actions endanger not only the entire empire but also the Bene Gesserit Sisterhood, which includes both Valya and Tula. A sequence of tender, emotional, and impactful scenes that beautifully illustrate a tragic romance ultimately prove pivotal to every aspect of “Dune: Prophecy.” According to Emma Canning, Tula’s impulsive choice – that one instant decision – altered everything dramatically.

Read More

2024-12-21 18:54