Ranking All Stardew Valley Bachelorettes by Dating Difficulty

Ranking All Stardew Valley Bachelorettes by Dating Difficulty

As a seasoned Stardew Valley player with countless hours spent tending my farm and courting the town’s lovely inhabitants, I must say that each of these bachelorettes presents its unique set of challenges for those seeking the perfect partner.


Over the years, numerous tier lists have ranked the datable women in Stardew Valley from various angles, including their favorite gifts, styles, and heart events. However, because each marriage candidate has a unique personality and character development arc, players need to consider much more than just basic traits and appearance.

In Stardew Valley, there’s general agreement on who the ideal bachelorette is, based on fan-supplied statistics and surveys. However, one point of contention persists: which bachelorettes present the most challenging courtship experience? This discussion goes beyond simple gifts or events and focuses on the intricacies of their story arcs.

The following table summarizes the best and worst traits of all the romanceable women in Stardew Valley.

Bachelorette Best Trait Worst Trait
Abigail Is cool and relatable Can be immature and blunt
Maru Is brilliant and independent Can be cold and distant
Penny Is levelheaded and loyal Can be boring and detached
Leah Is giving and passionate Can be insecure and depressed
Haley Is charming and confident Can be childish and spoiled
Emily Is honest and friendly Can be a people-pleaser

6 Abigail

The Challenge: Not Falling for Her

Ranking All Stardew Valley Bachelorettes by Dating Difficulty
  • Loved Items: Amethyst, Banana Pudding, Bakery Cobbler, Chocolate Cake, Pufferfish, Pumpkin, Spicey Eel, and Monster Compendium.

It’s evident that Abigail is frequently chosen as a spouse in Stardew Valley, demonstrating how captivating she is to players. She’s warm-hearted and engaging, and her intriguing past only enhances her allure, making her similar to Sebastian, the most popular bachelorette character.

Nevertheless, while Abigail is cherished by numerous gamers, she does possess certain shortcomings. On occasion, she may exhibit immaturity and bluntness, which could grate on people. Additionally, her peculiar traits like eating rocks might find disfavor with others.

5 Leah

The Challenge: Ignoring Her Green Flags

  • Loved Items: Goat Cheese, Poppyseed Muffin, Salad, Stir Fry, Truffle, Vegetable Medley, Wine.

In Stardew Valley, Leah is the most promising choice for marriage. She’s known for her compassion, kindness, and diligence, making her an exceptional partner. Moreover, her deep bond with nature means she easily adapts to the lifestyle of a farmer following marriage. Consequently, courting Leah isn’t a challenging task at all.

She starts presenting presents to the player following the sixth Heart Event and remains lively in her affection, which sets her apart from numerous other bachelorettes who may lose some spark post-marriage. However, it’s worth noting that her heart events might not be particularly impactful compared to others. Still, this doesn’t significantly deter the choice of partnering with her.

Leah gifts the player with an exotic sculpture during their sixth heart event.

4 Haley

The Challenge: Seeing Through Her Childish Personality

  • Loved Items: Coconut, Fruit Salad, Pink Cake, Sunflower.

Haley resembles Sam among the group of single women; at first glance, she seems self-centered, immature, and reckless, making it difficult to date her since it’s essential to see past her “popular high school girl” persona and encourage her to showcase a more understanding, compassionate, and altruistic side.

Despite maintaining her popularity due to her unique appearance and fashion sense, Haley still carries some of her less endearing qualities into her married life, which can sometimes make her seem aloof or unapproachable to others. For example, she occasionally makes humorous comments that suggest she could find someone better suited for her, subtly implying that the person she’s interacting with might not be her perfect match.

3 Penny

The Challenge: Accepting Her Normie Side

  • Loved Items: Diamond, Emerald, Melon, Poppy, Poppyseed Muffin, Red Plate, Roots Platter, Sandfish, Tom Kha Soup.

From a fan’s perspective, dating Penny seems devoid of notable drawbacks, yet it fails to deliver substantial benefits as well. In the small town we live in, Penny embodies the female counterpart of Harvey – she’s sweet and endearing but lacks complex character growth or a compelling history that sets her apart.

Nevertheless, Penny continues to be among the most favored bachelorettes in Stardew Valley due to these characteristics. Similar to how players opt for Harvey because of his emotional balance and accessibility, many pick Penny for her tranquil and consistent demeanor. Nonetheless, individuals seeking a more thrilling romantic tale may find her relationship somewhat lackluster.

2 Emily

The Challenge: Adapting to Excitement-Free Life

Ranking All Stardew Valley Bachelorettes by Dating Difficulty
  • Loved Items: Amethyst, Aquamarine, Emerald, Jade, Parrot Egg, Rubby, Topaz, Wool, Cloth, Survival Burger.

Although Emily is among the kindest Non-Player Characters in Stardew Valley, she isn’t commonly chosen as a spouse by many players. Nevertheless, her cheerful demeanor and upbeat character tend to make her a preferred option for forming friendships.

The main challenge in dating Emily is that her Heart Events tend to be self-centered. There are few memorable moments throughout the relationship, and even after marriage, she remains the same predictable, people-pleasing person she was at the start. Nothing significant changes.

1 Maru

The Challenge: Dealing with Her Ongoing Family Drama

  • Loved Items: Battery Pack, Cauliflower, Cheese Cauliflower, Diamond, Dwarf Gadget, Gold Bar, Iridium Bar, Miner’s Treat, Pepper Poppers, Radioactive Bar, Rhubarb Pie, Strawberry.

In the quaint town of Pelican, there’s a unique character named Maru, admired for her kindness, ambition, and exceptional intellect. She stands out for her self-reliance and independence. Yet, her complex relationship with her parents tends to cast a shadow on the delightful aspects of courting her. Those who choose to court Maru might find themselves navigating her family issues, which could potentially disrupt the romance.

Over time, fan-created surveys have repeatedly indicated that Maru is among the least popular bachelorettes. This can be attributed to a few factors: firstly, some players find her Heart Events and overall storyline unengaging. Secondly, compared to characters like Leah, Maru’s less romantic personality seems to be a factor in her lower popularity.

Read More

2024-09-07 08:35