Securing DeFi with AI: A New Approach to Smart Contract Audits

Author: Denis Avetisyan

Researchers have developed an agentic framework that significantly improves the accuracy and cost-effectiveness of identifying vulnerabilities in Ethereum smart contracts.

Existing strategies for auditing smart contracts undergo qualitative evaluation to reveal their strengths and weaknesses.

This paper introduces Heimdallr, a neuro-symbolic reasoning agent designed for automated smart contract auditing with a multi-stage workflow.

Despite the critical importance of smart contract security, current auditing methods struggle with scalability, precision, and cost. This paper introduces ‘An Effective and Cost-Efficient Agentic Framework for Ethereum Smart Contract Auditing’-specifically, the Heimdallr agent-which addresses these challenges through a novel neuro-symbolic approach to vulnerability detection. Our evaluations demonstrate Heimdallr’s ability to reconstruct recent real-world attacks and identify zero-day vulnerabilities with significantly reduced analysis time and financial costs, achieving up to 97.59% and 98.77% reductions respectively. Can this framework usher in a new era of automated, accessible, and robust DeFi security?

The Escalating Stakes in a Decentralized World

The decentralized finance (DeFi) landscape is experiencing exponential growth, with total value locked steadily increasing and new protocols emerging at a rapid pace. This burgeoning ecosystem, while innovative, simultaneously presents an increasingly lucrative target for malicious actors. The very characteristics that define DeFi – permissionless access, open-source code, and reliance on cryptographic security – also create vulnerabilities that can be exploited. Attackers are drawn to the substantial financial rewards potentially available through hacks and exploits, focusing on protocols that manage significant capital. Consequently, the financial stakes are rising dramatically, demanding heightened security measures and proactive vulnerability detection to protect both users and the integrity of the decentralized financial system.

Modern smart contracts, increasingly utilized in decentralized finance, present a substantial escalation in complexity compared to traditional software. This intricacy stems from factors like recursive function calls, complex data structures, and interactions with multiple contracts-features designed to enhance functionality but which simultaneously overwhelm conventional vulnerability detection techniques. Static analysis, while useful for identifying obvious errors, often struggles with the nuanced logic and stateful behavior inherent in these contracts, leading to a high rate of false negatives. Similarly, fuzzing, a dynamic testing method, requires immense computational resources to adequately explore the vast state space created by complex interactions. Consequently, vulnerabilities that bypass these established methods are increasingly prevalent, creating attractive opportunities for malicious actors and raising the stakes for developers and users alike. The limitations of existing tools necessitate a shift towards more sophisticated and adaptable security measures to mitigate the growing risk of exploits in the rapidly evolving landscape of decentralized applications.

The pursuit of secure smart contracts faces a persistent hurdle: zero-day vulnerabilities – flaws unknown to developers and therefore lacking existing patches. Traditional static analysis, while valuable for identifying known error patterns, proves insufficient against these novel threats. Researchers are now actively exploring dynamic analysis techniques – including fuzzing and symbolic execution – to proactively uncover weaknesses by subjecting contracts to a wide range of inputs and conditions. Furthermore, the integration of machine learning models, trained on historical exploit data, offers a promising avenue for anomaly detection and predictive vulnerability assessment. This shift towards proactive, runtime-focused security measures is crucial, as the financial incentives for exploiting zero-day flaws in rapidly expanding decentralized finance ecosystems continue to escalate, demanding a constant evolution in defensive strategies.

Heimdallr: Augmenting Security Through Intelligent Automation

Heimdallr addresses limitations in current smart contract auditing practices by introducing an automated agent designed to enhance both the scale and accuracy of vulnerability detection. Traditional auditing methods are often manually intensive and struggle to keep pace with the increasing complexity of smart contracts, leading to potential security risks. Heimdallr aims to overcome these challenges through automated analysis, enabling the review of a larger code base with improved precision. This is achieved by combining large language models with neuro-symbolic reasoning techniques, offering a more systematic and reliable approach to identifying potential exploits compared to purely manual or solely automated methods.

Heimdallr employs a Plan-Remind-Solve workflow to conduct systematic vulnerability analysis of smart contracts. The ‘Plan’ phase involves decomposing the contract into constituent parts and generating a plan for focused analysis, prioritizing areas likely to contain vulnerabilities. The ‘Remind’ phase retrieves relevant security knowledge, including previously identified bug patterns and exploit techniques, to inform the analysis. Finally, the ‘Solve’ phase executes the plan, applying the retrieved knowledge to detect potential vulnerabilities within the contract code, and generates a report detailing findings and recommended remediation steps. This structured workflow ensures comprehensive coverage and reduces the likelihood of overlooking critical security flaws.

Heimdallr demonstrates an 86.7% detection rate for high-value smart contract exploits, as measured against a benchmark dataset. This performance is achieved through the integration of Large Language Model (LLM)-based auditing techniques with neuro-symbolic reasoning, allowing for both broad pattern recognition and formal verification of potential vulnerabilities. The system’s overall performance is quantified by an F1 score of 0.62, indicating a balance between precision and recall in vulnerability detection. This combination of detection rate and F1 score results in a substantial improvement in both the coverage of potential vulnerabilities and the efficiency of security analysts performing contract audits.

Heimdallr is implemented as a modular system enabling flexible control and adaptation to diverse robotic platforms.

Precision Through Context and Formal Verification

Contextual profiling within Heimdallr addresses the computational limitations imposed by analyzing large and complex smart contracts. This technique dynamically manages the analysis context by prioritizing and focusing on relevant code sections, thereby circumventing the constraints of fixed context windows. By identifying and tracking data flow within specific function calls and contract interactions, contextual profiling enables efficient static analysis without requiring the full contract state to be loaded into memory at once. This targeted approach significantly reduces computational overhead and allows Heimdallr to process contracts exceeding typical context limits, improving both analysis speed and scalability.

Heimdallr incorporates Slither, a static analysis framework, to generate dependency graphs representing the control and data flow within smart contract code. These graphs visually map the relationships between contract components, functions, and variables, enabling a detailed understanding of potential execution paths. This dependency graph serves as the foundational input for subsequent vulnerability analysis stages, allowing Heimdallr to trace how data is used and modified, and to identify potential attack vectors stemming from complex interactions between contract elements. The use of Slither facilitates the detection of vulnerabilities related to control flow hijacking, incorrect state management, and unintended data exposure.

Heimdallr employs the Z3 Theorem Prover to mitigate false positives during vulnerability analysis. This involves formally verifying potential vulnerabilities by constructing logical constraints based on the contract’s code and execution paths. The Z3 Solver then attempts to satisfy these constraints; if a constraint cannot be satisfied, it indicates the reported vulnerability is likely a false positive. This automated verification process significantly reduces noise in the vulnerability reports, improving the efficiency of security audits by focusing analysts on genuine security concerns and minimizing investigation time wasted on non-issues.

Heimdallr’s compatibility extends to both Solidity and Vyper, two prominent smart contract programming languages used on the Ethereum blockchain. This multi-language support significantly broadens the scope of security assessments that can be performed using the tool. While many static analysis tools focus solely on Solidity, Heimdallr’s inclusion of Vyper allows for comprehensive evaluations of a wider range of smart contract codebases, increasing the overall coverage of potential vulnerabilities within the Ethereum ecosystem. This capability is crucial as developers increasingly adopt Vyper for its security-focused design and different approach to gas costs.

Heimdallr’s efficacy in identifying real-world vulnerabilities has been demonstrated through its successful reproduction of 17 out of 20 publicly known smart contract exploits. This testing methodology utilized a dataset of established vulnerabilities, allowing for quantitative validation of the tool’s detection capabilities. The 85% reproduction rate indicates a high degree of accuracy in identifying and replicating known attack vectors, suggesting Heimdallr’s potential for proactive security auditing and vulnerability discovery in deployed smart contracts. The four exploits not reproduced are currently under investigation to determine the root cause of the discrepancy and to further refine Heimdallr’s detection algorithms.

Scaling Security for a Resilient Decentralized Future

Smart contract security often lags behind the rapid scaling of decentralized applications, creating a critical bottleneck as codebases grow increasingly complex. Traditional security tools struggle to efficiently analyze large amounts of code, leading to vulnerabilities slipping through the cracks. Heimdallr directly addresses this challenge by enhancing scalability in vulnerability detection, allowing for the thorough examination of expansive smart contracts without sacrificing speed or accuracy. This improved capacity is crucial for securing the expanding decentralized finance (DeFi) ecosystem, where even minor flaws can lead to substantial financial losses and erode user confidence. By efficiently handling larger codebases, Heimdallr ensures that security assessments keep pace with development, fostering a more robust and trustworthy decentralized future.

A heightened precision in vulnerability detection directly mitigates the financial and reputational risks inherent in decentralized systems. By minimizing false positives and, crucially, reducing false negatives – undetected vulnerabilities – the potential for costly exploits is substantially lowered. This isn’t merely about preventing immediate financial loss; accurate vulnerability identification fosters a stronger foundation of user trust, a critical element for the sustained growth of decentralized finance (DeFi). When users are confident in the security of smart contracts and decentralized applications, participation increases, liquidity improves, and the entire ecosystem benefits from a more stable and reliable operating environment. Ultimately, enhanced precision translates into a more secure and dependable future for decentralized technologies.

Recent evaluations indicate Heimdallr achieves a noteworthy 35.6% improvement in vulnerability detection rates when contrasted with the Claude baseline. This substantial performance gain signifies a considerable advancement in the precision and efficacy of smart contract security tools. The increased detection rate translates directly into a reduced likelihood of successful exploits, bolstering the integrity of decentralized applications and minimizing potential financial losses for users. This benchmark highlights Heimdallr’s capability to identify a significantly larger proportion of security flaws compared to existing solutions, suggesting its potential to become a leading tool in safeguarding the rapidly expanding decentralized finance (DeFi) landscape.

Heimdallr presents a compelling economic advantage for developers and organizations prioritizing smart contract security. Current vulnerability detection tools often carry substantial operational costs, hindering widespread adoption, particularly for smaller projects. However, Heimdallr achieves a significant reduction in these expenses, operating at just $0.59 per 10,000 lines of code (LOC) analyzed. This cost-effectiveness stems from its innovative neuro-symbolic architecture, which optimizes resource utilization without compromising accuracy. By substantially lowering the financial barrier to comprehensive security audits, Heimdallr enables broader participation in the decentralized ecosystem and fosters a more secure and trustworthy environment for users and investors alike.

The burgeoning decentralized finance (DeFi) landscape, while innovative, remains acutely vulnerable to security breaches, demanding adaptable and robust protective measures. A neuro-symbolic approach, such as that demonstrated by Heimdallr, offers a compelling solution by integrating the pattern recognition capabilities of neural networks with the logical rigor of symbolic reasoning. This synergy allows for not only the detection of known vulnerability signatures, but also the identification of novel attack vectors that might elude traditional static analysis tools. As the DeFi ecosystem continues its exponential growth, and smart contract complexity increases, this capacity for proactive, intelligent security becomes indispensable; it’s anticipated that this methodology will form a foundational layer for trust and stability, enabling continued innovation while mitigating the ever-present risk of exploitation and financial loss.

Heimdallr’s design embodies a principle of reductive clarity. The agent prioritizes focused analysis through its multi-stage workflow, effectively stripping away extraneous information to pinpoint vulnerabilities with enhanced precision. This echoes Donald Knuth’s sentiment: “Premature optimization is the root of all evil.” While not directly about optimization, the framework’s success hinges on a similar philosophy – delaying complex additions until a solid, streamlined core is established. The neuro-symbolic reasoning component, in particular, exemplifies this, favoring deliberate, interpretable steps over brute-force approaches. It’s a testament to the power of concentrating on what remains essential for accurate vulnerability detection within the complex landscape of Ethereum smart contracts.

What Lies Ahead?

Heimdallr offers a pragmatic advance. Yet, efficacy isn’t absolution. Current evaluations center on vulnerability detection. Future work must address prevention. Can such agents proactively shape secure contracts, rather than merely finding flaws? This is the core shift.

Neuro-symbolic systems remain brittle. They demand curated knowledge. Abstractions age; principles don’t. The field needs agents that learn from failure-that refine their symbolic reasoning without endless human intervention. Every complexity needs an alibi. Can these systems justify their decisions, offering transparent audit trails, not just positive/negative assessments?

Cost-efficiency is a relative measure. True scalability demands minimal resource consumption. The focus should move beyond incremental gains in detection rate. It should explore fundamentally new approaches to contract analysis-approaches that sidestep the combinatorial explosion inherent in complex code. The goal isn’t merely to automate existing audits; it’s to redefine what an audit is.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.17833.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

The Escalating Stakes in a Decentralized World

Heimdallr: Augmenting Security Through Intelligent Automation

Precision Through Context and Formal Verification

Scaling Security for a Resilient Decentralized Future

What Lies Ahead?

See also: