Joe Locks the Wrong Twin in a Cage: You Season 5 Episode 2 Recap

by

Spoiler alert: This article contains spoilers for You season 5, episode 2.

Summary

  • Joe’s life gets chaotic, navigating new characters and challenges.
  • Kate discovers Joe’s dark past, causing tension in their marriage.
  • Episode 2 ends with a twist as Joe locks the wrong twin in a cage.

In the second episode of Netflix’s fifth season of “You”, we delve deeper into the rollercoaster journey of Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley) as he navigates his marriage with Kate Lockwood (Charlotte Ritchie). The series maintains its allure, introducing intriguing new characters and capturing the essence of New York City. When “You” debuted in 2018, it introduced viewers to Joe, a charming bookworm who seemed harmless at first but was later revealed as a chilling serial killer. With insights into Joe’s past and a peek into his thoughts, he stands out among the most unique horror villains ever portrayed on screen.

In the fifth season of ‘You’, during episode 2, Joe’s existence becomes increasingly tumultuous and convoluted. Audience members will appreciate getting to know the fresh cast members as well as delving further into Joe’s current situation.

What Happens In You Season 5 Episode 2?

In the second episode of season 5 titled “Blood Will Be Blood”, Joe rejoices over his apparent resurrection while cleaning Mooney’s bookstore. Upon returning home, Kate advises him to destroy his writings about murder, indicating that he must conceal this aspect of his life from her. Although Kate might be swayed by Joe, at this point, she disapproves of his actions. Meanwhile, Joe finds Bronte intriguing at Mooney’s and refers to her as captivating. It appears that season 5 is positioning Bronte as another potential love interest for Joe, making viewers eager to see how their relationship unfolds.

In the second episode of You season 5, we see two primary plotlines unfolding. Firstly, Joe and Kate find out that Henry has been suspended for physically harming Raegan’s daughter, causing further tension between them, Raegan, and Joe. Secondly, Joe grapples with his feelings towards Bronte.

At a tumultuous dinner party hosted by Kate, both Raegan and Maddie are invited. During the event, Raegan confronts Kate and Joe for past transgressions. Meanwhile, Bronte secretly explores Mooney’s basement and discovers the original cage – the same one we saw in season 3 at A Fresh Tart bakery when Joe was keeping various people captive. Intriguingly, Bronte becomes trapped inside this very cage, leaving viewers questioning if she will find herself there again throughout the season.

Though it’s still early in You season 5, we saw a teaser showing Joe confined within a cage as well, but the specifics of how he ends up there remain unclear for now.

Following Reagan’s accusation that Kate was responsible for Bob’s death, Henry angrily hurls a knife at Reagan, causing both Kate and Joe unease. They are concerned about Henry displaying Joe’s aggressive tendencies. The underlying issue in Joe and Kate’s relationship surfaces when Kate queries: “Are we harboring violent instincts?

“You want us to kill everyone who is suspicious of us for the rest of our lives? When does it end?”

Currently, Joe is facing two challenges: one arising from a situation with Bronte, and another on his phone. Upon checking his phone, he discovers an issue there as well. Meanwhile, Bronte informs him that she sold one of their rare books to clear debt and fund her play. In response, Joe dismisses her. This narrative takes an intriguing turn when Joe recognizes that Bronte comprehends him better than Kate does. Consequently, he re-hires Bronte and instructs her to reside in the apartment above Mooney’s.

After that, Joe visits Kate’s office and encounters Raegan and her spouse Harrison (Pete Ploszek). In an unsettling turn of events, Joe confines Raegan within a cage. Although some movie villains are concealed throughout the film, Joe’s sinister schemes and strategies are consistently revealed to the audience, making every moment chilling. Joe then speaks:

“It’s been a while since you put a monster in a cage.”

How Does You Season 5 Episode 2 End?

In episode 2 of season 5, Joe acknowledges he must conceal his sinister self from Kate. She voices her concern that Joe’s violent actions, such as killing Bob (Michael Dempsey), were impulsive and should not be repeated. It’s evident that Kate is fearful of Joe and questions their marriage’s authenticity. Joe contemplates murdering Raegan and maintaining the secret from Kate. This scene leaves a lasting impression as it becomes apparent that Joe and Kate’s relationship is strained, sparking curiosity among fans since they relocated to New York City in season 4 finale. It seems likely that Joe will continue his killing spree, and at some point this season, Kate will discover the truth, causing her immense shock and terror.

The episode winds up with a surprising turn of events, much like what enthusiasts of “You” have come to anticipate. It’s revealed that it was Maddie, not Raegan, who was trapped inside the cage, and Joe exclaims this discovery.

“You caged the wrong twin.”

You season 5 is now streaming on Netflix.

Read More

2025-04-24 17:10