Lord of the Rings’ Iconic Battle Rated by Military Historian: Realism vs. Drama Revealed

by

Summary

  • Konijnendijk rates epic battles in movies, noting certain details in “The Return of the King” were “made up” for dramatic effect.
  • Charges into battle in movies are often more dramatic than reality, with horses galloping at different speeds instead of together.
  • The incredible cinematics and epic scenes of The Lord of the Rings make it one of the best movie trilogies.

Among numerous captivating elements that attract fans to Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy, one can point out its intricately crafted storyline, breathtaking travels through scenic landscapes, and richly detailed lore. However, what truly stands out is the battle scenes, which are considered among the most spectacular in cinematic history. Based on J.R.R. Tolkien’s books, these movies brought to life the vibrant and complex world of Middle-earth, allowing audiences to follow Frodo, Sam, and their companions as they embarked on an epic journey aimed at destroying the One Ring.

As a passionate movie enthusiast, I must confess that while there have been many remarkable battle scenes in recent films, such as the Battle of Stirling from Mel Gibson’s Braveheart, the Battle of Thermopylae in Zack Synder’s 300, and the opening battle in Ridley Scott’s Gladiator, nothing quite compares to the epic combat scenes in The Lord of the Rings trilogy, particularly the legendary battle in Peter Jackson’s Return of the King. This battle has been acclaimed for its breathtaking cinematic representation of a looming war. Now, while the historical accuracy of the battles in this fantasy series might not be a priority for fans, it’s interesting to note that one historian has pointed out certain details in the battle scene that were fictionalized for the movie.

Ancient Historian Rates Lord of the Ring’s Epic Battle Against the Orcs

In a chat with Insider on YouTube, historical expert Roel Konijnendijk analyzed battle sequences from various movies. He appraised battles in films like “Gladiator 2,” “House of the Dragon,” and “Prince of Persia,” but his most intriguing remark emerged when he was presented with the epic battle from “The Return of the King” where King Theoden mobilizes his troops before clashing against the Orcs. Konijnendijk pointed out that a specific scene, in which King Bernard Hill slaps his sword against the soldiers’ lances to rally them for war, was an improvisation by the actor for dramatic effect as it was “a stylish move” and not historically accurate. However, he did acknowledge that it successfully enhanced the battle’s realism and awarded it 8 out of 10 in terms of authenticity.

The representation is so convincing that one might wonder if it’s a genuine historical event, with some even questioning, ‘Is this truly historical? Could ancient or medieval commanders have done something similar?’ To clarify, the portrayal you see was created by Bernard Hill for the film, offering an intriguing depiction of what seems like pre-modern warfare. However, remember, it’s all part of the movie experience.

Konijnendijk offered a comparison between Theoden’s army charging into battle, as depicted in movies, and real historical battle charges. He noted that in actuality, these charges were often more organized and methodical than they appear on screen due to the desire of directors to slow things down for dramatic effect. Additionally, he pointed out that it was unrealistic for all the horses in a charge to gallop at the same speed since they each had their own individual paces.

From a historian’s perspective, it’s quite intriguing to consider the depiction of battles in The Lord of the Rings from an unusual angle. Many fans might not have considered this before, given that the story is purely fictional. However, what cannot be denied is the sheer captivating power of The Lord of the Rings, with its epic scenes and breathtaking cinematography that continue to make it one of the greatest films ever made.

Source: Insider

Read More

2025-01-22 15:43