One Piece: Shanks Shouldn’t Actually Have An Evil Twin Brother

As a long-time One Piece fanatic who has sailed through countless arcs and theories, I must say that the recent development of Shanks’s supposed evil twin theory leaves me feeling a bit queasy in my sea legs. Having followed this series since its inception, I can confidently say that Shanks’s enigmatic character has been one of the most intriguing elements, shrouded in mystery and complexity.

Granted, it is still up for debate whether Shanks truly has an evil twin lurking in the shadows or if this is just another red herring from Oda to keep us guessing. However, as a seasoned navigator of the One Piece world, I can’t help but feel that such a revelation would be akin to discovering that Blackbeard was secretly a vegetarian who preferred carrot-shaped pirate hats.

The prospect of Shanks having an evil twin seems like a step back from the morally gray character we have come to know and admire, transforming him into yet another do-gooder pirate. It feels as if the writing team is reaching for a familiar trope to make Shanks more likable but at the expense of his depth and intrigue.

Of course, I’m no expert on the mysteries of the One Piece world, but I can’t help but wonder: If Shanks has an evil twin, does that mean he gets free pirate grog at the local tavern? After all, who doesn’t love a good happy hour with a doppelganger or two?

In the end, I suppose we’ll have to wait and see how this story unfolds. As for me, I’ll be here, sailing the seas of speculation and theorycrafting, eagerly awaiting the next chapter in the grand adventure that is One Piece.

This article contains spoilers for One Piece’s Elbaf Arc.

Summary

Shanks’s evil twin theory gains traction with recent evidence in One Piece.
Introduction of an evil twin could weaken Shanks’s morally gray character.
Fans fear Shanks becoming a clichéd good pirate if the evil twin theory is confirmed.

To date, within the narrative of “One Piece,” Shanks, the Red Hair Pirate, stands out as one of the series’ most influential yet enigmatic figures. Though he serves as both a mentor and role model to Luffy, the specific objectives Shanks pursues in the storyline, along with his broader strategies, remain largely unexplored. This ambiguity has sparked endless debate among fans, who have pondered over what exactly Shanks’ mission might be within the realm of “One Piece.” Speculation ranges from theories suggesting that Shanks is a secret agent for the World Government, to those proposing that he harbors an evil twin brother.

The theory about Shanks having an evil twin has gained significant attention following the publication of One Piece Chapter 1134. This chapter presents additional evidence that strengthens the argument for many, seemingly conclusively proving this theory. However, if this theory is indeed accurate, it might indicate a problematic turn in the storyline of One Piece and could potentially tarnish Shanks’s character.

Shanks’s Evil Twin Theory In One Piece

This Theory Has Gained A New Piece Of Evidence

In the world of “One Piece,” the Shanks’ Evil Twin Theory originated during the Paramount War. This theory suggests that a scar-less Shanks, who appeared in the story at that time, wasn’t the real Shanks, but rather his wicked counterpart working for the World Government. While Oda, the creator of “One Piece,” claimed this was just a mistake, many fans argue otherwise. They believe that when Shanks later visited the Five Elders, it wasn’t actually Shanks, as this action seemed unusual for his character. Instead, they propose that this was a visit by Shanks’ evil twin.

Does the new era scare you so much? – Shanks

In the latest installments of “One Piece,” a character strikingly similar to Shanks has surfaced on Elbaf, much like how the Five Elders summoned. Given this resemblance and the circumstances, some fans speculate that Shanks might have an evil counterpart who works with the World Government and possibly serves as one of “One Piece’s” Holy Knights. Regrettably, despite this intriguing revelation at the end of Chapter 1134, Chapter 1135 offers no fresh insights into the enigmatic figure on Elbaf.

Shanks’s Evil Twin Weakens His Character

A Twin Makes Shanks A More Boring Person

Shanks Having An Evil Twin Weakens His Character
Shanks Used To Be An Interesting Morally Gray Pirate

While it’s not yet definitively clear if this new character is indeed Shanks’ evil counterpart, numerous fans are convinced that Oda is steering Shanks’ storyline towards this development. Yet, this twist might prove detrimental to Shanks’ character arc within the narrative of One Piece. Essentially, introducing an evil twin for Shanks could potentially undermine many intriguing aspects of his personality that fans have come to appreciate over time. By providing a convenient excuse for past misdeeds, this alteration may diminish Shanks’ character strength in the long run.

In the tale of “One Piece,” despite Shanks often appearing as a jovial and carefree pirate, he has displayed a hint of his ominous nature. At certain moments, Shanks demonstrates an uncompromising brutality, such as when he vanquished Kid and his crew, or maintains secrecy, like during his clandestine talks with the leaders of the “One Piece” World Government. This ambiguity in his character, making him seem more sinister than initially suggested, gives Shanks an enigmatic quality that embodies the complex moralities of a true sea-faring pirate.

Shanks’s Evil Twin Is A Bit Cliché

Even If It Was Hinted At In One Piece It Still Seems Like A Bad Move

In contrast, if Shanks were to possess an evil counterpart in “One Piece”, his already complex character would be significantly weakened. Instead, Shanks would simply emerge as another virtuous pirate striving for a better world, much like Luffy. Introducing an evil twin for Shanks, even though it has been subtly suggested throughout the series, still appears to be a worn-out trope and a simple means to make Shanks more appealing, yet less compelling.

Put your life on the line. – Shanks

As a long-time fan of One Piece, I can confidently say that the masterful storytelling of Eiichiro Oda is unparalleled. Having read through numerous manga series and watched countless anime, I can attest to the fact that Oda has a knack for taking common tropes and making them feel fresh and exciting. The Elbaf Arc promises to be no exception, and I eagerly await each new chapter, hoping for more answers to unfold within this captivating world. It’s clear that Oda has complete control over the direction of the story, and I have full faith in his ability to deliver a satisfying conclusion to One Piece.

2025-01-03 06:04