The Walking Dead Needs to Get Grimy Like This Netflix Show!

by

Summary

  • The Walking Dead lacks realism, characters appear too clean for an apocalyptic setting, undermining authenticity.
  • American Primeval excels in gritty realism, characters reflect harsh frontier life, enhancing storytelling immersion.
  • Realism plays a crucial role in enhancing audience engagement in storytelling, The Walking Dead could learn from Netflix.

For years, AMC’s “The Walking Dead” has been a go-to for apocalyptic storytelling, gripping viewers with its harrowing narratives about surviving among hoards of the undead. However, as time went on, some spectators started to observe that the show’s visual style didn’t always align with its grim narrative. Characters in “The Walking Dead” seemed unusually clean for people who were supposedly living without access to modern comforts. On the other hand, Netflix’s “American Primeval” has significantly enhanced gritty realism by portraying frontier life accurately.

American Primeval powerfully demonstrates the impact of meticulous detail in creating an immersive experience, by fully embracing the gritty and chaotic atmosphere of its environment. The Walking Dead might benefit from adopting similar techniques to better portray its intended harshness.

The Walking Dead Isn’t Grungy Enough

In the series The Walking Dead, there’s no shortage of gripping action, tension, and bloodshed. However, it occasionally falters in a significant aspect: authentic visual presentation. Despite the world being portrayed as ravaged by decades of apocalyptic ruin, the characters’ appearances often contradict this concept. Granted, at times a character might have dirt smeared on their face or their clothes appear tattered, but these instances often come across as deliberately designed costumes rather than realistic outcomes of their surroundings.

To illustrate the later stages of the series, characters such as Michonne, Rick, and Daryl are portrayed as seasoned survivors who have endured numerous battles to stay alive. However, despite their hard-scrabble existence, they seem unusually well-groomed. Their hair may be purposefully messy, but it retains an unexpected level of styling, hinting at the presence of a barber or hairstylist in this post-salon world. Additionally, while their skin is soiled, it appears as though a skilled makeup artist has carefully applied dirt and grime to them. This minor inconsistency casts doubt on the show’s commitment to maintaining authenticity within its premise.

The Walking Dead
Showrunner
  • Frank Darabont (season 1)
  • Glen Mazzara (seasons 2–3)
  • Scott M. Gimple (seasons 4–8)
  • Angela Kang (seasons 9–11)
Developed By Frank Darabont
Starring
  • Andrew Lincoln
  • Jon Bernthal
  • Sarah Wayne Callies
  • Laurie Holden
  • Jeffrey DeMunn
  • Steven Yeun
  • Chandler Riggs
  • Norman Reedus
  • Lauren Cohan
  • Danai Gurira
  • Melissa McBride
  • Scott Wilson
  • Michael Cudlitz
  • Jeffrey Dean Morgan
  • Khary Payton

In a world where soap is hard to come by, laundry often gets neglected, and maintaining personal cleanliness feels like a privilege, one might assume the characters would appear noticeably unkempt. However, if the clothing of these characters lacks realistic dirt, bloodstains, or signs of wear, it can disrupt the immersive quality of the show, making viewers aware that they’re watching a TV production instead of a believable post-apocalyptic setting.

American Primeval Shows How It’s Done

Instead, the TV series American Primeval immerses viewers in the raw, unflinching truth of its frontier backdrop. This western production presents a world where life is gritty, violent, and unyieldingly bleak. Characters’ physical aspects mirror the merciless environment they dwell in. Caked with dirt and bloodstains, they seem to have survived every moment of their brutal lives.

American Primeval
Director Peter Berg
Writer Mark L. Smith
Starring
  • Taylor Kitsch
  • Betty Gilpin
  • Dane DeHaan
  • Saura Lightfoot-Leon
  • Derek Hinkey
  • Joe Tippett
  • Jai Courtney
  • Preston Mota
  • Shawnee Pourier
  • Shea Whigham

This dedication to authenticity transcends mere visual appeal; it significantly strengthens the narrative. In the novel “American Primeval“, when a character sustains an injury, persistent bloodstains and ripped garments evoke the challenges they face, heightening the importance of their journey for viewers. The constant grime and sweat on their faces underscore the harshness of their surroundings, making their survival seem more deserved. This meticulous attention to detail immerses audiences further into the story, enabling them to experience the hardships alongside the characters.

Furthermore, American Primeval doesn’t hesitate to portray the effects of its characters’ actions. Be it a fierce battle or a strenuous journey through the wilderness, the strain is clearly seen on their physiques and attire. This method not only makes the world seem more authentic but also intensifies the emotional resonance of the narrative. When characters appear battered and bruised, their triumphs feel more rewarding, and their defeats land harder.

Why Realism Matters

In order for audiences to fully immerse themselves in the narrative of “The Walking Dead”, a sense of realism is vital as it makes the world seem more authentic. The deeper this authenticity, the more viewers can empathize with the characters and their hardships. Neglecting the grittier survival aspects might lead to a disconnection between the series and its audience.

American Primeval showcases how embracing authenticity can intensify a series’ influence. The characters appear as if they have genuinely endured the hardships they encounter, which adds a layer of realism that makes their narratives more profoundly relatable. A series like The Walking Dead might gain from adopting a similar strategy, especially in depicting the harsh effects of its post-apocalyptic environment.

The Walking Dead” might find improvement by adopting a comparable strategy, especially in depicting the harsh physical impact of its post-apocalyptic environment.

If characters from “The Walking Dead” were given the freedom to appear as gritty and gory as those in “American Primeval,” it could inject fresh vitality into the series’ visual style. This transformation might result in Rick’s beard no longer symbolizing merely ruggedness but also a tangled, muddy, and bloodstained mass. Similarly, Carol’s meticulously constructed survivalist persona could be disrupted by the harsh realities of long-term travel, making the show’s tales seem more raw and impactful. These alterations wouldn’t only make the series appear more authentic; they would also make its narratives feel more intense and immediate.

Ultimately, both “The Walking Dead” and “American Primeval” strive to narrate tales of survival amidst harsh environments. However, “American Primeval” pushes boundaries with its authentic grittiness, establishing a new benchmark for realistic portrayal. If “The Walking Dead” learns from Netflix’s approach, it could rekindle the rough, intense feeling that characterized its initial seasons. Remember, in a world swarming with the undead, there’s no place for polished lines or delicate grime.

Read More

2025-01-20 17:24