Marvel’s Multiverse Embraces Comic Book Continuity, But At a Cost

by

Key Takeaways

  • MCU is embracing the multiverse concept to explore new storylines unencumbered by single continuity.
  • Marvel is drawing from comic book traditions, allowing characters who have died to return in new forms.
  • The return of Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom risks undercutting the emotional impact of Tony Stark’s sacrifice.

As a gamer and a long-time Marvel fanatic who has witnessed the rise and fall (and rise again) of superheroes on the big screen, I can’t help but feel a mix of excitement and trepidation as the Marvel Cinematic Universe delves deeper into the multiverse. On one hand, I love the creativity and freshness that this concept brings to the table, allowing for new storylines and character returns without being encumbered by a single continuity. But on the other hand, it seems like we’re in danger of losing some of the emotional impact that made Marvel movies so memorable in the first place.

After the unpredictable period following the “Endgame”, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has been gradually drifting from a singular connected narrative towards the complexities of the multiverse. The idea gained momentum in 2021 with the debut of Loki, introducing the Time Variance Authority and alternate timeline characters. This multi-dimensional concept was further emphasized in Doctor Strange and the Multiverse of Madness the following year. With phase five, six, and beyond on the horizon, it appears the MCU is fully committed to integrating countless realities into its storyline.

In an imaginative manner, the concept of the multiverse offers the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) a great deal of flexibility. It can move in virtually any direction without being constrained by a single continuity or narrative thread. This freedom paves the way for innovative concepts within a shared universe that has seen financial success but has been facing challenges in replicating its previous triumphs. Moreover, it provides an opportunity to resurrect characters who were previously deceased, either through alternative versions or by manipulating time to reverse their demises. However, although this may benefit the MCU’s future and the actors’ earnings, it can impose a significant price on storytelling quality.

The MCU is Taking a Page From the Comics

For a long time, comic books have been known for their flexible, evolving storylines. Different writers and artists frequently revamp established franchises and launch new narratives unrelated to previous issues. Characters can die dramatically, only to resurface later in completely different forms. Marvel appears to be blending this spontaneous continuity style with the familiar characters and story arcs that readers have grown attached to over the years, using its own multiverse as a platform. While Hollywood has been rebooting for decades, Marvel is now pioneering the concept of reboots within an ongoing series.

Initially, Marvel Studios emerged as the leading producer of blockbuster movies in Hollywood, creating epic spectacles and a connected universe spanning numerous films, an approach unprecedented on such a massive scale. However, what truly set Marvel apart was its commitment to the characters; it ensured that these productions were not only filled with action and witty dialogues, but also offered deep emotional impact. As a result, viewers kept coming back for more movies, not just for the action or stunning CGI effects, but because they developed genuine feelings for these characters. Moreover, when a character met their end, the loss carried significant emotional significance.

In the movie “Avengers: Infinity War,” Vision (Paul Bettany) was tragically killed by Thanos, a character who couldn’t be resurrected through the time-traveling abilities of the Avengers in “Endgame.” The intense sorrow that Wanda Maximoff (Elizabeth Olsen) experienced over his death culminated in one of the most poignant moments in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, as seen in the series “WandaVision.” Similarly, when Thanos sacrificed Gamora (Zoe Saldaña), his adopted daughter, to acquire another Infinity Stone, her death was shocking and carried a heavy weight, as it couldn’t be reversed.

In simpler terms, we don’t get to see the full emotional weight of Gamora’s death until “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3”. This is because a different version of Gamora from another timeline is introduced in the movie. Writer/director James Gunn attempts to create drama with this development as this new Gamora has no connection with Peter Quill (Chris Pratt), while Peter is still grieving over his Gamora. However, the introduction of a new Gamora does lessen the profound impact of her death on Peter and the Guardians to some degree.

Marvel’s Troubling Robert Downey Jr. Gambit

It’s causing some concern that Robert Downey Jr. will rejoin the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Doctor Doom in the upcoming “Avengers: Doomsday.” Details about how Marvel intends to use Downey’s character are scarce, but speculation has been rampant lately, with one popular theory suggesting that this version of the character could be a variant of Tony Stark. If true, this would lessen the emotional impact of Stark’s death at the end of “Endgame.

Tony Stark’s selfless act could be considered the most significant event in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) up to date. It marked the culmination of a ten-year character journey, during which Stark evolved from a self-centered playboy into a hero willing to give his life for others. This noble choice to save the universe resonated throughout numerous subsequent projects and served as an emotional farewell for the character, who first appeared in 2008 with Downey Jr. at the helm. Although it’s uncertain whether Downey will portray Doom as a Stark variant, his return does soften the impact and finality of Stark’s departure.

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but speculate that many viewers might not give a second thought to all this, swept away by the joy of seeing their beloved characters back on screen, no matter what form they take. The multiverse theory could rejuvenate a franchise that’s been creatively struggling lately, offering filmmakers more freedom to explore new ideas. For instance, Fantastic Four: First Steps seems poised to introduce a fresh retro-futuristic aesthetic to the MCU. However, for a series that has always been remarkable in evoking deep emotions through its intricate narratives, it’s a bit disheartening to see how easily those emotional threads can be severed by a simple leap across timelines.

Read More

2024-12-11 22:23