Why Adding New Straw Hats Could Ruin One Piece’s Iconic Crew

by

Summary

  • The Straw Hat crew is complete with 10 members, each fulfilling a crucial role on the ship.
  • Adding new members at this stage of the series would be unnecessary and disrupt the crew’s dynamic.
  • Potential future Straw Hats include Vivi, Carrot, Yamato, and even Loki, but fans debate who will join.

In the world of anime, it’s hard to find a hero group as recognizable as the Straw Hats. At the current stage in the One Piece narrative, if any of them were to face trouble, the crew would undeniably lose its unique charm. Each member plays a distinct role on the ship, and their absence would significantly alter how the pirate crew operates. Although some roles might seem more crucial than others, each one is essential for the smooth functioning of the team.

Throughout their travels, Luffy and his companions have encountered numerous individuals who have subsequently joined their crew. Consequently, Luffy has frequently pledged to many potential recruits a permanent position on board in the future. This has sparked endless fan speculation about who might be the final member of the Straw Hat crew. However, some fans argue that the Straw Hats should not accept any new members, so let’s discuss the reasons behind this viewpoint.

A Complete Crew For The Future Pirate King

Luffy’s Crew Is Full For Now

Straw Hat’s Captain Monkey D. Luffy
First To Join Roronoa Zoro
Latest To Join Jinbei

At the onset of the One Piece narrative, a naive and enterprising youth named Monkey D. Luffy embarked on an ocean voyage with just a simple straw hat as his possession. He had no specific destination or purpose in mind, but he was driven by the ambition to be crowned Pirate King and to assemble a crew that would aid him in achieving this goal.

Over time, I stumbled upon Zoro and Nami, the duo who would later become my trusted comrades and core members of our Straw Hat Pirates crew. With humble beginnings, we set sail on an unforgettable journey that transformed us into one of the world’s most notorious and powerful crews, with me, Luffy, at the helm – now recognized as the newest Emperor of the Sea. However, adding a new member to our crew always presents a challenge, for we must ensure they share our spirit and can contribute to our shared dream.

Initially, in several early scenes from the “One Piece” comic, Luffy expressed his ambition to establish a substantial pirate gang that would serve as a newfound family for him. Specifically, he believed that a group of 10 members was ideal, as this made it a true team. As things stand now, there are currently 10 members in the Straw Hat Pirates crew, which means Luffy’s dream has come to fruition while also aligning with Oda’s original concept for the team.

Above all, each crew member currently aboard the pirate ship plays a specific part, though some roles might appear less significant than others, they are all indispensable for the crew to function optimally. According to the narrative presented so far, every position on the pirate ship has been accounted for, and no further additions are needed. Here’s how the roles break down:

1. The Captain, who leads the crew and makes important decisions.
2. The Quartermaster, responsible for navigation and map reading.
3. The Boatswain (or Bosun), in charge of maintaining the ship and managing the crew.
4. The Gunner, who handles the cannons and their ammunition.
5. The Cook, who prepares meals for the crew.
6. The Surgeon, responsible for treating injuries and illnesses among the crew.
7. The Lookout, tasked with scanning the horizon for approaching ships or other threats.
8. The Cabin Boy (or Swabbie), a junior member of the crew who performs general duties such as cleaning and fetching supplies.
9. The Marauders, the fighters who defend the ship and attack enemy vessels during boarding actions.
10. The Pirate King, an influential figure among the pirates who commands respect from the rest of the crew.

  1. Captain – Luffy
  2. First Mate – Zoro
  3. Navigator – Nami
  4. Cook – Sanji
  5. Sniper – Usopp
  6. Doctor – Chopper
  7. Archaeologist – Robin
  8. Shipwright – Franky
  9. Helmsman – Jinbei
  10. Musician – Brook

A pirate crew is like a family!

It appears that the pirate crew currently has all they need, according to fans. Adding more members wouldn’t benefit the crew significantly and could only prolong encounters with friends made along the journey. While this scenario sounds enjoyable for character interactions, it seems illogical from a practical perspective.

Furthermore, it’s worth noting that “One Piece” is currently in its Final Saga, making the end of the series more imminent than ever before. Given this, introducing a new crew member at this juncture might not bring much novelty, as they would likely have limited time to interact with others and their presence could primarily serve fan service. Moreover, there are numerous possibilities regarding who could be the final crew member, which makes adding another character seem somewhat unfair towards fans of the existing characters.

Who Are The Potential Future Straw Hats?

Many Candidates Exist

For years, there’s been much discussion about who will be the final member of the Straw Hat crew, a role some think is still unclaimed. The most likely candidate appears to be Nefeltari Vivi, who spent significant time with the crew during crucial arcs but left to fulfill her duties as Princess of Alabasta. However, many speculate that other characters like Carrot and Yamato also have equal chances for this role.

In essence, Carrot spent approximately the same duration as Vivi and Yamato with the Straw Hat crew before her arrival, yet Yamato delayed joining due to safeguarding Momonosuke, who was suggested as a future team member. Interestingly, numerous fans speculate that Loki might eventually join the crew too, given indications that he may not be entirely villainous and could ultimately become a hero by the end of the Elbaf saga.

One Piece can be streamed on Crunchyroll.

Read More

2025-02-22 17:57