In A Perfect World We Would Have Gotten Mike Flanagan’s I Know What You Did Last Summer, Not The Latest Mess From Sony

by

Summary

  • Flanagan’s vision for an ‘IKWYDLS’ reboot was promising but not realized.
  • The 2025 film’s lack of depth & character development left much to be desired.
  • Flanagan’s potential involvement could have elevated the reboot immensely.

Despite the fact that horror movies and autumn seem to be a perfect match (with crisp leaves and pumpkins), it’s also enjoyable to relax in an air-conditioned theater and watch the newest slasher flick. As a connoisseur of the horror genre, especially ’90s slashers, I was eagerly anticipating the reboot of “I Know What You Did Last Summer“. Unfortunately, this film falls short as it’s not scary, the characters aren’t intriguing, and the plot is too similar to the ’90s version. When “IKWYDLS ” debuted in 1997, it rode the wave of excitement following the success of the first “Scream” movie, which won over audiences in 1996 with its clever humor and iconic Ghostface killer. The reboot offers some nostalgic moments, but it’s no match for the original fun.

Excited as a Mike Flanagan admirer, I couldn’t wait to learn he was crafting his unique take on the I Know What You Did Last Summer film. Regrettably, it didn’t materialize, but my imagination keeps running wild wondering what an amazing production that could have been.

I Wish Mike Flanagan Had Directed The I Know What You Did Last Summer Reboot

Mike Flanagan is set to take on directing a fresh adaptation of ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’, while Jeffrey Howard will be crafting the script. According to Howard’s recent interview with Bloody Disgusting, they have had discussions with Original Film, the studio founded by Neil Moritz, who was involved in the original film’s production. As Howard elaborated, one executive emphasized that as long as the story aligns thematically with the title and the related universe, creators are free to come up with their own ideas.

Howard continued:

Our goal was to create something reminiscent of an Agatha Christie production – essentially multiple stage adaptations of her works, overseen by her, that offered engaging and entertaining mysteries centered around a group of characters thrown into challenging situations.

According to Bloody Disgusting, Howard’s screenplay titled “I Know What You Did Last Summer” revolves around four friends vacationing in Antigua. Their peaceful lives are disrupted when a woman named Christie vanishes. Subsequently, one of them, Matt, ends up in prison for the crime. Upon his release, he receives similar threatening messages as seen in the original slasher film. Additionally, there’s a true-crime podcast dedicated to this intriguing case.

I find it intriguing that Flanagan and Howard decided to put a unique twist on this story, rather than producing another uninspired remake like the current reboot of “I Know What You Did Last Summer” in theaters. As long as they incorporate a hook similar to the ’90s movie, I’m open to substantial changes. However, the 2025 film seems to struggle by sticking too closely to the original plot. It fails to deliver the captivating and skillfully crafted characters that made the 1997 version memorable. The reboot is marred by cringe-worthy dialogue, Gen Z stereotypes, and a generic backdrop. Frankly, it’s not particularly noteworthy.

Being a great admirer of Flanagan’s work, particularly his Netflix horror series like “The Haunting of Hill House” and “Midnight Mass”, I firmly believe he is the ideal director to revisit the story of “I Know What You Did Last Summer”. Flanagan excels at crafting compelling, chilling, and supernatural tales centered around young adult characters. His 2022 series, “The Midnight Club”, offers a humorous and emotional exploration of accepting death’s reality, demonstrating his talent once again. Given his track record, it’s safe to say that his slasher reboot would be more intelligent and impactful compared to the 2025 version.

I adore the classic film “I Know What You Did Last Summer” for its cheesy dialogue and 90s ambiance, yet I can’t help but admire its character arcs. The protagonists Julie James and Helen Shivers are haunted by their past, and it’s heartbreaking to witness their ongoing misery in the aftermath of the pivotal event. Regrettably, the 2025 reboot failed to delve sufficiently into how the characters grappled with the accident’s impact. If Flanagan had directed this project, he would have provided a riveting exploration of their emotional journey following the incident.

Mike Flanagan’s Carrie Plans Prove He Would Have Made A Great I Know What You Did Last Summer Reboot

Mike Flanagan intends to approach his television adaptation of Stephen King’s ‘Carrie’ similarly to how he handled ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’. Namely, he plans to explore a fresh narrative that deviates from the original storyline. In an interview, Flanagan stated that they are not simply retelling the tale and further revealed that his series will creatively incorporate social media as a key element.

Flanagan’s method of adapting stories, which involves identifying the core essence and then infusing it with novelty, is commendable, especially when he tackles a grand narrative such as Stephen King’s The Dark Tower. I can’t help but wonder what a Flanagan-directed I Know What You Did Last Summer might have been like, and I remain intrigued by the potential vision he might have brought to that film.

Read More

2025-07-29 22:00