The Most Evil Decisions In The Witcher 3

Key Takeaways

Geralt’s decisions in
The Witcher 3
can have significant consequences on the story and his relationships with other characters.
Players face morally questionable choices such as refusing Ciri’s wishes, betraying allies, or releasing dangerous entities for personal gain.
The game challenges players with nuanced dilemmas, showcasing the complex and morally ambiguous nature of the fantasy world.

As a seasoned Witcher and someone who has seen more than his fair share of sorrow, I must say that these quests in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt are as dark and twisty as the paths one treads in the vast lands of the Continent.

The third installment in “The Witcher” series, titled “The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt,” is renowned as one of the greatest open-world RPGs ever made, and rightfully so. This game offers a vast and stunningly beautiful landscape for players to lose themselves in for countless hours, along with an intriguing narrative that places you in the role of Geralt, who must reunite his ‘family’ while simultaneously combating the looming threat of the Wild Hunt – an elite force of Aen Elle elves disguised as wraiths and spirits.

In The Witcher 3, the protagonist isn’t your typical role-playing game character because Geralt of Rivia is already predefined. He has a distinct personality and was previously featured in a series of books, which gives him a set moral code. Unlike characters in other RPGs that you create yourself, Geralt’s decisions aren’t as free-roaming as those, and he can sometimes make choices that are morally ambiguous or even borderline evil. However, it’s important to note that Geralt is generally portrayed as a good character.

8 Refusing To Pay A Visit To Skjall

Denying Ciri An Opportunity

The Most Evil Decisions In The Witcher 3

In the game, Skjall is a secondary character who experiences an unfortunate end. After Geralt and Yennefer journey to Skellige in search of Ciri, they stumble upon a devastated village, left in ruins by the Wild Hunt. Here, they hear tales of the Craven, a young man who forsook his people, bringing shame upon him at death. Yet, it soon becomes clear that he deserted them to safeguard Ciri.

After learning of Skjall’s passing, Ciri yearns to pay her respects at his grave. Geralt could choose to console her and accompany her, or he might harshly refuse her request. This action deeply saddens Ciri and contributes to a bleak outcome, straining the bond between her and Geralt, as well as depriving players of the chance to find closure about the past.

7 Killing The Baron’s Child

Forcing The Stillborn To Suffer

In this intricate and ethically ambiguous tale within the game, known as “The Bloody Baron” questline, themes of abuse and loss are explored. Geralt unintentionally gets entangled in the tragic saga of a fractured family. At a certain juncture, he’s given the option to unearth the Baron’s deceased child, using it as a means to track down his wife and daughter.

One approach could be to transform the child destined to become a botchling into a helpful spirit that leads the Witcher on his journey. Players, however, have the option to kill the child, which, although it may be crucial, leaves the father deeply traumatized and causes him additional pain.

6 Accepting The Payment For Ciri

Making A Fool Of Geralt

Instead of bringing Ciri to meet Emhyr var Emreys before pursuing Imlerith in Velen, the player has an option. Should they choose to do so, they’ll encounter another decision: Whether or not to accept the coin that Emhyr offered for finding Ciri. If Geralt declines the coin, Ciri feels extremely proud.

If Geralt takes the coin, Ciri perceives it as being traded to the Emperor, which she sees as a betrayal by Geralt. The scene is drawn out while the coin is being tallied, seeming designed to demean Geralt and provoke remorse in the player about this decision. This choice leads to an unfavorable ending for Ciri at the culmination of the main storyline.

5 Forcing The Godling Out

Refusing The Peaceful Solution

While Geralt was in Novigrad, he turned to a woman named Corinne Tilly for aid, but encountered an issue: She was tormented by relentless nightmares. The Witcher embarked on a quest to uncover the cause and discovered it was a Godling named Sarah who was behind them. Now residing in Corinne’s household, Sarah was the one summoning these dreams.

In this scenario, The Witcher has the option to converse with her and devise a tranquil resolution, or alternatively, force her out by employing some burdock. Regardless of the choice made, Sarah exits the house and heads towards the marsh, hurling insults at Geralt for his thoughtlessness and tactlessness in choosing the more aggressive route when a peaceful solution was feasible.

4 Choosing Both Triss And Yen

Adultery

As a gamer immersed in this captivating world, Yennefer and Triss are two intriguing love interests that captivate my heart. Each player may have their personal leanings and justifications for favoring one over the other. Yet, what makes this game truly unique is the option to confess my feelings to both of them during their individual quests, a choice that initially sparks hope. However, as I navigate through the storyline, it becomes apparent that Geralt’s path with these two women isn’t destined for a cheerful resolution.

As Geralt prepares for his journey to Skellige, he receives a surprising proposition: a threesome with Yennefer and Triss. However, instead of joining them, they bind him to a bed and abandon him for the night. Later, Dandelion arrives to free him. Although Geralt has the chance to commit infidelity and hurt both Triss and Yen, his actions lead to him being left alone in the end.

3 Freeing The Tree Spirit

Aiding An Ancient Evil

When Geralt meets the Crone sisters, they assign him a mission to eliminate an ancient menace concealed beneath an antique tree. Later on, when Geralt unearths this beast, he receives an offer: To liberate the spirit from its cage and let it go, enabling it to save the children that the Crone sisters intend to consume, followed by the spirit taking its vengeance.

As the spirit honors its pledge by liberating the children, it simultaneously destroys the neighboring village and all its inhabitants. It remains at large, posing a threat with no chance to restrain it later on, implying that Geralt released a highly perilous entity in return for just a few lives being spared, which raises concerns about the wisdom of his decision.

2 Dooming Olgierd

Condemn A Soul To Torture

In the gripping world of “Hearts of Stone,” I found myself embroiled in the life of a complex character named Olgierd von Everec. At first glance, he seemed cold-hearted and ruthless, a warlord with a dark past that includes harming his own kin. But as I delved deeper into his story, I discovered the intricate web of circumstances that shaped him. His dealings with the enigmatic Gaunter O’Dimm unfolded layer upon layer, revealing a man who, despite his flaws, was more than just a warlord.

At the end of the expansion, you encounter Olgierd at a hidden location where Gaunter attempts to claim his soul. You have the option to help Olgierd break free from his curse, allowing him a chance for redemption, or step back and let Gaunter subject Olgierd to an eternity of pain and torment.

1 Killing Keira Metz

Slaughtering A Friend

Keira Metz is a companion to Geralt, Triss, and Yen in the books. She becomes a character you interact with in Velen, where she has a story-driven mission assigned to her. One of these missions involves exploring the Tower of Mice and assisting her in locating some old sorcerer’s notes. This quest could potentially result in a romantic encounter between Geralt and her.

In the end, instead of working together, Keira resorts to taking notes from Geralt and leaving him behind. This leads to a confrontation between them, and if Geralt behaves impolitely and antagonizes Keira, they engage in a fight where Geralt kills one of his companions, losing a valuable ally for himself, over an issue that could have been resolved amicably.

2024-10-14 13:34