Return To Silent Hill Has One Advantage Over The Previous Movies

by

Return To Silent Hill Has One Advantage Over The Previous Movies

Key Takeaways

  • Return to Silent Hill will be a direct adaptation of Silent Hill 2, focusing on James Sunderland’s search for his missing wife.
  • The film’s success hinges on faithful storytelling and avoiding the deviations seen in previous adaptations.
  • Director Christophe Gans’s return ensures the iconic Silent Hill atmosphere will be preserved on-screen.

As a long-time fan of the Silent Hill series, I can’t help but feel a mix of excitement and trepidation about the upcoming “Return to Silent Hill.” After the disappointing sequel, it’s refreshing to see the team going back to the roots with the plot of Silent Hill 2. Michael J. Bassett’s attempt to combine elements from the previous film and Silent Hill 3 felt like a hodgepodge that missed the mark.

Video games like horror titles such as Silent Hill are often challenging to transform into movies due to their intricate gameplay and storylines. The initial Silent Hill movie was appreciated for its eerie ambiance, but it departed significantly from the original game. Some viewers think it’s one of the better video game adaptations from the 00s, while others criticize it for deviating too far from the source material. However, the first film’s legacy pales in comparison to Silent Hill: Revelation, which tried to blend elements from the first movie’s story with those of Silent Hill 3, resulting in a disjointed experience. But it seems that Return to Silent Hill might break new ground and be the first truly successful Silent Hill film.

This month saw a true-to-life remake of the game Silent Hill 2, and it seems that the upcoming movie Silent Hill: Rise from the Ashes aims to follow suit by being a more accurate portrayal of the original game. Recent updates hint at refreshed designs for classic monsters, but it appears that the main storyline will mirror the video game’s plot closely. This should make Silent Hill: Rise from the Ashes more consistent than its predecessors.

Differences Between the First Silent Hill Game and First Film

Return To Silent Hill Has One Advantage Over The Previous Movies

As a dedicated fan, I must admit that the first “Silent Hill” movie, penned by Roger Avary and masterfully directed by Christophe Gans, certainly took creative liberties with the original game’s narrative. In this cinematic interpretation, the protagonist Harry Mason is transformed into a woman named Rose, who embarks on the chilling journey instead. Unlike Cheryl from the game, her adopted daughter in the film is called Sharon. A significant change is also seen in Rose’s personal life, as her husband, Christopher, remains alive in this version of the story.

In my gaming journey, as I hunt for Sharon amidst the haunting landscape of Silent Hill, I find myself simultaneously seeking them both in the reality we all know. During this chase, I stumble upon a chilling cult called the Brethren. As fate would have it, they had set fire to a girl who bears a striking resemblance to Sharon – a girl named Alessa. This brutal act was an attempt to cleanse her as she was born out of wedlock. The horror of this act not only consumed Alessa but also the very town itself. In her fury, Alessa’s soul shattered into two parts: the darkness within became Dark Alessa, while Sharon, her innocence, reincarnated in our world. Interestingly enough, while Dahlia, Alessa’s mother, plays an antagonistic role in the game, she is portrayed with more empathy in the film as she grapples with the loss of her daughter.

The film combines various aspects from multiple Silent Hill video games, with the music being a notable feature. Notably, this movie marked the first time Pyramid Head was featured on screen; he is frequently regarded as Silent Hill’s most terrifying monster. However, Pyramid Head didn’t emerge in the games until Silent Hill 2, where he symbolized James Sunderland’s remorse over his wife Mary’s death. In the game, Pyramid Head was created to punish James, as that is what James himself desired. Unfortunately, the portrayal of Pyramid Head in the Silent Hill movie disregarded this crucial aspect of the monster’s backstory and seemed more like an attempt to please fans.

Silent Hill: Revelation Is a Mess of a Narrative

Return To Silent Hill Has One Advantage Over The Previous Movies

The original Silent Hill film is generally praised as one of the better video game adaptations, and it’s definitely among the best from its era. Initially, Konami and Sony had Michael J. Avary and Christophe Gans involved in a sequel. However, in early 2008, Avary was arrested for vehicular manslaughter and DUI, which led to both him and Gans leaving the project. The project then found itself in a state of limbo, known as development hell.

Ultimately, M. J. Bassett was enlisted to pen and direct the sequel, blending aspects from the original film with storylines derived from Silent Hill 3. The characters Sharon and Christopher assume new identities as Heather and Harry Mason, adopting a wandering lifestyle. When Harry is abducted by the Order, Heather is compelled to revisit Silent Hill to rescue him. As it turns out, her acquaintance Vincent (portrayed by Kit Harrington, renowned from Game of Thrones) is the son of the new cult leader, Claudia. In this story, Heather aligns with Dark Alessa and the two become one entity. She unmasks Claudia as a monstrous figure known as the Missionary, and summons Pyramid Head to engage in combat, eventually leading to her demise. By the film’s end, Harry chooses to remain behind in search of Rose while Heather and Vincent make their escape, with Travis Grady from Silent Hill: Origins providing rescue.

Regrettably, the outcome produced a movie lacking the original’s ambiance. It primarily leaned on an outdated 3D trick, and had a weaker connection to the game it claimed to be based on compared to its predecessor. Despite the intention to broaden the film’s appeal beyond the first movie, it ultimately veered away from being a horror film, turning into an unintended comedy instead.

How Return to Silent Hill Can Be a Success

Return To Silent Hill Has One Advantage Over The Previous Movies

The initial “Silent Hill” movie introduced novel aspects and veered considerably from the original game. Since “Silent Hill: Revelation” carried forward the same narrative thread, it had to adhere to similar patterns. However, unlike previous installments that focused on the Da Silva/Mason family, “Return to Silent Hill” will deviate from this path. Instead, it will revolve around the storyline of the video game “Silent Hill 2,” specifically following James Sunderland as he searches for his deceased wife. This offers the creative team a unique chance for a complete reboot and fresh beginning.

On this occasion, Gans is collaborating with Sandra Vo-Anh and Will Schneider on the screenplay. Fingers crossed, this team can steer clear of the past errors and stay true to the original game as much as possible. With Gans returning as director, there’s no question that the chilling Silent Hill ambiance will grace our screens once more. As long as the narrative adheres to the game without unnecessary deviations, it appears that all the necessary components are in place for this journey to Silent Hill to be the finest yet.

Translating video games like horror masterpiece Silent Hill onto the big screen is undeniably tricky. Now, with the long-awaited cinematic adaptation gracing our screens, director Gans and his team stand on a precipice; they could either achieve a resounding success or face a significant setback. Over the years since the initial Silent Hill film, video game movies have made considerable progress. It’s evident that Gans has gained valuable insights during these nearly two decades. Here’s hoping he delivers what fans crave: a chilling psychological horror reminiscent of Silent Hill 2.

Read More

2024-10-22 02:04