One Batman Villain Will Always Need Two Movies to Tell Their Story

by

One Batman Villain Will Always Need Two Movies to Tell Their Story

Key Takeaways

  • James Gunn has debunked rumors of Boyd Holbrook as Two-Face in “The Batman Part 2.”
  • Harvey Dent’s character needs two movies for proper development.
  • Dent’s character arc requires adequate time and portrayal of his transformation.

As a lifelong Batman fan who grew up with the comics and the animated series, I can confidently say that Harvey Dent/Two-Face is one of the most complex characters in the entire rogues gallery. The rumor mill may churn out false stories about actors landing roles as Two-Face, but if we are to see this iconic villain on the big screen again, it needs to be done right.

Fans will have to be patient for another two years before they can watch the sequel of Matt Reeves’ well-received film “The Batman” in cinemas worldwide. There’s a lot of buzz surrounding “The Batman Part 2,” with speculations about character castings running rampant, but James Gunn has stepped in to clarify things on Meta’s Threads. Lately, there have been whispers that Boyd Holbrook might be playing the role of Two-Face in the sequel. However, Gunn firmly denied these rumors, stating that the casting announcement is false.

In the hypothetical scenario where Harvey Dent/Two-Face appears in “The Batman Part 2” or “Brave and the Bold,” it’s crucial to handle his character with care, given the depth and complexity of his storyline. Unlike many other members of Batman’s rogues gallery, Harvey Dent isn’t just a simple villain; he is a complex and tragic figure who elicits sympathy from the audience. Overlooking this aspect of his backstory would be equivalent to dismissing all the commendable actions Commissioner Gordon has taken for Gotham City if he were to turn villainous. Therefore, it’s essential to allocate ample screen time to explore the intricacies of Harvey Dent’s character and his transformation into Two-Face, ensuring a compelling narrative that resonates with viewers.

Harvey Dent Was One of the Good Guys

One Batman Villain Will Always Need Two Movies to Tell Their Story

In 1942, Harvey Dent made his first appearance in Detective Comics #66. His creation was designed to portray the duality within human nature, drawing inspiration from The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. It’s crucial that the good half is genuinely good for this narrative to hold up. Throughout the years, Dent’s background has been expanded upon and modified, but one notable story, The Long Halloween, depicts him collaborating with Batman and Gordon in their efforts to reform Gotham City as its district attorney.

In his role as the district attorney, Dent often found himself at odds with many powerful figures, most notably the mobster Sal Maroni. This conflict eventually led to a brutal attack where Maroni threw acid on Dent’s face during one of his court cases. It’s no secret that someone like Maroni doesn’t make allies easily, especially not with someone as upright as Dent who couldn’t be swayed or corrupted. Contrastingly, the DA Gil Colson in The Batman series, portrayed by Peter Sarsgaard, was more bent than a dog’s leg, easily swayed and compromised.

Nolan Tried With The Dark Knight

Christopher Nolan crafted a highly acclaimed Batman film trilogy on screen, characterized by a realistic and grim atmosphere that stayed true to the original storyline. There were occasional variations where he added his unique touch to maintain authenticity, but they were minor compared to the Joel Schumacher films. The Dark Knight, in particular, received widespread appreciation from both regular moviegoers and comic book enthusiasts. This was largely because of Heath Ledger’s exceptional portrayal of the Joker, who left a lasting impression, while Aaron Eckhart’s performance as Harvey Dent/Two-Face should not be underestimated.

Instead of how Tommy Lee Jones portrayed the character, Eckhart’s interpretation showcased the finest Gotham has to offer before he became corrupted. Fans were given a chance to witness the district attorney collaborating with Gordon and Batman, a crucial aspect of his comic book history, as they worked together to combat the pervasive corruption in Gotham City.

In The Dark Knight, Nolan might have delved deeper into the narrative. Bruce’s connection with Dent was predominantly centered on their rivalry due to Bruce’s envy, which could have been more complexly portrayed. Additionally, Two-Face didn’t have a significant impact on the movie as his role was rather limited, appearing only in the final act and not contributing much to the overall plot. Nolan could have also done better with Dent’s dual nature. While Dent did exhibit signs of darkness, such as threatening Joker’s henchmen and flipping coins to feign pulling the trigger, the development of his darker persona felt hasty and underdeveloped.

Why Two Movies Would Improve Harvey Dent’s Character

One Batman Villain Will Always Need Two Movies to Tell Their Story

Redefining the narrative for Harvey Dent’s character development across two movies would be advantageous, as it could intensify the dramatic tension. The films should depict Harvey as a good man initially, forming an alliance with Batman throughout the storyline. However, towards the end, Batman’s trusted ally inexplicably turns against him, mirroring the transformation of Harvey Dent into the villainous Two-Face.

Providing Dent’s character with two films would allow a director like Matt Reeves (or any other director using Two-Face in the future) to gradually develop the character’s descent into a life of crime. Initially, Dent could be as reliable and trustworthy as Commissioner Gordon, but following an attack, he might lose all his trustworthiness. The audience could then witness Dent’s journey from a shining beacon of faith in the justice system to someone whose confidence in it gradually diminishes as criminals are granted bail without rehabilitation. This narrative would showcase the complex and tragic nature of many comic book characters.

Read More

2024-09-26 23:04