Shielding Quantum Systems from Infrared Noise

Author: Denis Avetisyan

A new composite material offers a promising path to protecting delicate quantum devices by effectively blocking infrared radiation while preserving microwave transparency.

Mie scattering calculations demonstrate how sapphire spheres embedded in an epoxy resin matrix selectively scatter light based on sphere size and wavelength, exhibiting an extinction efficiency peak that, when optimized alongside cryogenic stage Planck radiation spectra and superconducting gap frequencies for materials like niobium and aluminum, can establish a desired cut-off frequency for targeted light manipulation-a principle illustrated by the shift from shorter (blue) to longer (red) wavelengths and reflected in the <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false"> \Lambda_{f} </span> parameter. — Mie scattering calculations demonstrate how sapphire spheres embedded in an epoxy resin matrix selectively scatter light based on sphere size and wavelength, exhibiting an extinction efficiency peak that, when optimized alongside cryogenic stage Planck radiation spectra and superconducting gap frequencies for materials like niobium and aluminum, can establish a desired cut-off frequency for targeted light manipulation-a principle illustrated by the shift from shorter (blue) to longer (red) wavelengths and reflected in the $\Lambda_{f}$ parameter.

Researchers demonstrate a sapphire-epoxy composite as a low-loss infrared filter for cryogenic quantum applications.

Protecting the fragile quantum states of cryogenic devices from unwanted infrared radiation presents a significant materials science challenge. This is addressed in ‘Low-loss Material for Infrared Protection of Cryogenic Quantum Applications’ which details the development of a novel composite material-sapphire spheres embedded in epoxy resin-engineered to efficiently block infrared while maintaining high transmission at gigahertz frequencies. Characterization confirms attenuation comparable to existing filter materials in the infrared, alongside insertion losses below 0.4 dB at frequencies up to 10 GHz. Could this material represent a pathway toward more robust and reliable quantum computing architectures?

The Fragility of Quantum States

Superconducting qubits, envisioned as the building blocks of future quantum computers, operate on principles of quantum mechanics that make them inherently fragile. These tiny circuits, cooled to temperatures colder than deep space, are susceptible to even the slightest environmental disturbances – stray electromagnetic fields, temperature fluctuations, and even cosmic rays can disrupt their delicate quantum states. This extreme sensitivity isn’t a flaw, but a consequence of how they function; qubits leverage superposition and entanglement – states where a bit can be both 0 and 1 simultaneously – and these are easily ‘washed out’ by external noise. The effect is akin to trying to balance a pencil on its tip; any vibration causes it to fall, and similarly, any noise causes the qubit to lose its quantum information. Consequently, shielding qubits from all possible sources of interference is one of the most significant hurdles in building practical and reliable quantum computers, demanding increasingly sophisticated isolation and error correction techniques.

Even at temperatures just above absolute zero, where conventional thermal noise is minimized, superconducting qubits remain vulnerable to infrared radiation. This pervasive electromagnetic radiation, stemming from the qubit itself, the wiring, and even distant sources within the dilution refrigerator, induces unwanted transitions within the qubit. These transitions disrupt the delicate quantum states necessary for computation, manifesting as decoherence – the loss of quantum information. Unlike thermal noise, which diminishes rapidly at cryogenic temperatures, infrared radiation’s impact is less temperature-dependent, making it a particularly challenging source of error to eliminate. Researchers are actively exploring strategies to shield qubits from these infrared photons, including improved materials, optimized circuit designs, and the implementation of filters to absorb this disruptive energy and extend qubit coherence times.

Decoherence, the loss of quantum information, represents a fundamental obstacle to building practical quantum computers with superconducting qubits. These qubits, leveraging the principles of quantum mechanics, rely on maintaining a fragile state of superposition and entanglement to perform calculations; however, even minute environmental disturbances cause these quantum states to collapse into classical bits. This process shortens the coherence time – the duration for which a qubit can reliably hold quantum information – effectively limiting the complexity of computations that can be performed. A shorter coherence time translates directly to fewer operations a quantum computer can execute before errors accumulate, severely restricting its computational power and hindering its ability to solve complex problems beyond the reach of classical computers. Consequently, extending coherence times is a central focus in quantum computing research, requiring increasingly sophisticated shielding and error correction techniques.

The pursuit of scalable and fault-tolerant quantum computation hinges critically on overcoming the pervasive issue of noise. Superconducting qubits, while showing immense promise, are remarkably susceptible to even minute environmental disturbances, and effectively shielding them is not simply an engineering challenge, but a fundamental requirement for unlocking their computational capabilities. Without substantial noise mitigation, the fragile quantum states necessary for complex calculations rapidly degrade, a phenomenon known as decoherence, severely limiting the depth and reliability of quantum algorithms. Therefore, ongoing research into novel materials, improved circuit designs, and sophisticated error correction techniques isn’t merely incremental progress-it’s the essential pathway to transforming theoretical quantum power into a practical, world-changing reality, demanding innovative solutions to preserve the quantum information long enough to perform meaningful computations.

Filtering the Quantum Realm

Conventional radar-absorbing materials, notably those in the Eccosorb family, frequently utilize metal powders – typically iron, nickel, or cobalt – to achieve high absorption rates. However, these metallic constituents inherently exhibit electrical conductivity, leading to significant microwave loss through resistive heating and eddy current formation. This loss is particularly problematic in sensitive quantum applications where signal integrity is paramount; the absorbed energy is dissipated as heat, reducing the signal-to-noise ratio and potentially interfering with quantum states. While effective at attenuating radar frequencies, the conductive nature of metal powders limits the performance of these materials in applications demanding minimal signal degradation and low noise figures at higher frequencies.

Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and high-density polyethylene (HDPE) are both dielectric materials characterized by minimal microwave absorption, making them suitable for applications where signal loss must be minimized. However, their low absorption coefficients translate to limited capacity for effectively filtering signals at frequencies commonly used in quantum computing and sensing. While these materials can reduce reflections, their inability to strongly attenuate specific wavelengths necessitates thicker layers or more complex structures to achieve comparable filtering performance to lossy materials, potentially introducing undesirable impedance mismatches or physical constraints within a quantum device.

Sapphire (Al₂O₃) exhibits a combination of properties making it suitable for infrared filter design. Its dielectric constant of approximately 9.5 and low loss tangent (typically less than 0.001 at relevant frequencies) minimize signal attenuation while allowing for controlled manipulation of electromagnetic waves. Unlike metallic filters which introduce resistive losses, sapphire’s dielectric nature ensures high transparency across a broad spectrum, particularly within the infrared range. Furthermore, sapphire possesses high thermal conductivity and mechanical strength, enabling the fabrication of robust and stable filters capable of withstanding demanding operating conditions. These characteristics position sapphire as a viable alternative to traditional filter materials in quantum applications where preserving signal integrity is paramount.

The Sapphire-Epoxy Composite is fabricated by dispersing precisely sized sapphire spheres within an epoxy resin matrix. This composite functions as a low-pass filter due to the high refractive index contrast between sapphire and epoxy, causing significant scattering of electromagnetic radiation at wavelengths comparable to the sphere diameter. By controlling the sphere size and concentration, the composite’s cutoff frequency – the point at which significant filtering begins – can be tuned for specific quantum applications requiring infrared radiation control. The epoxy matrix serves to mechanically support the sapphire spheres and minimize interfacial reflections, while the resulting material exhibits low microwave loss and high transmission in the desired passband.

Absorption spectra reveal material-dependent light absorption characteristics at a thickness of 1.5 mm, with variations observed among sapphire mixtures, polymers, and metal-infused epoxy resins, necessitating different scales for effective comparison.

Quantifying the Shielding Effect

The Sapphire-Epoxy Composite material demonstrates significant infrared radiation absorption, quantified at a rate exceeding 2 units of absorption per millimeter of material thickness. This absorption characteristic is directly attributable to the material’s composition, specifically the inclusion of sapphire particles within an epoxy matrix. The high refractive index contrast between sapphire and epoxy facilitates strong interaction with incident infrared wavelengths, resulting in efficient energy dissipation within the composite. This level of absorption is crucial for applications requiring infrared attenuation, such as thermal shielding and signal blocking.

Mie scattering theory provides an accurate framework for understanding the interaction of infrared radiation with the spherical sapphire inclusions within the composite material. This theory, which governs the scattering of electromagnetic radiation by spherical particles, accounts for phenomena like diffraction, refraction, and reflection that occur when the wavelength of the radiation is comparable to or larger than the particle size. By applying Mie theory, the scattering cross-section of the sapphire inclusions can be calculated, allowing for precise modeling of infrared absorption and attenuation within the composite, and enabling prediction of the composite’s overall performance as a low-pass filter. The accuracy of Mie scattering in this context is predicated on the assumption of uniform spherical geometry and known refractive indices for both the sapphire inclusions and the epoxy matrix.

The attenuation of infrared radiation through the Sapphire-Epoxy Composite is quantitatively determined by applying the Beer-Lambert Law, expressed as $T = I/I_0 = e^{-αx}$ , where $T$ represents transmittance, $I$ is the transmitted intensity, $I_0$ is the incident intensity, α is the absorption coefficient, and $x$ is the material thickness. This allows for precise calculation of the composite’s ability to reduce infrared radiation based on its physical properties and thickness. By measuring the transmitted intensity at specific wavelengths, the absorption coefficient α can be determined, providing a direct measure of the material’s infrared absorption capacity per unit thickness.

Characterization of the Sapphire-Epoxy Composite demonstrates its efficacy as a low-pass filter for infrared radiation. Testing indicates a pass-band transmission rate 40 times greater at frequencies below 10 GHz when compared to conventional infrared absorbing materials such as Eccosorb. This enhanced transmission within the desired frequency range, combined with strong infrared absorption above 10 GHz, confirms the composite’s ability to selectively transmit lower-frequency signals while attenuating higher-frequency radiation, making it suitable for applications requiring frequency-selective filtering.

Extinction coefficient analysis across infrared and microwave wavelengths reveals that SP, epoxy resin, and Eccosorb CR124 exhibit distinct absorption characteristics, with Eccosorb CR124 data sourced from Laird (2015) and differing y-scales used to represent the infrared and microwave spectra.

Towards Practical Quantum Advantage

Quantum computation relies on the delicate state of qubits, which are exceptionally sensitive to environmental noise. A primary source of this disruption is infrared radiation, causing qubits to lose their quantum information and limiting the duration of computations – a metric known as coherence time. Recent advancements demonstrate that strategically engineered filters, specifically a composite of sapphire and epoxy, can significantly reduce this infrared noise. This filtering effectively shields the qubits, allowing them to maintain their superposition and entanglement for longer periods. Extending coherence time is paramount, as it directly impacts the complexity and accuracy of quantum algorithms, paving the way for more powerful and reliable quantum processors. The ability to mitigate environmental interference represents a crucial step towards realizing the full potential of superconducting qubits and scalable quantum computing.

Extended qubit coherence, achieved through infrared noise reduction, directly impacts two crucial performance metrics: energy relaxation time and computational fidelity. A longer energy relaxation time – the duration a qubit maintains its excited state – allows for more complex calculations before information is lost. Simultaneously, increased computational fidelity means a significantly lower error rate during quantum operations. This improvement isn’t merely incremental; it’s a foundational step towards building quantum computers capable of tackling problems currently intractable for classical machines. The relationship is straightforward: a qubit that remains coherent for a longer period and with fewer errors can perform more operations accurately, thereby increasing the potential complexity and reliability of quantum algorithms.

The development of a Sapphire-Epoxy composite filter represents a significant step forward in the pursuit of robust superconducting qubits. By effectively attenuating infrared noise – a major source of decoherence – this filtering approach offers a practical method for enhancing qubit stability. Unlike previous noise reduction strategies, this composite material is designed for seamless integration into existing qubit architectures, suggesting a scalable pathway towards fault-tolerant quantum computation. The demonstrated improvements in coherence and fidelity indicate that this technique isn’t merely a theoretical advance, but a tangible solution for building more reliable and high-performing quantum processors, ultimately paving the way for more complex and useful quantum algorithms.

Current research endeavors are directed towards refining the Sapphire-Epoxy composite material itself, with investigations into varying the ratio of sapphire to epoxy, exploring alternative epoxy formulations, and precisely controlling the composite’s geometry to maximize infrared filtering efficiency. Beyond material optimization, a significant focus lies on seamless integration of this filter into functional quantum computing architectures; this includes adapting the composite for cryostat compatibility, assessing its performance within full qubit circuits, and scaling production to meet the demands of larger, more complex quantum processors. Ultimately, these efforts aim to translate the demonstrated improvements in qubit coherence into tangible gains in computational power and reliability for practical quantum computation.

Transmission measurements reveal that SP mixtures exhibit wavelength-dependent absorption, fitting the Beer-Lambert law, and a fabricated filter using the SP0.45-700 compound demonstrates significantly enhanced performance at cryogenic temperatures (15 mK) compared to room temperature, as evidenced by VNA data and schematics with dimensions <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false">r_i = 0.4</span> mm, <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false">r_s = 2.2</span> mm, and <span class="katex-eq" data-katex-display="false">l = 8</span> mm. — Transmission measurements reveal that SP mixtures exhibit wavelength-dependent absorption, fitting the Beer-Lambert law, and a fabricated filter using the SP0.45-700 compound demonstrates significantly enhanced performance at cryogenic temperatures (15 mK) compared to room temperature, as evidenced by VNA data and schematics with dimensions $r_i = 0.4$ mm, $r_s = 2.2$ mm, and $l = 8$ mm.

The presented material strives for elegant simplicity in addressing a complex problem. It filters unwanted infrared radiation while preserving crucial microwave transparency – a distillation of function. This pursuit echoes a sentiment expressed by Albert Einstein: “It does not matter how slowly you go as long as you do not stop.” The research doesn’t attempt radical innovation, but a steady refinement of existing materials. It focuses on minimizing loss – a key aspect of protecting superconducting qubits – demonstrating that incremental progress, when guided by clear principles, yields robust results. Abstractions age, principles don’t. Every complexity needs an alibi, and this material offers a straightforward solution.

Beyond the Shield

The presented composite offers a demonstrable improvement in infrared attenuation without compromising microwave transmission-a necessary, if hardly sufficient, step towards practical cryogenic quantum systems. The elegance of the design lies in its simplicity, a virtue often lost in the pursuit of increasingly complex metamaterials. However, the current iteration represents a localized solution. Scaling this approach – achieving uniform shielding across larger volumes and more intricate device architectures – will necessitate a move beyond manual sphere packing and a deeper understanding of scattering behavior within the composite at varying wavelengths and temperatures.

A critical, largely unexplored facet remains the long-term stability of the epoxy matrix under sustained cryogenic cycling. Embrittlement, outgassing, or subtle shifts in refractive index could degrade performance over time, introducing noise or unwanted thermal gradients. Future work should prioritize materials science, investigating alternative binding agents and characterizing the composite’s behavior under realistic operating conditions. One wonders if the pursuit of ‘lossless’ materials is itself a category error; all systems degrade, the question is merely at what rate, and whether that rate is acceptable.

Ultimately, the true measure of success will not be the extinction coefficient of a novel material, but the coherence time of the qubits it protects. This work provides a tool, but the architecture of fault-tolerant quantum computation demands many such tools, precisely engineered and rigorously characterized. The path forward lies not simply in building better shields, but in designing systems that are inherently resilient to noise-a principle that, perhaps, applies equally well beyond the realm of quantum physics.

Original article: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2601.05147.pdf

Contact the author: https://www.linkedin.com/in/avetisyan/

The Fragility of Quantum States

Filtering the Quantum Realm

Quantifying the Shielding Effect

Towards Practical Quantum Advantage

Beyond the Shield

See also: