In the game called Stardew Valley, players immerse themselves in a world filled with farming and small-town lifestyle. As they progress, they’ll discover various methods of cultivating crops, gathering resources, and crafting items to develop their inherited farm. At some point, farmers are given the option between a cave for Fruit Bats or one for mushrooms. To help decide which is more beneficial in a playthrough, consider this Stardew Valley guide.
To play this section of the game, players must accumulate 25,000G initially. In Stardew Valley, farmers can achieve this by selling resources or valuable crops for a good profit. Once you’ve reached that amount, a villager will appear each morning to offer you an option. This choice determines whether your farm’s cave becomes inhabited by bats or a site for mushroom cultivation. Neither decision significantly alters the game, but there are valid reasons to favor one over the other in certain situations.
How to Unlock the Farm Cave
How to Make 25000g Quickly
Without doubt, you might be curious about the method for unlocking the Farm Cave. To access this location, you will first have to accumulate a grand total of 25000 Gold Coins (or simply 25000g). It’s important to note that you don’t need to possess all 25000g at once; instead, the total amount you’ve earned across your journey will determine if you can unlock it.
In the game, there isn’t a specific achievement that signals when you reach 25,000, but there is indeed the “Greenhorn” achievement awarded at 15,000 gold. This can serve as a helpful guide to let you know how near you are to the target of 25,000 gold.
As a film enthusiast, I’d like to rephrase it for you: If you qualify, Demetrius will drop by tomorrow morning, inquiring if he can access your property’s Farm Cave. Then, a dilemma arises where you’ll need to decide between permitting mushroom collection or granting permission for fruit bats.
If you’re having trouble making the 25000g, then here are some pointers:
- Unless it’s required for the Junimo Bundles at the Community Center, you should be selling everything you grow or catch. Gold-star quality produce and fish sell for more than their no-star counterparts.
- Sell to Pierre and Willy as often as you can. You can use the bin outside your farmhouse, but you won’t get the funds until the following day. Thus, if you’re in a rush to obtain the money, selling them straight up is recommended.
- Once you have a coop and barn, you can start getting eggs and milk. Instead of selling these products as-is, you should turn them into mayonnaise and cheese respectively, then sell them.
After you’ve made up your mind, there’s no going back on that choice. So, if you initially picked fruit bats and later wish to switch to mushrooms during gameplay, unfortunately, you won’t be able to.
Fruit Bats Cave
How Often Does Fruit Spawn?

If you’re aiming to finish the Pantry bundle for the Community Center before winter sets in, I’d strongly suggest visiting the Fruit Bat cave. The Artisan Bundle, which consists of six items, can be fulfilled either with animal products such as Cheese, Goat Cheese, and Truffle Oil or with fruits. Consequently, you could theoretically complete the Artisan Bundle by gathering a single fruit of each type.
Fruit bats are capable of gathering fruits throughout all seasons, so you can potentially find an apple (a fall fruit) even during winter, spring, or summer. The advantage here is that the type of fruit you receive from these bats isn’t predetermined, but you won’t have to wait a full 28 days in-game for a fruit tree sapling to grow before harvesting fruits.
You can get the following fruits from the fruit bat cave:
- Spice Berry
- Blackberry
- Salmonberry
- Wild Plum
- Apple
- Orange
- Peach
- Pomegranate
- Apricot
- Cherry
The drawback when choosing fruit bats is that you might not consistently get your preferred type of fruit. Additionally, it’s best to maintain an empty cave floor since the probability of fruit spawning is influenced by the available space. Fruit has a chance of spawning every night, but there’s also a 48% likelihood of no fruit being produced. Lastly, the usefulness of fruit bats diminishes once you accumulate enough fruits to purchase fruit tree saplings.
Simply put, opting for the Community Center, picking out fruit bats instead of spending money on fruit tree seeds for the Artisan Bundle is a more cost-effective choice.
Mushrooms Cave (Farm)
How Often Do Mushrooms Spawn?
.jpg)
In simpler terms, choosing the mushroom setup will result in six containers being arranged, each producing a mushroom approximately every two days. From the farm cave, you’ll be able to collect several types of mushrooms.
- Common Mushroom
- Chanterelle
- Morel
- Red Mushroom
- Purple Mushroom
While mushrooms aren’t as scarce as fruit, it’s more probable that you’ll gather mushrooms rather than fruit from fruit bats. Yet, mushrooms play a crucial role in brewing the Life Elixir potion, a drink that instantly refills your health gauge when imbibed.
Another advantage of selecting the mushroom cave is that it includes a drying apparatus. In version 1.6, opting for the mushroom cave will also provide you with this device for free, whereas the fruit bat cave offers nothing. This tool is incredibly useful for drying fruits or mushrooms, which can be either sold or given to the raccoons in Cindersap Forest.
The disadvantage of choosing the mushroom cave is that there are numerous simpler methods to cultivate mushrooms. Instead of waiting for growth inside your Farm Cave, you could gather Red and Purple Mushrooms from the mine’s Mushroom Floors, Chanterelles in the Secret Woods during fall, and Morels in spring. Additionally, Common Mushrooms can be found while foraging in the fall season.
Ginger Island Mushroom Cave

Starting with Stardew Valley version 1.5, you can explore Ginger Island once you finish building the Community Center or the Joja Mart project. Once you collect enough Golden Walnuts to fix the bridge leading to the Archaeological Site, you’ll uncover a new cave that generates mushrooms after helping Professor Snail (you’ll need a bomb for this task).
By selecting the mushroom option for your farm cave, there’s a possibility of having not one, but two mushroom caves. If you’d prefer to have only one type of cave, opt for the fruit bats when choosing your farm inhabitants on Ginger Island, as this will provide you with a mushroom cave already.
Read More
- Invincible’s Strongest Female Characters
- Top 8 Weapon Enchantments in Oblivion Remastered, Ranked
- MHA’s Back: Horikoshi Drops New Chapter in ‘Ultra Age’ Fanbook – See What’s Inside!
- Nine Sols: 6 Best Jin Farming Methods
- Fix Oblivion Remastered Crashing & GPU Fatal Errors with These Simple Tricks!
- Top 8 UFC 5 Perks Every Fighter Should Use
- How to Reach 80,000M in Dead Rails
- Gold Rate Forecast
- USD ILS PREDICTION
- Silver Rate Forecast
2025-05-08 08:44