Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

As a die-hard fan of the original Silent Hill 2, I must admit that this remake has left me utterly speechless. The way they’ve managed to preserve the essence of the game while enhancing its story, characters, and overall experience is nothing short of remarkable.


The fog is thick, heavy in ways that only grief can burden.

The town of Silent Hill calls, beckoning, taking on a familiar name and face to entice us closer. What motivates us forward: regret, hope, fear? It won’t matter, you’ll soon come face to face with these demons, metaphorically and literally.

Expressing that the Silent Hill games hold significant importance for me is actually a modest statement. This game series has been an integral part of my upbringing – figuratively and literally. It instilled fear in me in ways that no other survival horror games have managed, even today; thus, it holds a deeply emotional connection for me, and I believe fellow fans harbor the same affection towards it.

Upon Konami revealing the remake of Silent Hill 2, responses varied, encompassing both enthusiasm and apprehension. Many fans are still disheartened over the cancellation of Silent Hills (known as P.T.), and they fear this could be another instance where the game would serve solely as a money-making venture, adding to Konami’s long list of questionable decisions.

However, it appears that Bloober Team has managed to change our expectations with the launch of this remake, rekindling the passion among fans that had been missing for so long.

In other words, the reboot faced immense pressure from fans’ anticipation, as it needed to live up to its predecessor. Luckily, it managed to exceed all expectations.

Eerie Doesn’t Begin To Cover It

This game truly excels in its overall ambiance; there’s no doubt about it. Instead of concentrating on combat with monsters, the developers at Bloober Team chose to emphasize psychological terror, a decision that undeniably paid off for them.

In the game called Silent Hill, there are two primary realms: the eerie town of Silent Hill and an alternate dimension known as the Otherworld. Each world has a distinct feel, yet they both deliver chilling, location-specific fears in their unique ways.

In the realm unlike our own, the terror is strikingly immediate: an overwhelming gloom and grotesque creatures set to the calming melodies of composer Akira Yamaoka’s washer. Yet, the town itself exudes a chilling unease, stirring feelings of suspicion.

Having been raised on the Silent Hill series, I’ve become remarkably resilient to fear. Yet, there I stood, frozen with terror, doubting if I had the courage to take even one more step further into the enshrouding mist.

The Silent Hill 2 Remake can be summed up as genuinely terrifying. There’s simply no other way to express it, as it seems to ooze dread from every nook and cranny of its maps.

In this game, the horror is constructed exceptionally well, even including the sudden shock moments known as jump scares. Unlike most instances where these are considered cheap tactics to frighten players, they serve as a form of relief here. The overall ambiance keeps you on edge and tense, much like a taut spring ready to release at any moment.

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

A specific adversary, the Mannequin Pairs (joined mannequin legs), doesn’t trigger the radar, because it can conceal itself and assume an immobile stance.

They excel at setting ambushes, and as the game advances, they become capable of climbing walls and traversing ceilings, the soft tapping of their feet sending a creepy sensation down your spine.

These monstrous creatures grow more menacing as an ominous fear pervades the surroundings, becoming even scarier when they begin to emit sounds of their own.

For instance, the characters known as the “Bubble Head Nurses” are often observed to jerk or make noises, sounds that echo through the lengthy, dim, vacant corridors of the hospital in Silent Hill.

The sounds are enough to stop you in your tracks and make you second-guess whether you really want to move forward (and then you do, see them creepily twitching, and then hit them with a Steel Pipe).

True Survival Horror

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

True to the style of Silent Hill, resources are scarce, particularly on higher difficulty levels. Remember to heal promptly when necessary, or else you might encounter one of the game’s unfavorable conclusions, similar to the warnings given by Resident Evil.

In the remake of Silent Hill 2, there are a couple of gameplay concerns to be aware of. For instance, during scenes with heavy action or movement, you might experience some frame rate drops, lag, and technical glitches.

In situations where strong winds distort the landscape, swarms of insects scuttle across walls, or similar occurrences take place, there might be noticeable frame drops. Generally, I’m not overly concerned about such matters, but since this game was played on a PlayStation 5 in ‘Performance Mode’, these types of problems shouldn’t arise.

Beyond that, the game carries a challenging difficulty and poor visibility as well. It isn’t merely its grim tone that makes it tough, but the fact that certain areas are so dimly lit that the flashlight hardly provides any help at all, even under the suggested game settings.

Certainly, there’s a sense of fear in that, but also annoyance, particularly when you find yourself clinging to walls to figure out your path, and in certain places where maps aren’t immediately provided. To ensure you can spot things more easily and navigate with some comfort, it might be helpful to bump up the settings brightness slightly beyond what’s recommended.

As a gamer, I find myself constantly grappling with the issue of that over-the-shoulder camera setup. While it does manage to create an intense sense of closeness and claustrophobia, it unfortunately doesn’t do much for improving the lighting or addressing those pesky bugs. In tight, confined spaces, it feels like the camera is right there with me, but this proximity often results in visual glitches as the camera struggles to keep up its position, only to get stuck against a wall.

The Unreal Engine further amplified these issues, particularly due to its size and camera movement restrictions. At times, it gives the impression that the Silent Hill 2 Remake is merely a fan-made game. Now, I’m not saying it’s poorly done; quite the contrary, it’s exceptionally well crafted. However, as a AAA title produced by a renowned studio like Konami, it should have a more polished look that surpasses the appearance of a dedicated fan project.

Fortunately, not the entire game resembles this, but certain aspects are quite distinguishable.

All that said, the gameplay is still loads of fun.

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

The adversaries possess predictable attack patterns that are straightforward to learn and avoid, followed by a counter-attack. However, it’s important to note that they cause damage when they strike you, so learning how to dodge effectively should be your top priority, as you don’t want to find yourself getting hit frequently and quickly depleting the limited health resources available.

Also, familiarize yourself with close-quarter fights since ammunition is scarce. It’s best to conserve bullets for boss encounters and critical situations.

Regarding the puzzles, they offered a moderate level of challenge, more like an average setting. Perhaps I’ve become accustomed to solving puzzles in games such as Silent Hill, but they didn’t require extensive brainstorming and were quite inventive instead.

Some instances and brain-teasers were directly lifted from the original game as well. To illustrate, in the original version of the game, during the initial confrontation with the renowned character Pyramid Head, players needed to evade him until the sirens started sounding once more. In the remake, this first boss battle follows the same pattern, offering experienced players a chance to use strategies they mastered in the original game.

Talking about the game’s rewards, it’s extraordinarily satisfying for those players who take the time to thoroughly investigate their surroundings. If you’re like me, always taking a close look at every detail in a room to see what can be interacted with, you’ll discover plenty of goodies and hidden delights that make the exploration an enjoyable experience.

Here’s one way of paraphrasing the passage: One instance in the game involves numerous locked doors (prepare yourself, there are many). By thoroughly exploring my map and opening every door, I discovered extra resources and even earned an achievement after 50 attempts. It’s not classified information, but it’s a satisfying reward to show that all your hard work isn’t in vain.

At least, that’s what James is telling himself throughout this ordeal.

Wholly Authentic to the Original

Bloober Team understood the assignment perfectly.

Silent Hill 2 is brimming with symbolism and visual imagery, and the remake doesn’t strip any of these layers off. Instead, it seems to enrich them even further, making the narrative more captivating. The characters are more vivid and appealing, including the challenging Eddie, whose boss battle is now more enjoyable due to a refreshed approach.

In Silent Hill 2, the themes are incredibly deep and heavy, which could be challenging for some new players. Consequently, a cautionary notice is displayed at the start of the game to prepare them. This approach is sensitive and well-executed.

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

Thankfully, the remake pulls no punches with the game’s themes. I’m so glad it didn’t; I was genuinely worried that the messages and darkness would be watered down. If anything, though, they have more of an emotional impact now with the improved voice acting and graphics.

One specific death sequence stands out. In the initial game, this character’s demise was rather theatrically over-the-top, complete with dramatic wailing, shouting, and a hand extending towards James, as if straight from a daytime drama.

In the reimagined version, there’s a hushed terror where one can almost feel the air leave their bodies after the fatal strike, followed by a moment of stunned silence, as if frozen in time, observing the fading life and light from their eyes until we are certain they have passed away.

It was harrowing.

Silent Hill 2 Remake Review: A Remarkable Return

The remake portrays the hardships and sorrow of the characters more intensely than before, which wasn’t fully captured in the original version. Moreover, it also highlights other heartbreaking events that were part of the game.

In this game, the emotional force of the cutscenes was significantly heightened, as I was already aware of the plot twists and events that took place in different regions and involving various characters (spoilers).

This remake closely follows the original game, yet it repeatedly caught me off guard. It manages to intensify the emotions while preserving the eerie, surreal quality that the scenes often evoke.

Absolutely, Akira Yamaoka’s soundtrack is simply outstanding, enhancing every encounter with a charm that makes listening pleasurable. Many tracks share similarities with their original versions, yet most have been reimagined and are exquisite. This music contributes significantly to the game’s atmosphere and emotional depth, but it’s also captivating enough to be enjoyed independently as standalone pieces.

Despite the significant enhancements and richer narrative added to the remake, what I find most disappointing is the absence of the bonus chapter “Born from a Wish.” This missing piece could have elevated the game to an absolute masterpiece, as it was a vital story element that complemented the overall improvement in the plot and character development.

Despite everything, this game remains extraordinary. It carries a strong and evocative narrative, immersing players in a chilling atmosphere throughout.

Previously suggested, I managed to unlock the “In Water” conclusion due to my overzealous use of healing resources. Interestingly, the method for obtaining this “In Water” result stays faithful to the original gameplay. Despite being a less favorable ending, it left an impression that remains vivid even after the end credits have rolled away.

Closing Comments:

The Silent Hill 2 Remake is a masterclass in psychological horror with an unforgettable atmosphere. The improved graphics, acting, and soundtrack create an authentically horrifying experience that brings pride to the original. Despite some performance issues, new and veteran fans will genuinely love the Silent Hill 2 Remake — it’s absolutely stellar.

Read More

2024-10-14 15:09