Why Bringing Ace Back Would Ruin One Piece Forever

Summary

Ace’s death marked a turning point for Luffy and the series.
Reviving Ace could undo emotional development.
One Piece lacks consequences due to characters surviving impossible situations.

In the universe of One Piece, death has been a thought-provoking topic due to its scarcity. Characters who find themselves in life-threatening situations, even when their circumstances seem dire, tend to survive and remain significant figures in the narrative. This consistent survival rate often leaves fans displeased, as they feel it undermines the intensity of perilous encounters involving the Straw Hats or other key characters, since it seems that no one’s life is truly at risk.

In the world of One Piece, a handful of characters have met their end thus far. Among these, the death of Ace stands out as one of the most poignant moments in the show. Though some viewers seemed to find solace in such an impactful event, others were left devastated, as they had grown particularly fond of this character. As a result, there are those who fervently wish for Ace’s resurrection before the series concludes, so he can be reunited with his brothers once more.

Ace’s Death Marked A Turning Point For Luffy And The Series

His Death Was A Shock That Changed One Piece

From the very beginning of the “One Piece” series, despite its frequent exploration of more serious themes, the demise of a character within the ongoing narrative has rarely been depicted. In fact, it’s quite common for characters who appear to have perished to miraculously survive, even in instances where their survival seems illogical. A striking instance of this pattern is the character Pell during the Alabasta Arc. After giving his life and detonating a colossal bomb, somehow Pell managed to endure the subsequent explosion.

I’m sorry you didn’t get to save me… – Ace

Later in the Marineford Arc of the series, two significant characters, Ace and Whitebeard, met a permanent end. The demise of Ace, happening rather abruptly, was deeply shocking for fans to experience. Unlike earlier deaths in the series, there was no room for speculation about their survival because both characters died on screen, leaving no doubt in the minds of the audience.

Could Ace Come Back To Life?

This Undo A Lot Of The Emotional Development Of The Series

Killing Ace Was An Important Event In The Series
Going Back On This Would Reinforce Some Of One Piece’s Worst Criticism

Although Ace’s death is undeniably one of the most significant events in the series and plays a crucial role in Luffy’s growth as a character, there are some fans who speculate that Ace might be resurrected before the series concludes. This idea stems from the belief that a fragment of the One Piece treasure, or another enigmatic aspect related to Joy Boy and Laugh Tale, could grant Ace a second life. If this were to happen, it would reunite the three brothers – Ace, Luffy, and Sabo – who would then potentially become significant figures in the upcoming age of pirates that Luffy is expected to initiate.

Many people within the community believe that bringing back Ace could be among the poorest decisions made by One Piece. Primarily, Ace’s death served as a pivotal moment in Luffy’s development, introducing an emotional dimension to his character that hadn’t been seen before. Resurrecting Ace would reverse this growth, allowing him to revert to his less mature emotional states, given that death wouldn’t seem like a genuine consequence. Furthermore, Ace’s death is one of the few major deaths in the series, and reversing it might give the impression that One Piece lacks meaningful consequences for perilous situations.

Giving Luffy A Final Conversation With Ace Could Be Okay

The One Piece Treasure Could Have The Power To Do Something Like This

Instead of Luffy having a direct means of communication with his deceased brother, let’s consider a scenario where the One Piece treasure has an unusual property: it allows Luffy and Ace to communicate across time or space. This way, they could have meaningful conversations that would add emotional depth without diminishing Ace’s final words’ impact.

Thank you… for loving me!! – Ace

Although discussing death can be a sensitive issue among fans, resurrecting Ace might not be the wisest move for “One Piece.” While there are alternative storylines, it seems more fitting to let Ace’s character remain as a reminder of the reality of death in the “One Piece” world.

2025-04-06 04:06