Studio Ghibli’s Lacking Tale: What Made Tales From Earthsea Disappointing

by

Studio Ghibli is a world-renowned anime studio, famous for beloved classics like Spirited Away and My Neighbor Totoro, among many others. For years, fans and critics thought they consistently produced flawless films. However, that perception shifted in 2006 with the release of Tales From Earthsea.

Following the huge success of Howl’s Moving Castle in 2004, many people were surprised by the noticeably lower quality of Studio Ghibli’s next film. Tales From Earthsea didn’t seem to have the same magic as Studio Ghibli’s previous work, leading both viewers and critics to react negatively. What went wrong with Tales From Earthsea, and what impact did it have on the studio?

What Did Critics and Fans Dislike About Tales From Earthsea?

Studio Ghibli films are consistently praised for their beautiful animation, well-developed characters, and emotionally resonant stories. However, many fans and critics feel that Tales From Earthsea didn’t live up to these standards, and that’s a primary reason why it disappointed viewers.

Lacking Plot Line and Characters

Tales From Earthsea centers on Prince Arren’s journey after he kills his father. He travels with the powerful wizard, Sparrowhawk, but the movie is slow to start. For the first hour or so, there’s little action and the characters’ reasons for doing things aren’t very clear. We don’t learn exactly why Arren killed his father, Sparrowhawk’s goals are vague, and the background of Therru remains a mystery.

The story becomes confusing when Arren, controlled by Cob, reveals his real name is Lebannen. This feels sudden, as there was no prior indication he’d been using an alias. Cob’s origins are also unclear, leaving viewers questioning how he obtained the ability to control life and death. While it’s mentioned he desires immortality, his motivations and connection to Sparrowhawk remain a mystery.

The friendships between the characters also feel a little hurried. For example, Therru initially dislikes Arren and tries to avoid him, but they quickly become close – so close that Arren confesses to killing his father. Many viewers felt these relationships would have been stronger if they’d been developed more gradually and naturally, similar to how they’re handled in other Studio Ghibli films.

Couldn’t Capture The Original Spirit of the Books

The biggest issue with Tales From Earthsea is its hurried pace, which stems from trying to fit the stories of three separate novels into one film.

  • A Wizard of Earthsea
  • The Farthest Shore
  • Tehanu

I’ve been reading Ursula K. Le Guin’s work, and it’s fascinating to learn she herself feels Tales From Earthsea doesn’t quite hit the mark of what she intended with the books. What I’ve noticed is the movie really emphasizes action, whereas the books are much more focused on inner thoughts and feelings.

The movie would have been better if it hadn’t tried to cover so much material at once. By attempting to adapt three books into a single film, the story felt very rushed, resulting in a confusing and difficult-to-follow plot.

How Did Studio Ghibli Regain Its Reputation?

Returned With More Instant Classics

Following the disappointing response to Tales From Earthsea, fans started to lose confidence in Studio Ghibli. Up until that point, the studio had consistently delivered beloved and highly-regarded films, including:

  • Princess Mononoke
  • Spirited Away
  • Howl’s Moving Castle

Studio Ghibli fans are very familiar with their classic films, so Tales From Earthsea didn’t resonate with many of them. Fortunately, the studio quickly recognized a problem and fixed it in their next movie.

Many of Studio Ghibli’s earlier successes were directed by Hayao Miyazaki, so when his son, Goro Miyazaki, took the helm of Tales From Earthsea, it didn’t quite reach the same heights. Studio Ghibli realized Goro needed more experience, and they brought Hayao back to direct the popular film Ponyo in 2008.

I was really worried after Tales From Earthsea didn’t quite connect with people. It felt like a tough spot for Goro Miyazaki, but thankfully, he got some extra support and guidance before his next project. And it showed! From Up on Poppy Hill, released in 2011, was a much bigger hit, and you could really see how much his directing had improved. While Tales From Earthsea definitely hurt Studio Ghibli’s reputation a little, they bounced back quickly, and thankfully, continued to make amazing films that we all love.

Read More

2026-02-12 23:09