Shrek 5's Risky Plot Could Sink the Franchise

Summary

Shrek 5 seems to be taking a major risk with its setting, transporting Shrek and Donkey to the human world.
Audiences are concerned that a change in setting will impact the unique fantasy world environment that defined the Shrek franchise.
The decision to lean into internet culture for laughs in Shrek 5 may lead to a dated, silly fourth-wall-breaking mess that veers away from the heart of the franchise.

The recent announcement regarding the cast for Shrek 5, confirming Zendaya’s involvement, has sparked conversations about what we might expect when it hits cinemas on Christmas 2026. It seems that Shrek 5 will center around Shrek and Fiona’s family dynamics as they navigate their children’s growth. However, details about the movie’s main storyline remain scarce.

On the other hand, it seems that the plot direction suggested for Shrek 5 might not be well-received. Dreamworks seems to be venturing into uncharted territory in an attempt to offer something new to fans. Given Shrek’s immense popularity and global impact on millions of people, this decision could potentially spark a strong reaction from the fanbase.

Shrek 5 Is Reportedly Making A Big Switch With Its Setting

This Is Going To Be A Major Risk

The brief trailer for Shrek 5 didn’t reveal much about the plot, but it did share Zendaya’s casting news, the upcoming release date, and a significant update on the animation style change that has sparked controversy. However, according to the industry insider MyTimeToShineHello, Shrek 5 will find Shrek and Donkey being transported into the real, human world we inhabit. This move would separate them from their beloved co-characters, which some consider a potential misstep since the chemistry between these two characters has been carefully developed over the course of four films and is what audiences have come to expect.

In other words, exploring Shrek and Donkey in the human world could open up some intriguing narrative possibilities, however, it’s a considerable risk since it departs significantly from the traditional elements that have defined the Shrek franchise. Fans anticipate certain elements in a Shrek film, so placing most of the story within a human setting might not resonate well with many viewers. This change is substantial for the franchise, especially after four movies, which makes this decision a challenging one. It demonstrates Dreamworks’ creativity, but there’s a strong likelihood that it may not strike the right chord with some audiences due to specific reasons.

The Shrek Franchise Is Known For Being In A Fantasy World

Audiences Want To See Shrek In That Environment

The initial four Shrek films have been constructed within a captivating fantasy realm teeming with enchanting fairytale figures, all coexisting in a unique environment. These movies have crafted an exhilarating backdrop for this harmonious existence, and remarkably, humans are neither considered nor mentioned – which is a beneficial choice. Unlike certain animated films that thrive in human settings, such as The Secret Life of Pets, the Shrek universe doesn’t require or benefit from the inclusion of human characters. Instead, audiences prefer to witness Shrek tromping through his swamp or besieging a castle with a dragon, rather than navigating a world where humans are preoccupied with their phones.

In essence, introducing Shrek into a human world in Shrek 5 might bring the franchise back to its roots, but with a fresh twist. The original Shrek film opened by depicting most characters being afraid of Shrek because of his size and temperament, which seems reminiscent of the narrative that could unfold in Shrek 5. However, having an ogre roam among humans might evoke familiar fears, potentially leading to a repetitive storyline.

Shrek Is Leaning Into The Internet Culture

This Is Likely Being Done For Cheap Laughs

A significant concern about Shrek entering the human world is that Dreamworks might capitalize on the modern online culture associated with the franchise. Over the past few years, Shrek has become popular on platforms like YouTube and TikTok, often appearing in adult-oriented scenarios that may not be suitable for all audiences. Some of these scenes were hinted at in the trailer, such as the TikTok meme where Shrek is enlarged, dressed in latex attire, and dancing across buildings. These jokes can seem cheap and could potentially make the movie feel outdated if it heavily incorporates this type of content. Movies set in a human world have a tendency to fall into this trap, which is why the timelessness of Shrek’s fantasy realm makes it an effective franchise. Audiences wouldn’t appreciate Shrek 5 embracing the internet’s obsession with him because most of it isn’t family-friendly, and it diminishes his character as a joke.

In the teaser, Shrek recognizing certain trends might make it easier for humans to identify him when he enters their world. This could present an unusual twist from the usual fear people have of him, but it risks becoming a chaotic break of the fourth wall that may turn out to be overly comedic and fast-paced. The choice to embrace such situations seems questionable due to its potential cheapness and risk, which is why there’s concern. Instead, audiences don’t want Shrek 5 to be a hasty production solely for the sake of it; they crave the enchanting animation and emotional depth that has characterized the first four films.

2025-04-07 15:35

Shrek 5’s Risky Plot Could Sink the Franchise