Red Dead Redemption 2 Fan Points Out Potential Plot Hole

Red Dead Redemption 2 Fan Points Out Potential Plot Hole

Key Takeaways

  • A player finds a potential plot hole in Red Dead Redemption 2 involving Micah Bell’s suspicious contributions to the camp ledger book.
  • Theories include Dutch potentially adding money to make Micah look useful even while in jail, sparking debate among fans on Reddit.
  • Despite the game’s outstanding level of detail, some players speculate it could be a glitch or an intentional plot twist by the developers.

As a seasoned cowboy and avid gamer who’s ridden the dusty trails of Rockstar Games since the days of Horseshoe Overlook, I can confidently say that I’ve developed an eye for detail, much like a hawk scanning the plains for its next meal. So when I stumbled upon this peculiar plot hole in Red Dead Redemption 2, I felt compelled to share it with fellow trailblazers.


A player who’s been enjoying ‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ has spotted what appears to be an inconsistency in the game’s story. Specifically, it seems that during Micah Bell’s time behind bars, an unusual amount of money was mysteriously added to Dutch’s camp ledger. This blockbuster game from Rockstar, launched in October 2018, is famous for its immersive natural landscapes where players can indulge in hunting and fishing whenever they please. The game also offers a rich selection of side activities including Blackjack, Dominoes, Poker, and Five Finger Fillet among its four minigames.

One effective way of paraphrasing the given text in a natural and easy-to-read manner could be: “One key factor that makes Red Dead Redemption 2 stand out is its high level of detail, which continues to draw players into the Wild West setting six years after its release. A dedicated fan recently uncovered an intriguing detail about Dutch van der Linde in the game while modifying his character; this hidden aspect can only be spotted by those who engage in RDR2’s modifications.

A diligent player of “Red Dead Redemption 2” on Reddit suspects there could be a possible inconsistency in the game’s plot. User YoucancallmeLule, while reviewing the ledger for camp upgrades and member contributions, noticed an oddly large sum of money credited to the book by Micah Bell, a character who later becomes the primary antagonist in “Red Dead Redemption 2” and was once a part of the Van der Linde gang. This discovery is troubling because, at the time this money was allegedly added, Micah was imprisoned in Strawberry after killing two men during this suspicious financial transaction.

Red Dead Redemption Player Discovers Strange Micah Bell Plot Hole

Some comments in the Reddit thread suggested that Dutch could have added money to the ledger to make Micah look more useful than he is, and then forgot to stop doing it when he went to jail, while others have stated that it’s just a weird Red Dead Redemption 2 glitch that the developers haven’t got around to patching yet. One commentor did humorously suggest that Micah might still be earning money while behind bars so he could contribute to the camp, but that theory isn’t as likely, since Micah did end up betraying the Van der Linde gang before becoming a mole for the Pinkertons.

As Rockstar Games continues their work on the release of Grand Theft Auto 6, it appears that a fresh installment in the Red Dead Redemption series may not surface for some time. There’s been talk that the original Red Dead Redemption could be making its way to PC platforms, but we’ll have to wait and see what innovative paths Rockstar will choose for this cherished franchise.

Read More

2024-09-17 16:53