Red Dead Redemption 3 Protagonist: Who Should It Be?

The Red Dead Redemption series has solidified its place as a standout franchise, with every main character possessing an unforgettable narrative. In the case of Red Dead Redemption 2, players bid farewell to John Marston as the protagonist, leaving room for potential new protagonists in a hypothetical Red Dead Redemption 3. These characters could either be seen in a prequel or sequel, continuing the saga of the gun-wielding outlaws that define this series.

Regardless of whether players rejoin the Van der Linde gang, there are numerous intriguing characters from Red Dead Redemption that could excel as the main character in Red Dead Redemption 3. The possibility for a sequel or prequel is just as likely as that for Grand Theft Auto 6.

Spoilers ahead for Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2

8. Sadie Adler

An Expert Bounty Hunter Who Grieves for the Loss of Her Husband

Sequel or Prequel: Sequel

As a devoted fan, I wholeheartedly believe that Sadie Adler would be an outstanding choice for the protagonist in “Red Dead Redemption 3.” This game could provide a satisfying continuation of her story, picking up where it left off after she departed from the Van der Linde gang. Her new role as a bounty hunter offers a rich backdrop to explore the profound grief and anger she harbors following the brutal killing of her husband by outlaws. This emotional turmoil could lead to a complex moral journey, where Sadie grapples with her past, seeks self-discovery, and redefines her identity as a bounty hunter.

The narrative of Sadie Adler was exceptionally portrayed in Red Dead Redemption 2, yet her character could have taken bigger strides as the first female lead in the series. Additionally, it could offer more insights into what happened to her following Abigail and John Marston’s wedding. Sadie’s tale is far from concluded, and a sequel would be highly anticipated.

7. Uncle

Find Out Why Uncle is So Lazy and Was Once Called the One-Shot Kid

Sequel or Prequel: Prequel

Once referred to as the One-Shot Kid, the background of this character, known simply as Uncle, remains a mystery, shrouded in tales that are more likely fabrications than truths. These stories usually unfold around a campfire, with a bottle of whiskey nearby.

Over time, numerous speculations have arisen about Uncle’s true identity. Some believe he could be Red Harlow from the game Red Dead Revolver. However, despite these theories, the real story of who Uncle is and what his past entailed before crossing paths with the Van der Linde gang remains unclear.

Rockstar Games holds a significant opportunity to narrate the prequel tale of Uncle’s life, delving into his past as part of the Van der Linde gang and revealing how he transformed into a man plagued by alcoholism and back pain. Exploring Uncle’s history might offer fresh perspectives on the character within both Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2, potentially shedding light on aspects such as grief, disillusionment, or reverence.

6. Charles Smith

A Great Hunter Who’s Heritage Stops Him From Fitting In During the Old West

Sequel or Prequel: Both

As a devoted fan, I can’t help but feel excited about the untold tale that lies ahead for Charles Smith. Whether it’s a prequel or a sequel, the narrative potential is simply astonishing. Born to an African American mother and a Native American father, Charles Smith grapples with his identity in a world that often judges him based on the color of his skin. The son of two rich cultural backgrounds, he finds himself ostracized, a fate that only serves to stoke his anger and solidify his feelings of isolation.

Charles possesses exceptional skills as both a fighter and hunter, making him ideally suited for the role of a gunslinger in the Old West. His backstory, detailing the events that transpired before or after joining the Van der Linde gang, could be fascinatingly woven into his narrative, including reminiscences about Arthur Morgan, the gang, and his outlaw days.

5. Javier Escualla

A Mexican Outlaw Who’s Adventures in a Pre-Revolution Country Could Change His Views

Sequel or Prequel: Prequel

The story of Javier Escualla is familiar after the Van der Linde gang disbanded, yet there remains a chance to delve into the events following the Pinkerton raid on Beaver Hollow and Arthur Morgan’s apparent demise. How did Javier react in those moments, and what series of actions led him to embrace a more cruel character, ultimately causing turmoil in Mexico upon his return?

Additionally, it’s possible that a prequel could be developed, detailing how Javier first encountered the Van der Linde gang. Given his admiration for Dutch and his ideals, it would be intriguing to explore Javier’s journey from Mexico to America where he connects with men like Dutch who share similar beliefs. This could provide a fresh perspective on Javier’s tragic story.

4. Jack Marston

The Son of John Marston Shows Vengeance is a Fools Game

Sequel or Prequel: Sequel

Carrying on John Marston’s legacy can only be achieved through his son Jack, the last living member of the Van der Linde gang. Though Jack was a child during the events portrayed in the Red Dead Redemption games, he may have picked up a couple of unwanted skills, despite his fondness for literature rather than gunslinging. As an adult and consumed by vengeance, his journey could serve as the ideal platform for his redemption following the murder of Edgar Ross.

Following Edgar Ross’s demise in 1914, Jack Marston found himself at a crossroads, with the possibility of avoiding or even participating in World War I. This scenario presents an intriguing tale about the last iconic outlaw emerging during a period when laws and conflicts were expanding on a global scale, effectively marking the end of the great American Frontier as a cherished dream.

3. The Callender Brothers

Mac and Davey Were Seen as Ruthlessly Violent, But Are They Owed Redemption?

Sequel or Prequel: Prequel

In 1899, at the beginning of “Red Dead Redemption 2”, Mac and Davey – two siblings – had previously been associates of the Van der Linde gang. Tragically, they met their ends during the Blackwater job. Unlike Arthur Morgan, who was a central figure in the original “Red Dead Redemption”, the Callender Brothers were frequently referenced within the game. This discrepancy leaves ample opportunity to delve into their past and explore their characters more deeply in a prequel storyline, one that uncovers their identities as brothers, criminals, and outlaws.

Charles Smith typically finds the Callender Brothers troublesome, frequently describing them as unruly and aggressive. However, it’s evident that the Van der Linde gang has a soft spot for them, showing sorrow upon their passing while also cautioning about their potentially dangerous nature. Introducing dual protagonists for a potential Red Dead Redemption 3 could add an intriguing layer, as players would have the chance to witness the brothers’ lives before their untimely end, making the loss of these two characters even more impactful.

2. Dutch Van der Linde

A Conman Charismatically Takes Over His Own Gang and Forms New Rivalries

Sequel or Prequel: Prequel

Dutch van der Linde might consider himself a learned philosopher with a polished demeanor, but his hidden vulnerabilities and less savory traits tend to surface unintentionally. These imperfections, combined with Dutch’s charm, could make for an enthralling tale of how he built the Van der Linde gang into its heyday, intertwining with the backstories of John Marston and Arthur Morgan, as well as the heartbreaking event involving Annabelle at the hands of Colm O’Driscoll.

Dutch Van der Linde’s tale might make for a poignant conclusion to the sequel of Red Dead Redemption 2. A climactic twist during the Blackwater ferry job, which transitions into the Colter Chapter, would surprise players and shed light on the mysterious events that transpired aboard the boat, offering insights into Dutch Van der Linde’s descent into sociopathy.

1. Hosea Matthews

A Prequel Focused on An Outlaw in Love and in His Prime

Sequel or Prequel: Prequel

Similar to Dutch’s tale, Hosea’s story could be just as heart-wrenching since it delves into his background and the establishment of the Van der Linde gang. Telling Hosea’s story comes with numerous challenges, as it would intertwine with his complex relationship with Bessie and potentially involve responsibility for younger versions of John Marston and Arthur Morgan.

Playing a prequel of “Red Dead Redemption 3” with Hosea as the main character could provide a richer exploration of his personality, significantly influencing his destiny in “Red Dead Redemption 2”. By immersing players in an entire game as him, they would witness firsthand his exceptional skills as a gunslinger and conman, revealing how he was before losing Bessie.

2025-02-03 14:34