One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit

Key Takeaways

  • Some characters in One Piece should never eat Devil Fruits due to their established identities, skills, and weaknesses.
  • Characters like Bepo, Dracule Mihawk, and Monkey D. Garp have unique strengths and abilities that would be negated by consuming a Devil Fruit.
  • Eating a Devil Fruit would undermine the character growth, fighting style, and efficiency of characters like Koby, Shanks, and Franky.

As a long-time fanatic of One Piece and a connoisseur of its captivating characters, I wholeheartedly agree with the points made about the Straw Hat Pirates and their Devil Fruits.


In the world of “One Piece”, Devil Fruits serve as unique, powerful abilities for its characters. Consuming one grants an unusual yet advantageous superpower, but they are extremely scarce and not all significant series characters have had a chance to partake. Some should strictly avoid doing so.

In the realm of “One Piece”, some significant characters have molded their personas around proficiency in powers such as Haki or Rokushiki. Consuming a Devil Fruit, which they should avoid, would contradict their well-established character traits. Moreover, these fruits come with a severe disadvantage – a vulnerability to water – a liability in this expansive semi-aquatic world. Therefore, the following characters ought never to partake of such strange fruits.

8 Bepo

This Mink Has A Huge Advantage Over His Brethren

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 498 (Manga) Episode 392 (Anime)

Members of the Mink Tribe possess two potent assets for combat: their Electro skill and their Sulong transformation. Unlike many others, they don’t rely on a Devil Fruit to battle their adversaries since they can utilize these abilities effectively. However, Sulong can be unpredictable as it only triggers when there’s a full moon out. But unlike others, Bepo doesn’t face this issue.

Thanks to Tony Tony Chopper, Bepo can activate his Sulong form anytime, regardless of the moon’s phase. When he does so, combining it with his strong martial arts abilities, makes this transformation incredibly effective. Notably, it was instrumental in saving Bepo’s captain, Trafalgar Law, by allowing him to swim away into the sea during a critical moment. Acquiring a Devil Fruit would essentially negate all these advantages.

7 Dracule Mihawk

What Would Be The Point Of Being The Strongest Swordsman?

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 49 (Manga) Episode 23 (Anime)

Dracule Mihawk has consistently been known as the “Most Skilled Swordsman” across the entire One Piece universe since the early storylines of the series. Indeed, he lived up to this distinguished title, given his exceptional swordsmanship, which enables him to effortlessly cut through massive battleships or icebergs without any difficulties.

Mihawk is proficient in using Haki, yet he tends not to rely on it during battles, unlike Shanks and other swordsmen of similar skill level. His mastery seems to be the result of tireless effort, and consuming a Devil Fruit would diminish his achievements, rendering his title of “Strongest Swordsman” meaningless. It would feel like an unfair advantage, or cheating.

6 Monkey D. Garp

He Became The Hero Of The Marines Without One

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 92 (Manga) Episode 68 (Anime)

Without a shadow of a doubt, Monkey D. Garp stands as one of the most powerful characters in One Piece, given that he defeated the notorious Rocks D. Xebec (with the assistance of Gol D. Roger) and earned the title “Hero of the Marines”. Following this, he continued to apprehend dangerous pirates and even started guiding younger marines such as Koby and Helmeppo.

In combat, Garp’s prodigious physical power, mastery of Rokushiki techniques, and expertise in three forms of Haki make him an unstoppable force, capable of performing extraordinary deeds such as his devastating Galaxy Impact that virtually leveled Hachinosu. Remarkably, Garp has achieved this impressive skill set without consuming a Devil Fruit, which suggests he doesn’t require one to excel in battle at the moment.

5 Koby

It Would Go Against His Inspiring Character Growth

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 2 (Manga) Episode 1 (Anime)

In no other character from One Piece has growth been as remarkable as Koby’s: he transformed from a timid child yearning to join the Marines into a valiant Marine Captain possessing such strength that he can shatter a portion of an island with his powerful Honesty Impact. It’s clear as day that Koby is Garp’s apprentice, and he mirrors his master’s combat style.

Koby’s unique aspect lies in the fact that he worked tirelessly to reach his current position, and consuming a Devil Fruit might dilute the significance of his character progression and evolution. Although Devil Fruit consumers must still dedicate considerable effort to their battles and training (with Monkey D. Luffy serving as a notable example), Koby wouldn’t gain any advantage from eating one at this juncture.

4 Shanks

He Is Already One Of The Most Skilled Haki Users In The Series

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 1 (Manga) Episode 4 (Anime)

Shanks, the one with red hair, stands out among all Emperors in One Piece as he lacks any Devil Fruit abilities. However, his exceptional Haki techniques have been so formidable that even Whitebeard acknowledged them. Given his training under the legendary Gol D. Roger, this is hardly surprising.

In the story, after Luffy encountered numerous formidable enemies with powerful Devil Fruits like Big Mom and Kaido, Shanks has taken on a significant role to demonstrate the extent of a Haki expert. His dominating wins over Ryokugyu and Kid showcased his absolute command over all three forms of Haki, suggesting that there might be no one else in the world who can match his proficiency with this ability. Consequently, it becomes evident that Shanks not only shouldn’t consume a Devil Fruit but that he was essentially crafted to never require one.

3 Franky

He Already Has His Advanced Cyborg Technology

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 329 (Manga) Episode 233 (Anime)

Regarding the Straw Hat Pirates, creator Eiichiro Oda has nearly struck the ideal equilibrium, as just four out of every ten crew members have consumed a Devil Fruit. Although it’s debatable whether some might eventually partake, there are undeniably others who should never eat one, and Franky is among the strongest cases in this category.

Franky’s role in the story is to introduce cyborgs and demonstrate what an ingenious and skilled engineer can create with advanced technology. With a durable metal physique, various weapons at his disposal, and the capacity to pilot a colossal mech, Franky doesn’t need a Devil Fruit since it wouldn’t add any benefits for him. Interestingly, Franky is among the few characters who have refused a Devil Fruit, as Luffy once offered him the Mera Mera no Mi during the Dressrosa Arc. However, he turned it down because he values his ability to swim.

2 Vinsmoke Sanji

He’s A Proficient Swimmer With Super Human Abilities

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 43 (Manga) Episode 20 (Anime)

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but marvel at Sanji’s exceptional swimming skills among the Straw Hat Pirates. Time and again, he was the swift and courageous crew member who plunged into the water first to rescue Luffy or Chopper from perilous drowning situations. It would truly be a pity if he were ever to consume a Devil Fruit, as it could potentially rob us of one of his most invaluable abilities.

It’s worth noting that Devil Fruit powers wouldn’t necessarily give an advantage in combat for Sanji since he’s already adept at various martial arts techniques. Moreover, his devastating Diable Jiambe move involves igniting his legs on fire, and most impressively, he’s recently activated the genetic enhancements within him, making him swifter, stronger, and more durable.

1 Jinbe

It Would Literally Ruin His Entire Character And Fighting Style

One Piece: Characters Who Should Not Eat A Devil Fruit
  • First Appearance: Chapter 528 (Manga) Episode 430 (Anime)

Characters like Fish-Men and Merfolk, due to their inherent amphibious traits, are typically immune to the effects of Devil Fruits. This has been demonstrated in the series by only two instances: Vander Decken IX and Jack. Jinbe, being part of this group, shares the same immunity. Given his status as the most proficient swimmer among the Straw Hat Pirates and his role as helmsman, which keeps him constantly near the ocean water, the Devil Fruit would not pose a significant disadvantage for him.

In addition, Jinbe is proficient in both Fish-Man Karate and Fish-Man Jujutsu, two distinct martial arts that leverage his swimming skills and water manipulation. Given his vulnerability to water, these abilities would render his long-honed fighting style ineffective. It’s highly unlikely that Jinbe will gain any advantage from Devil Fruit powers throughout the series, and it seems certain that he’ll conclude the story without consuming one.

Read More

2024-10-02 05:04