My Hero Academia Characters That Would Have Made Better Villains

Summary

Bakugo’s potential to be a villain would have posed an immense challenge for Deku.
Characters like Nighteye and Phantom Thief had the potential to become dangerous villains.
Vlad King and Gang Orca could have made impactful antagonists in My Hero Academia.

As the final chapter unfolds for “My Hero Academia,” the much-loved anime series concludes Deku’s journey, providing fans with an emotional and thrilling tale that has resonated within the anime community over the years. Although the primary narrative of “My Hero Academia” is captivating, its true value lies in the multitude of supporting characters who have their moments to shine throughout the series.

In the world of “My Hero Academia,” Deku’s classmates, professional heroes, and others like them are fascinating characters with their own captivating tales that could have been explored further. Despite many heroes serving as beacons of pride, there were a handful who appeared to be in roles they didn’t quite fit. Here is a list of characters from My Hero Academia who might have excelled as antagonists.

8. Bakugo

The Wild Lone Wolf

Quirk: Explosion

In the anime “My Hero Academia,” Bakugo plays the role of a significant character alongside the protagonist Izuku Midoriya, often serving as a rival to him. Bakugo’s personality in the series is fiery and impulsive, much like his explosive powers that spark massive detonations from his sweat. Unlike most of his peers and even many heroes, Bakugo is characterized by his destructive, aggressive behavior and swift temper.

During the course of the series, a more compassionate aspect of Bakugo was revealed later on, but at one point, his narrative could have unfolded quite differently. After being abducted by the Villain League, he had the opportunity to align himself with their faction. If Bakugo had chosen villainy, he would have presented a significantly greater danger than Shigaraki’s transformation into All For One’s successor, and he would have posed an immense challenge for Deku.

7. Nighthide

A Power Built For Control

Quirk: Brainwashing

Hitoshi Shinso made a short appearance in “My Hero Academia” during the sports festival, where Deku defeated him. Despite his Quirk being better suited for corporate positions, Shinso opted for a challenging career as a hero and enrolled in UA Academy.

Following his loss at the festival, Shinso came under Aizawa Sensei’s guidance, honing robust fighting and strategic abilities. Without this mentorship, Shinso might have joined the Meta Liberation Army, posing a significant threat to Class 1-A, and potentially even reversing the League of Villains’ fortunes.

6. Nighteye

The All-Seeing Eye

Quirk: Foresight

In the third season of My Hero Academia, I found myself introduced as an observer, where I was unveiled as All Might’s former partner and the present guide for Lemillion. Throughout the years, I remained loyal to All Might, utilizing my foresight ability to always stay one step ahead of potential perils that could have been devastating to my heroic figurehead. However, a disagreement over his safety led to our eventual separation after All Might’s severe wounding.

If the separation had been more tumultuous, Nighteye might have crossed over to the dark side, shifting his focus from finding All Might’s successor to demonstrating All Might’s limitations if a formidable challenge emerged. In this scenario, he could have posed a significant threat to All For One, potentially becoming one of the most dangerous villains in the world of “My Hero Academia.

5. Endeavor

The Flame Of Despair

Quirk: Hellflame

In the anime “My Hero Academia”, Endeavor’s connection with both the storyline and its audience is intricate. At first, he was depicted as an overly enthusiastic and self-centered character, but a swift change in his character left many viewers surprised, as he evolved into a composed and responsible hero who took over after All Might retired.

Regrettably, Endeavor’s past transgressions have cast a shadow over his character, causing many fans to view him differently. If Endeavor had allowed his delusions to consume him after recognizing his own shortcomings and plunged into darkness, he could have become one of the most formidable villains in the series, surpassing all others without All Might’s presence.

4. Vlad King

The Blood Hero Would Have Made A Better Antagonist

Quirk: Blood Control

In the animated series “My Hero Academia,” there’s a character named Vlad King, who serves as a homeroom teacher. He doesn’t appear often, but he carries an icy demeanor and quite an imposing presence. Known as the Blood Hero, Vlad King possesses a unique ability called Quirk, which allows him to control and shape the blood flowing within his body in various forms.

In my observation, Vlad King, though fascinating in the My Hero Academia series, might have left a greater impression if he had been introduced as a standalone antagonist, similar to Muscular or Overhaul. The vampire-like character type, while somewhat clichéd, seems more fitting for Toga’s narrative and could potentially enrich her storyline with additional layers of complexity.

3. Gang Orca

The Aqua Hero Could Have Been The Pirate Villain

Quirk: Orcinus

During the third season of “My Hero Academia,” the character known as Gang Orca played a substantial part in the Provisional Exam arc for Class 1-A students. In the show, Gang Orca is depicted as a fiery and hot-tempered individual, suggesting he may have had a troubled past, possibly as a delinquent in his youth.

Among his fellow comrades, he is highly admired and recognized as the twelfth-ranked hero. Gang Orca could have been an intriguing antagonist, instilling fear across the seas surrounding Japan. With a band of unsavory pirates, he would have provided an engaging adversary for the Class 1-A students or proved to be a powerful asset for the League of Villains.

2. Gale Force

A Sweeping Force That Could Have Been A Storm Of Terror

Quirk: Whirlwind

As an onlooker, I’ve come across a student hailing from Shiketsu High School who made his debut during the Provisional License Exam. This individual, Inasa Yoarashi, garnered some notice following an altercation with Shoto Todoroki post-exam. Equipped with a Quirk that enables him to control the wind, Inasa stands as a formidable hero, boasting a power proportionate to his self-assured demeanor.

From an underlying sense of jealousy towards Shoto, his singular struggle escalated, clouding his understanding of heroism’s true essence. Meanwhile, Inasa’s character didn’t significantly evolve after their encounter until the climactic fight. Yet, if Inasa had joined the Villains League to retaliate against Shoto, it could have led to a more dynamic conflict compared to Endeavor’s continuous battles in his Agency arc.

1. Phantom Thief

The Copy Hero Could Have Been A Major Threat

Quirk: Copy

Right from the start, it was evident that Neito Monoma didn’t belong in his chosen field. Despite being a notable member of Class 1-B, Monoma exhibited certain characteristics that set him apart quite noticeably from his fellow students, appearing strikingly unusual among them.

Character-wise, Momona exuded an ominous aura and displayed aggressive behavior towards his peers in Class 1-A, giving the impression that he was better suited to play the role of a villain rather than anything else. Monoma possesses a unique ability called Quirk, which enables him to replicate certain Quirks from others. However, there are restrictions associated with this power. In an alternate universe, a malevolent Momona could have been a pivotal figure in numerous conflicts within the world of “My Hero Academia.

2025-07-23 11:34